Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Dust collector muffler completed!

Posts

Dust collector muffler completed!

#1

Dust collector muffler completed!

David G. Sparks

>A few days ago I asked for ideas on how to muffle the noise of my 2 hp dust collector blower's exhaust going outside. Thank you for your responses. I decided to make a muffler using a 35 gal. plastic trashcan. I drilled 1 3/8" holes around the perimeter of the can about 2" from the bottom to let air escape. I put a plywood disc with a 4" hole in the center inside the can squeezed in to about 6" from the bottom. I drilled a section of 4" SD full of 1/2" holes. After cutting a 4" hole in the can's plastic lid, I glued two PVC couplings and a short piece of pipe together connecting them through the hole. I sealed this with silicone to keep rain from leaking in. I filled the can with several layers of carpet padding standing on edge. I also put a piece on the plywood disc and crammed some in around the top of the other padding to keep noise from coming through the lid. I glued the piece of SD pipe with the holes drilled in it into the inside coupling on the lid. I slid the pipe down through the hole in the plywood disc. The end of the pipe extends just a little past the bottom of the plywood. After putting the lid back on the can, I hooked up my exhaust line. When I cut my 2 hp blower on now the exhaust noise is less than the noise coming from a clothes dryer vent. I'm happy with how it worked out. Thanks again.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#2

Great !

Bricofleur

>Thanks for the feedback, and I'm happy your muffler turned out well. It seams the cost was at the minimum. Great ! That's what I call a real 'do-it-yourselfer'.

Best,

Serge

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#3

Congratulations

Hamish

>Hi David, I'm very glad that you have managed to find and make a good solution for damping the sound. Perhaps you could post a photo of your achievements.

Good day, Hamish.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#4

Here's a sketch and a couple questions

Ellis Walentine, Host

>This is my one-minute sketch of the muffler unit you described. My questions are:

1. What the heck is SD pipe? I assume it is just cheapo PVC drain pipe.

2. What are the operational airflow variables in a system like this? In other words, how do you determine the number and cross-sectional area of the holes in the can and the inside pipe to make sure you don't put too much back-pressure on your system? What are the real numbers in a situation like this?

Anybody?

Ellis


img

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Lemme see if I understand......

Jesper, Denmark

>Sound is waves of higher pressure travelling down the pipe.

From long ago, fitting low restriction straight-through Corvette mufflers to a "tuned" big block Chevy engine my understanding of how it worked was this:

The pipe at the muffler inlet went straight through to the outlet at the same diameter, but had holes drilled in the pipe all along the inside of the muffler can. The can was filled with basically fibreglass insulation.

The function was that the high pressure waves would push some air into the can, thus reducung the wave size at the outlet and reduce the noise. The air would come back into the pipe during passage of the low pressure part of the wave.

So, same frequency, but much lower peaks on the waves and less noise. The pressure drop was minimal, as there was no restrictions to airflow, only a slightly rougher side wall in a short piece of pipe.

As I see it, the main pressure loss in the can described is the change in velocity from the 4" pipe to the can bottom and the increase again through the holes in the side. The attanuation would probably be just as good if the can was simply cut off at the ply bottom - but it is not as convenient.

Just rambling thoughts...............

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#6

Re: Here's a sketch and a couple questions

Dave Paine

>1. I also expect SD pipe is PVC Sewar Drain pipe. I hope the person is using the smooth wall and not the corrugated bury in ground, which will have bad pressure drop. The pipe is not bad for pressure drop, but the fittings can be very bad. Designed for liquids and not low pressure gas flow.

2. It is complicated to calculate "real world" pressure drop values for a design like this. It has been a very long time since I did pressure drop calculations. Lots of variables.

If I were to attempt, I would ascertain either flow or static pressure without and then measure with.

Easier to rig up a manometer. Cut piece of wood/plastic/cardboard to fit in a waste gate. Drill hole in centre, gule in a piece of clear plastic tube several feet long. Put some water in the tube, about 1/2 length. Clamp the tube in a U shape. Turn on blower. Mark upper and lower water level. Measure distance.

Add device and repeat.

This design is going to have some impact on pressure drop and hence on flowrate.

Calculating overall "hole" area is easy. Probably want this to be larger than blower inlet area (metal opening not fitting size).

Calulating the pressure drop of the carpet padding is not so easy. The person mentioned "on end" so perhaps try to have air flow between the padding layers and not through.

Should be easy to start without, measure flow or pressure, then add, repeat and decide for yourself whether the dust collection on the tools are adequate.

In my shop, I use my planar as the guide for whether I have enough airflow/pressure. When I do not get my normal chip removal, it normally means time to clean the filters.

I also do a had test, literally put my hand in the 4in flex duct and feel the suction. You can feel the difference between clean system and time-to-clean system.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#7

Re: Here's a sketch and a couple questions

Barry Irby

>Don't know a thing about the calculations.

