No foul, no harm -- spiral bit cautions
Ellis Walentine, Host
>No worries, Hank. I think I just saw an opportunity to remind people (or clue them in) as to the special cutting properties of spiral cutters. Spiral bits are like steep-pitched screws, only they're traveling at between 10K and 24K rpm! You know how fast your cordless driver sinks a screw at 100rpm or less, so just imagine the velocity of that bit if it is allowed to pull itself into a board at 20K!
Like most hard-earned woodworking wisdom, this epiphany didn't come to me out of the clear blue. When I ran a custom shop, I had a 1,500 lb, 40's-vintage Porter pin router that I used for all kinds of shaping and routing chores. One day, I started a pattern-routing job with a 1/2" up-spiral bit. My workpiece was fully fixtured into a pattern jig, with several De-Sta-Co clamps holding it in place. I figured I was okay. Not! As soon as that bit contacted the workpiece (maybe I plunged it a little too fast, I'm not sure), the bit sucked up the workpiece, jig and all, in far less than a heartbeat (more like 1/300 of a second, faster than a tablesaw kickback). It was ugly and I was lucky I wasn't hurt. Since then, I've always thought through any spiral cutting operations prior to actually putting cutter to wood or vice versa. The key is to have a limiting force on the workpiece when routing into it. A hand-held router is much safer than an overarm router in this regard, since it has a baseplate that limits the travel of the bit.
Downward spirals have the opposite effect; their action pushes the workpiece away from the router. I used them mostly for routing grooves for inlay and such, where tearout at the edge of the cut was not acceptable. Usually the pushing action isn't a problem, but each situation should be considered carefully.
Ellis