Something is too wet
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>First let us dismiss the species issue. Whilte oak is not more prone to doing these sorts of things than anything else. Yes, it requires more care drying than pine but kiln operators know how to reliably dry white oak to furniture making standards.
Cupping 1/4" on a 3" board is extreme!
What is the source of this lumber? We sold lumber for almost 30 years. Once we tried a new supplier, a small kiln operator (also a new, small kiln operator as it turned out). Lumber seemed good and we delivered some to a customer. I was by the shop a few days later and glanced at the delivered stack which they had yet to use. The top boards had cupped up about 1/2", an alarming sign that the lumber was wet. I gathered it up and returned with lumber from a reliable supplier. The wet lumber measured 16% MC, far above something that could be worked for cabinetry. To my knowledge we never got under dried lumber from a large kiln operation. If you dried this lumber yourself, then it clearly isn't.
The only way lumber cups standing around is gain or loss of moisture. So, either the lumber was extremely dry and it was moved to a very damp location and only exposed on one side as it regained moisture OR this lumber was very wet by furniture standards and it is loosing moisture from only one side. If you lay a piece on the bench for a few days and the edges curl up then the lumber is wet and unsuitable for the task at hand.
Wet oak gives off a sharp odor when sawed, kinda burns the nose. The saw dust will feel wet, not dry and fluffy.