Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

OT new heat pump

Posts

OT new heat pump

#1

OT new heat pump

John Veerkamp,Western Mo

>I am getting ready to replace a 23 year old Lennox heat pump. I'm getting bids on Lennox, Trane nad Carrier. I'm looking at 16 seer units, 4 ton capacity. I need advice and any experience on these systems before I make a committment. I live about 50 miles south of KC mo. Our cooling load is slightly greater than the heating load.

Any advice and warnings will be greatly appreciated.

Thanks,

John

Re: OT new heat pump

#2

Re: OT new heat pump

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I had a two stage system installed in my 2400sf shop/studio about 5 years ago. Carrier I think, but I don't think that makes a difference.It has performed well. A programmable thermostat is worth while.

Clint

Re: OT new heat pump

#3

JL

Re: OT new heat pump

JL

>I went with a dual fuel when I replaced mine. I like the warm toasty feeling of the furnace (when necessary). I don't think the resistive heating strips alone are that economical (unless your electrical rates are very low).

The combine heating/air conditioning bill is much less - even with the increases in energy prices this past year. I've got an Amana - but I don't know if brand is that important - so long as you go with a major manufacturer.

Re: OT new heat pump

#4

Re: OT new heat pump

Barry Irby

>All Good brands. As a Home Inspector I can not tell that any brand is significantly better than any other. I would stick with plain Jane units and avoid exotica. Take the money you save and spend it on making the house more energy efficient. Storm windows, added attic insulation, air sealing, caulk, etc.

Re: OT new heat pump

#5

What was the efficiency/age of the one replaced?

Joe Pack

>I'm curious, JL...do you know the rated efficiency and the age of the furnace you replaced? I'm curious how much difference in efficiency affects actual energy costs in order to figure payback.

Re: OT new heat pump

#6

Re: OT new heat pump

Fred Davis

>Barry makes some good points, and I would add , at least everywhere I have lived , the local utility company is up to speed on the latest and best approach ,given any situation.

They are free of the tendency of HVAC contractors and appliance stores to recommend what they sell.

FredD

Re: OT new heat pump

#7

Re: OT new heat pump

Ron Jones

>Be sure to check with your utility company about rebates on certain units. Here the rebate is determined by efficiency, not brand IIRC.

Re: OT new heat pump

#8

Re: OT new heat pump

Dave Paine

>Your post may be a little premature for my response. Next week (24th) I am due to have my 3Ton York heat pump circa 1996 replaced with a Trane XL16i 4Ton system. The calcs said I need a tad over 3 ton, but the XL16i only comes in integer ton ratings. Hence the 4 ton.

A few weeks from now I may be able to advise how it is working.

I am hoping the two stage compressor means it will operate better in lower heat/AC days, meaning will run longer before turning off.

Asking which brand is better is a common question. Not finding a single answer is also common. From my own research, each manufacturer has more than 1 brand for nominally the same features. The brand alters the price, and warranty.

A major difference of responses appears to be in the installation. The latest refrigeratant allowed by the government standards runs at much higher pressures, so a slight leak means the refrigerant will disipate sooner, and be more costly to replace.

Pays-your-money-and-takes-your-choice.

I am crossing my fingers that my installer, who has a good local reputation makes me a happy customer.

Re: OT new heat pump

#9

Re: OT new heat pump

Jim Dillon

>John,

About 4 years ago, we finally bit the bullet and replaced our baseboard heat (no AC) with a complete install and got a Trane 4-ton SEER 14 unit (heat and AC) with the newer refrigerant. An entire house heat/cooling load calculation indicated we needed a 3-1/2 ton unit, but no 3-1/2 ton unit was made so we got the 4 ton. Heating and cooling loads calculated out to be about the same. We opted for the SEER 14 as it was in the middle range of SEER ratings at the time and seemed to provide a reasonable payback time based on our electrical rates in the MD/VA area. Higher SEER rated units at the time were much more expensive. Any of the brands you mentioned have good reps. At the time, Carrier was said to have better thermostat control, but Trane had a better warrenty. We have been very pleased with ours, and, so far, no problem. In fact, our electrical bill went down, even though we had never had AC before. Todays heat pumps and air handler units are really designed to work with one another, so you might think about replacing the air handler as well. You really got your moneys worth out of the old unit.

Jim

Re: OT new heat pump

#10

JL

Re: What was the efficiency/age of the one replace

JL

>The old one was ~10 years or older. It was 7 SEER or less - and was just a heat pump. It was also low in Freon (and it was old enough to use Freon). The newer one is 15 SEER and is a dual fuel furnace/heat pump. I run through maybe 400 gallons of propane a year.

