Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

dogholes

Posts

dogholes

#1

dogholes

Joey

>I've just finished putting two vises on my workbench that probably took me three years to finish. I wasn't working on it everyday. My goal now is to place 3/4" round dogholes in the top. I need advise as to the safest and cleanest way to accomplish this, eg. router, drill. Not only the tool but a guide for it, so my holes are in a straight line. Placement in reference to both vises and also for convenience of use would be helpful. One other thing, should I drill a doghole in the vise if the holes don't line up with the vises own dog? Thank You Joe


img

Re: dogholes

#2

Re: dogholes

Hank Knight

>Joey,

Nice looking leg joints!

I had the same concerns you have when I put the dog holes in my bench. I made a jig that screwed to the base of my plunge router. It placed the dog holes a constant distance from the edge of the bench and indexed the space between the holes from the previously drilled dog hole. I started the dog holes with a 3/4" spiral router bit and finished them with a 3/4" brad point bit in my hand drill (the router bit wasn't long enough to go through my 3" thick bench top). The initial hole from the plunge router was clean and deep enough to guide the drill bit and keep it vertical. I clamped a backer-board to the bottom of the bench top to prevent tear out. I finished each hole with a small chamfer using a single-flute chamfer bit from Lee Valley. Once I got the jig built, the whole process went quickly.

My $.02.

Hank

Re: dogholes

#3

Re: Reference router jig

Joey

>Hank; Thanks for the complement. I found those joints in Scott Landis's Workbench Book. That 3/4" spiral bit sounds like the answer. Who makes that bad boy? The jig that referenced off the previous hole, had a 3/4" dowel placed in it and a fence along the edge? Thanks again for the tip. Joey

Re: dogholes

#4

how I drilled mine

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I drilled (drill press to ensure straight) a 3/4" hole in a 2 1/2 thick piece of oak and used it for a drill guide. It was no trouble centering the hole in this guide on marks for the holes placed on the bench. I clamped a block on the bottom of the bench to prevent the exit from splitting when the drill came through. I used a common auger type bit with a lead screw powered by my 1/2" portable electric drill.

I spaced the holes 4" near the vise and every 6" after the first foot- 4, 4, 4, 6, 6, 6,etc. Near the vise I drilled one off-set hole to accommodate one of those crook necked things you pound on to hold stuff down whose name temporarily escapes me. They go through the bench and hit the vise screw so an off-set is necessary to use them near the vise edge.

Re: dogholes

#5

Re: how I drilled mine

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I would think you would space the holes slightly less distance apart than the total travel of the vise jaws. This would let you use the full range of the vise all the way across the table, without having to put a shim board between the dog and the work piece.

Lee - who's still trying to figure out how to fit a work bench into his shop...

Re: dogholes

#6

I let the work tell me

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>where it wants a hole, and that's where it goes.

Clint


img

Re: dogholes

#7

Re: I let the work tell me

Fred Davis

>

Re: dogholes

#8

Re: dogholes

Fred Davis

>Joey ,

that is a nice looking and strong leg connection.

I cut my "Bench Pups " holes cleanly with a Forstner bit in a Portalign tool I used to keep the bit plumb and control the depth.

Look at shopshot 876 and you can see if you look close the general idea, layout would be what suits your needs.

I personally thought about it for years and used a double row of holes in front of each vise.

Combined with the vise dog , they accomodate a endless variety of clamping applications.

FredD

Re: dogholes

#9

Be careful

Ellis Walentine, Host

>A 3/4" up-spiral bit can ruin your whole day (not to mention your workpiece) if it bites too quickly and self-feeds itself into the benchtop. Personally, I avoid this type of cut with a bit that size.

Ellis

Re: dogholes

#10

Dogholes the safe way *LINK*

Bricofleur

>Your workbench is awesome! Congrats. This is high level of craftmanship.

Follow this link leading the my website where I describe step by step the way I made mine... on a very very very humble MDF benchtop with a simple jig.

I believe this method is fool proof.

Best

Serge

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com


img

Boring bench dogs holes

Re: dogholes

#11

Re: Thank You, Merci beau coup

joey

>

Re: dogholes

#12

Re: Bienvenu - You're welcome

Bricofleur

>Bienvenu - You're welcome

�a m'a fait plaisir - My pleasure

Best,

Serge

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com

Re: dogholes

#13

Re: Be careful

Hank Knight

>Ellis,

If I'd seen your post before I drilled my dog holes, I probably would have looked for a different approach. As it was, I had no trouble at all with my router method. It never occurred to me that it might be a dangerous technique, otherwise I wouldn't have suggested it - or at least I would have included a word of caution. I've thought about what you said and I can see where the router could get out of hand with a big spiral bit. I think my jig was the reason mine worked so smoothly. The router was fixed to the jig with screws through the base. The jig was made of solid Baltic Birch plywood and securely clamped to the bench top so it couldn't go anywhere. I used a brand new spiral bit (from Lee Valley) so it was sharp - no grabbing. No problem.

Hank

Re: dogholes

#14

No foul, no harm -- spiral bit cautions

Ellis Walentine, Host

>No worries, Hank. I think I just saw an opportunity to remind people (or clue them in) as to the special cutting properties of spiral cutters. Spiral bits are like steep-pitched screws, only they're traveling at between 10K and 24K rpm! You know how fast your cordless driver sinks a screw at 100rpm or less, so just imagine the velocity of that bit if it is allowed to pull itself into a board at 20K!

Like most hard-earned woodworking wisdom, this epiphany didn't come to me out of the clear blue. When I ran a custom shop, I had a 1,500 lb, 40's-vintage Porter pin router that I used for all kinds of shaping and routing chores. One day, I started a pattern-routing job with a 1/2" up-spiral bit. My workpiece was fully fixtured into a pattern jig, with several De-Sta-Co clamps holding it in place. I figured I was okay. Not! As soon as that bit contacted the workpiece (maybe I plunged it a little too fast, I'm not sure), the bit sucked up the workpiece, jig and all, in far less than a heartbeat (more like 1/300 of a second, faster than a tablesaw kickback). It was ugly and I was lucky I wasn't hurt. Since then, I've always thought through any spiral cutting operations prior to actually putting cutter to wood or vice versa. The key is to have a limiting force on the workpiece when routing into it. A hand-held router is much safer than an overarm router in this regard, since it has a baseplate that limits the travel of the bit.

Downward spirals have the opposite effect; their action pushes the workpiece away from the router. I used them mostly for routing grooves for inlay and such, where tearout at the edge of the cut was not acceptable. Usually the pushing action isn't a problem, but each situation should be considered carefully.

Ellis

Re: dogholes

#15

Re: Ellis, Hank, Brico and all...

Joey, New Canaan, Ct.

>I just made my first dog hole, perfectly. I used a 1/2" upcut spiral, then a 3/4" plunge, finishing with a 3/4" twist drill bit. Thanks again. The bench top 10'X 29" took a lot of sweat, not to do over. Joey from Badger Pond days.

Re: dogholes

#16

Re: Ellis, Hank, Brico and all...

Hank Knight

>Cool! Glad it worked for you. I was worried that I might have led you astray.

Hank

Re: dogholes

#17

Re: Ellis, Hank, Brico and all...

Bricofleur

>Great! One hole at a time, all the way down.

Joey, would you also say it's a fool proof method of doing it?

Best,

Serge

PS: Thanks Ellis, I didn't even know 3/4" spiral bits exist.

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com