Also don't know a thing about measuring the noise levels. Apparently a 10 DB drop in noise is significant. Maybe somebody can explain the DB scale but apparently a 10 DB drop seems like about half the noise. Perhaps the scale is logarithmic.

On a side note: I just installed a bath fan for a customer. They wanted a quiet one that was powerful. Went to a big box store (their choice) and looked at the fans. The fans were rated in Sones (?). 70 CFM model was 1 sone. 105 CFM was 1.5 stones. 140 CFM was 2 Sones. They had a set up in the store and you could push the appropriate button to hear them run. 2 Sones was just audible above the back ground noise in the store. 1 stone was so quiet I had to look into the fan to make sure it was really running. Bought the 140 cfm unit. Then read the instructions closely. 2 stones with a six inch duct. A four inch duct raised it to 2.5 stones and dropped it to 130 CFM.

SD pipe is Sewer and Drain. I think it is schedule 20 (30?) and regular sewer pipe is schedule 40. The wall thickness is 1/8 or 3/16" and schedule 40 is a 1/4 or 5/16. The pipe is about half the weight and much easier to handle. Better fittings (much more "swept" or larger radius bends) are available for the schedule 40 pipe, but you have to buy a adapter to make the thinner pipe fit the fittings. Also, the fittings for the heavier pipe are maybe four times as expensive. The thinner pipe is significantly cheaper also. I used two forty fives in place of a ninety to get a gentler bend.

On Bill Pentz' site you can get instructions on how to bend the pipe and make your own fittings.

If you buy the pipe, look inside it when you pick the pieces. I found many with terrible defects inside. Buy the smooth stuff.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#8

Noise stuff

David Hammelef

>dB scale is logarithmic 3dB is a doubling of power. 10dB is HUGE.

Sones are a measure of Tonal (whiny) noises and not overall level. Fans usually have tones related to blade passage freq. More noticeable in prop fan not so much in squirrel cage. Great Marketing, but not the full story.

For the muffler, it is like Ellis drew it up, why use carpet padding that stuff is thick and not a great sound absorber. Fiberglass best stuff around for sound absorption.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#9

Re: Great !

David G. Sparks

>Thanks, Serge. I have about $50 in the whole setup. It really is quiet.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#10

Some figures about Sounds... *LINK*

Bricofleur

>To emphasize what David said about sounds, here are some figures.

It's always time to talk about SAFETY!

Best,

Serge


img

Protecting your ears.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#11

Re: Here's a sketch and a couple questions

David G. Sparks

>Wow Ellis, that's it exactly! SD stands for sewer and drain. I think maybe it's schedule 20 pvc or as you said the cheapo kind. I don't know how to figure back pressure, but the lid on the trashcan doesn't fit very tightly. When I cut the blower on the lid didn't blow off. The pipe isn't glued into the plywood disc, so it would move up if it needed to. The motor is running cool. Unfortunately, I don't have any way to check the amps it's pulling. I have great suction at my saw. I'm using 2 1/2" Locline at the blade, one line above my scroll saw's table and one below. I know a 2 hp blower is overkill, but it's what I had other than a 1/3 hp which was too weak. It seems to be working well. I probably have more holes in the can than I needed, but I figured more wouldn't hurt because of the resistance of the flex and pipe work for the exhaust. Thanks for your great sketch. I was afraid my description would not be clear enough.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#12

Re: Lemme see if I understand......

David G. Sparks

>The reason I put the disc in the can was so I wouldn't have to make a separate stand for the contraption. This way, the can trashcan just sits on the ground. You are right, the sound would still be lessened if the pipe were sticking straight out the bottom of the can.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#13

Re: Noise stuff

David G. Sparks

>I used remnant carpet pad from Lowes. It was cheaper than buying a roll of fiberglass insulation. You are right; the fiberglass would have been a better sound insulator. I also thought the carpet pad might hold up to the airflow a little better. It probably doesn't really matter at this flow rate.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#14

Re: Here's a sketch and a couple questions

Stuart Hough

>David, it looks as though you've created the trashcan equivalent of a glasspack muffler...just a LOT quieter! Kudos! If it's alright, I'd like to steal your idea for my shop!

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#15

Re: Here's a sketch and a couple questions

David Sparks

>Thanks, Stuart. Hope it works out for you. I was surprised at how quiet it made the exhaust. Seems like being cheap worked out well for me this time.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#16

Congrats! Could you post a pic

North of the Border

>of your final set up? Thanks.

Re: Dust collector muffler completed!

#17

Re: Congrats! Could you post a pic

David G. Sparks

>I'll try to post some pictures this weekend. I've been working my regular job until after dark for the past few days.