Re: OT new heat pump

#11

Re: OT new heat pump

Chuck Kettler Greenwood IN

>If you decide to go with a high efficiency unit that utilizes new and exotic technology make sure the local guy has sufficient resources to provide initial warranty repair and assistance down the line. Many new units require an an experienced refrigeration mechanic AND factory training in order to keep the unit running to original specifications.

Re: OT new heat pump

#12

Re: OT new heat pump

Don Evans

>I upgraded a year ago and have been very happy with my AC/Heat pump with propane furnace combination. Also installed a high priced thermostat Honeywell mainly so I could control the switch over from heat pump to propane heating. I like this thermostat because I can pick the outside temp that it will switch over. After some experimenting I set it for 40 deg switch and it will stay at that setting.

As far as brands go, they are all basically the same. Different brands, like anything now days, rely on components that someone else makes and they just assemble them and put there name on them.

Two brands that are good are Armstrong and Goodman. You should find these units that are same spec as advertised brands like Carrier are much less expensive.

Carrier and Armstrong are the same unit except the Carrier uses tinsel on the coil and Armstrong still uses the fin's on the copper tubing. But due to TV advertising the Carrier would have been $1500 more for the unit I got, same spec's but Armstrong on the cabinet. They both come from the same maker in Columbia SC (for this area anyway). Ever seen a Goodman or Armstrong advertised on TV?

I am a convinced believer that the newest SEER unit will not pay for itself. I put in a SEER 13 the cost for the SEER16 was far more than the unit would have saved over it's life due to lower utility cost here.

Don

Re: OT new heat pump

#13

What's exotic?

Tony - Memphis

>I don't follow HVAC equipment, so I'm not really up on what's new. SO, what do you consider exotic? I hope I'm not in the market any time soon, but when I am, I would like to invest in better effciency, but as an engineer, I understand to be cautious with anything "new." We have a Goodman brand unit that is very low SEER (ten years old so, amybe it was around 10?). Ours has lasted, but I've heard many horror stories about Goodman. My shop unit, which was a Goodman wall mount, went kaput rather quickly. They were both extremely noisy and the house unit still dims the lights on the whole block and wakes the whole neighborhood when it kicks in. Still kicking though!

Tony

Re: OT new heat pump

#14

Re: OT new heat pump

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>We replaced our old heat only geothermal heat pump with a geothermal heating/AC system last summer. It is a two stage unit with a variable speed fan. We leave the fan on low all the time and the hose is more evenly warm or cool because the air is constantly circulating on a low speed. When the heat or A/C are actually running the fan kicks up in speed to deliver the air and then it slows down when the cycle is done. We have a two stage compressor but other than when we turned it on and the house was very warm last summer, it has never run the second stage. We are very pleased with the efficiency and sound level of the new equipment.

Ours came with both Bryant and Carrier labels in the carton for the installer to put on, so both brands were obviously made by the same factory.

Lee

Re: OT new heat pump

#15

Re: OT new heat pump *LINK*

Bob Lemon, Sacramento CA

>One reason the dealers bad mouth Goodman is that you can buy it on E-Bay and put it in yourself. You don't have to be a refrigeration mechanic to hook up precharged units and tubing. Here is the E-Bay link.

I'd advise you to not buy a bigger unit than you need because you will get a lot of hot and cold, especially cold, drafts.


4 ton heat pumps

Re: OT new heat pump

#16

Re: What's exotic?

Barry Irby

>I'm not fully up to speed on what exotic is either. Some things that were unusual may now be main stream. When I bought my heat pump about ten years ago they talked me into a variable speed fan in the air handler, claiming it boosted the SEER 1 point. Within a month or two that fan went bad. There wasn't another in this end of the country. They wired in a single speed fan on an extension cord and it ran for a month continuously while they got a new variable speed one. They wired the old fan to the unit to trick the computer into believing it was still operating normally. When the variable speed fan came in, they failed to install it properly and it literally fell into the unit. (This is a one person anecdote and odes not condemn the industry)

Other more exotic things are units that convert the current to 3 phase for the various motors. Supposedly such motors are more efficient. When they break, who you gonna call? Ghost busters?

Another bit of exotica might be the systems used for "zoning" a heat pump so that you can have several thermostats controlling different parts of the house. Too long a story, but as a home inspector I have only seen about half a dozen. None of them worked as intended.

While not exotic I don't thing I would use a dual fuel system in most cases. At least not in this climate. (central Virginia). With dual fuel systems, the oil or gas provides heat when it is colder outside. Above the Set Point Temp the unit runs as a heat pump provides the heat. My Beef is that I suspect that above the set point the heat pump is slightly more efficient but at a substantial initial cost increase. But, above the set point it does not take a lot of heat to heat the house, so it does not matter much what the cost of the fuel is. I would Do the same as I mentioned above, Install a good quality gas or oil furnace coupled with a good quality AC and spend the savings over a duel fuel unit on improving the energy efficiency of the house itself.

