Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

Posts

OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#1

OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I'm told the Canadians have discovered the absolute best recipes and techniques for plank salmon. I seem to recall Sophie bragging about it. I'd like to ask for some help.

After viewing countless recipes on the web, LOML and I decided to try our hand at it. I cut a 15" slab of 1x6 cedar and soaked it for about 10 hours.

We tool just under two pounds of salmon fillets, skin on, and cut them into five portions. Tried different recipes on each piece. Heated the Weber gas grill to high, put the cedar on for five minutes and it never really got smoking much. Sprayed the smooth side of the cedar with olive oil and added the fish pieces, cooking covered for 12 minutes. When I checked them after the 12 minutes, they were still on the very rare side, still pink. I love seared Tuna thats very rare, but I figured the salmon needed to be a bit more done. Thoughts? Anyway, finished cooking them in the microwave.

One mistake we mades was to try to compare too many recipes. After sampling all five, it was hard to decide which tasted better than the others. Also never really got that sensation of smoke flavor everyone talks about.

Scratchin my head here, West of Chicago.

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#2

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This sounds like the kind of recipe that doesn't translate well from a remote lodge on a salmon river to the suburbs.

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#3

Re: OT - Plank Salmon

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>1: Don't cover it.

2: Don't start 'till your grill reaches max.

3: Put some chipped cedar in your smoker box. [Don't have a smoker box? Get one!]

4: Soak the plank in white wine.

5: Soak the plank in ale.

6: Regardless of season(ing) wear a tooc when cooking.

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#4

And

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>That would be "toques", eh hoser!

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#5

Like this one, Sophie's 06

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi Tim,

This was the one from Sophie's last party

Photobucket

I seem to remember it was western cedar, I maybe wrong, but the wood was very wet, wrapped it up in foil and cooked over the fire for enough time to go pink... can't remember the seasoning.... Chico might know

Take care,

Jim

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#6

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I've never liked cedar salmon, but since you didn't ask here's my favourite recipe:

1. Salmon, skin side down

2. Top with maple syrup and bit of butter

3. Wrap all this in aluminium foil and put in the BBQ (or oven) for ~20 minutes until done.

Repeat once a week, serve with Jasmine rice.

The only time I tried cooking a cedar salmon, I had just finished building my fence and had a few boards left over :-)

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#7

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Soak the western red cedar sticks overnight in water in a five gallon bucket beside the BBQ. Hold 'em down with a brick - you need total submersion.

Put grill on high, place cedar on grill, "smooth side" down, close the lid, allow cedar to heat "just" to the point of char.

Flip planks over (smooth side up), brush with olive oil, put salmon on them skin side down (salt/pepper only, nothing else), keep heat on high, maybe just off high, close the lid.

You want about ten minutes per inch of thickness, maybe a bit more, but not much

DO NOT OPEN THE LID!! If you do, you'll introduce oxygen and the wood will flare up. Keep it closed, it'll smoke/steam like crazy. Cook fast, the fire department's probably already been called.

Turn off the heat, have a platter at the ready, have a squirt bottle at the ready.

Open lid, remove salmon from the charred planks, place on platter, put out spot fires with squirt bottle and put the planks back into the five gallon bucket (full of water) to stop the smoking.

If you really want to serve the salmon "on the plank", have another set of planks ready to go to use at the table.

No maple syrup, no tin foil, no mayonnaise or anything else - With this recipe, use just fish with salt/pepper. Good fresh wild pacific salmon stands fine on it's own.

Rob (who used to be a commercial salmon fisherman)

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#8

More shots of Sophie's salmon

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Here's the chef himself. Looks like lemon slices and onion, and maybe a little salt and pepper.




Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#9

And a Hot Fire

Dustmaker Mike

>the trick is to get the plank smoldering. If you are using a Weber is it charcoal or gas? If it is charcoal then toss some fruit wood right on the charcoal after it gets going, it will smolder and let the smoke out. If it is gas you have to get the wood a lot hotter to get it smoldering. I have been know to put a foil pan on the splash guards over the burners to get them smoldering. I always soak in a cheap beer then toss the wood on the coal.

At least that is how I do it on the grill I also have a smoker that I use to cook it long and really slow.

Flavor is what ever you like I use a brown sugar glaze with a touch of lemon. Or I use a Cajun type flavoring once in awhile.

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#10

Flavor Preferences

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Have tried a number, but always seem to come back to Dijon, fresh dill, fine-chopped shallots, fresh lemon, with white wine as the cedar soak, and a 500+� gas fire. 10-12 min for medium rare, 18-20 for well done.

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#11

How the salmon is caught is also important *LINKS*

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>How the salmon is caught is also very important... as you can see in these two videos.

Enjoy!

www.youtube.com - Catching a Salmon

www.youtube.com - Catching a Salmon 2

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#12

A pressure treated plank leaves an off taste

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#13

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

david schaefer fairbanks ak

>kinda depends on the particular species of salmon that u have humpies need moch less cooking time than say chinook or jack. yellow cedar also works well. dont use river salmon (not as much fat) good eating ds

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#14

True, But It Lasts A Long Time!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#15

Re: Like this one, Sophie's 06

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>I seem to recall that JR supplied the wood and it was something like Brazilian Cherry. All I really remember was that it was very good.

glc

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#16

Not Canadian but

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>A couple of questions, what kinda of Salmon and what kind of Cedar? I have used Western Red Cedar fences boards but I much prefer an Alder plank and for me IT HAS to a Pacific Salmon, Chinook or Coho. I only soak the board an hour, a little Olive oil, salt and pepper and a hot grill. The place Lisa works has Alder Planked Salmon on their menu most nights. Slap the fillet on the plank stick it in a hot oven, a little chive oil on top to finish, serve with garlic mashers and Assparagus. One of my favorite meals. They use the planks over several times.

glc

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#17

with Wasabi sauce.....the best.

Victor P

>

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#18

I'll take that second one, ha, Too funny

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>I'm still laughing at that. K

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#19

Re: And

John in Calgary

>I'm not a hoser, you're a hoser....

Mmmmhhh, brings back memories of Octoberfest in Kitchener (where of course, Bob & Doug's dog drank all the tainted beer).

John

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#20

T'aint?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Strange dog. Strange Brew.

So that's like a strange brewdog, eh?

Re: OT - Plank Salmon, need advice from Canadians

#21

Similar method for Chicken...

Bill Wilkinson

>I'm itchin to try the planking method, but.....

We have a related method for chicken, but no wood (I know - sacriledge!)

We use aluminum pans with water under the chicken breasts. Cook with the BBQ on high, withthe cover CLOSED, except when you check the pans for water.

Do not let the pans get too low, or you will need to add too much water and it will sloow or stop the cooking process.

Keep a pitcher of water beside the grill (you could use beer, but that would be a waste

Our BBQ cooks the chicken in about 35-45 minutes - time will depend on your BBQ.

The chicken comes out nicely cooked, and very moist!

We have been using this method for about ten years and it is practically foolproof.

One bit of advice - try to have the cooking finish with about 1/4" of water in the pans, not full - they will be full of gunk from the drippings, and are a tippy mess to get out once they cool.

BTW, measure you BBQ to get pans that are a) disposable, and b) sized to fit under the chicken breasts and allow as much space around the pan to let the heat up.

Other than that, enjoy...

Regards,

Bill