Re: OT new heat pump

#17

Re: OT new heat pump

Fred Davis

>Bob,

so you buy it on Ebay and plug it in yourself, because you say no refrigeration mechanic is required.

Living in Ca. as you do you may want to run that statement by your building department for a update.

In addition , when you DO require a refrigeration mechanic to fix it , (and you can count on it) what do you say when he asks for your documentation from the brand that you bought ,dealer?

If you sell your home and naturally you will fill out the disclosure forms honestly because that state will fry you if you don't , how do you provide the necessary signed off permit for the new unit , that isn't' the same one the house came with?

Ebay doesn't provide inspection services to my knowledge.

Ummmm ,uh , I got a hell of a deal on it on Ebay won't work.

FredD

Re: OT new heat pump

#18

Re: OT new heat pump

jacomb

>I live 100 miles s of KC,MO. I replaced my 16 yr old geothermo last year. 4 ton pump and dump, put the first one in myself, put the secound one in myself. This one came in under $4000.00, eer 18.1 and cop 3.8. Plus I get a tax credit of $1113.00. I bought a comfort air from Heat controller. Check them out, been around a long time. My electric co-op started a rebate program last year that pays $750.00 per ton back. If I qualify, (might have installed just before rebate started) then I actually will make money, or save money on this installation. Florida heat pumps are also highly rated. My local carrier dealer was on another planet with his quote for a replacement.

Re: OT new heat pump

#19

May I suggest?????

Barry Irby

>It is hard to convince Americans that bigger is not better, but in the case of HVAC equipment, bigger is not better.

A simplistic statement is that if the equipment were sized exactly correctly, it would run 24 hours a day on the coldest (or hottest) day of the year and just barely keep up. (that's not exactly correct, because the "design day" is not the coldest/hottest day of the year, but we will set that aside for the moment.

This is desirable because the system is most efficient when it is running. It should run in long bursts. When it cycles on and off the efficiency goes down. Duct losses, flue losses, startup losses etc.

Oversized equipment runs in short bursts. Heats or cools fast and cuts off. Oversized AC equipment does not do as good a job of dehumidifying.

If the equipment is slightly undersized, you don't freeze to death or cook in summer. It just means that for a few hours on a few days a year the equipment MAY not be able to keep up and the house is a few degrees colder or warmer than desirable, until the day warms up or the sun goes down.

Bear in mind that installers sell the equipment "by the ton". Bigger units sell for more. I would install a three ton unit and spend the savings improving the energy efficiency of the house, reducing it to a three ton house. (This is not idle advice, As a builder years ago i built well insulated houses and regularly put in what the installers thought was under sized. Some of them made me sign saying I took responsibility. So did local Building Officials. Provided a five year warranty. No customer ever complained about the size of the equipment. The equipment lasted normal life expectancies.)

Re: OT new heat pump

#20

Thanks

Tony - Memphis

>Thanks Barry. Your input on such matters is much appreciated. Thanks for sharing your expertise with us (free of charge no less!).

Down here, the typical situation is natural gas heat. Heat pumps seem to have a bad rap around here. The cost of ng is so high these days, it makes you wonder about some other way to get heat. My shop is small and I have a wall/window unit that uses strip heat. That works fine for such a small space (16x20x10) that is well insulated and only has a couple of windows. I have heard good things about the "newer" systems. Hope I don't need one anytime soon! Ironically, I work around the corner from a Carrier plant. Not sure what they do there. I probably went to school with some of their engineers.

Tony

Re: OT new heat pump

#21

Re: May I suggest?????

Tony - Memphis

>That's what they did to us. Our house is 2300 sq ft and they installed a 5 ton unit. The house often feels clammy. It gets very humid here. Next time I build, I'll probably enlist a real life HVAC engineer rather than a local , uh, well, HVAC "expert."

Tony

Re: OT new heat pump

#22

Additional Information

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I located an "ENERGY USAGE/PAYBACK CALCULATOR FOR HEAT PUMP" Excel spreadsheet on the internet that was useful for calculating the payback in comparing different models to the existing system. Email me if interested and I can send you a copy of the file (it also works in OPen Office) or just do a google search for the title above.

Lee

Re: OT new heat pump

#23

Re: May I suggest?????

Fred Davis

>What Barry says about HVAC efficiency is exactly right,

'

What he didn't say is , what if your wife doesn't like the sound of long cycle running of the furnace or AC, I run the standard advice by her, point it out to her in the utility newsletter and get the spousal response, "I don't care what you or they say " .

Then I remind her that a efficient unit is a happy and cost effective unit and sometimes her Science teacher training will over ride her displeasure of a steady roar from the units fan. But not always ;-((

FredD