Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Building cabinets without face frames

Posts

Building cabinets without face frames

#1

Building cabinets without face frames

lee beeden

>I have built a few kitchens and also a few entertainment centres using the time honoured method of face frame construction.

However I have my first job were the client has asked for wall to wall cabinets in three rooms with no face frames.

As I have never built using this method could you offer any comments or tips.

Thanking you all in advance

Lee

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#2

Common anywhere except for USA

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Lee,

This is a common technique - I'm guessing that the client wants overlaid doors.

Blum, Hettich, Hafele, and a number of other European manufacturers make the hinges you'll need.

Remember that the hinges run on system 32.

Holes are commonly, but not always, 37mm from the front edge.

Use a dedicated 35mm forstner bit to cut the recess/pooket for the door hinge.

Check the instructions for the hinge to ensure that distances are correct.

CHeers,

Andrew

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#3

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

Fred Davis

>Frameless cabinet construction was a European development to cut down on the use of expensive materials in the cabinets (read wood).

In my and some others opinion this method subtracts from the strength of the cabinets relative to ones with face frames.

In addition , euro style hinges interfere with the storage of contents in the cabinet because of the way the hinge operates.

Case in point , my cousin and attorney could not wait for me to do her office complex and secretary bull pen cabinets so she wound up with her pardner supervising the choice of cabinets.

He chose Euro style frameless and the hinges destroyed stacks of paper work stored in the cabinets, shedding the edges of the stacks every time they were opened.

Because the doors had no visible pulls , the secretaries stuck tape on the edge of the doors that had the recess routed in the bottom for a pull, to recognize which edge was the opening edge .;-))

Needless to say they did wait for me for the law library project,but the cabinets for that particular use in the outer office were a disaster.

For people who like that style and many are led by interior decorators opinions on aesthetics , you can only point out the downsides to the construction techniques and in my case decline to tool up for a style I would not have for myself.

FredD

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#4

Is this what the client wants? *LINK*

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Lee,

Detail of the carcase construction and hinge overlay settings are in the attached link if so.

Cheers,

Andrew


img

http://www.blum.com/us/en/index.php

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#5

another opinion

Thomas S Stockton

>I find that once euro style cabinets are attached to the wall they are just as strong as face frame cabinets, especially if they are made out of 3/4" material. As for the hinge problem, they make zero protrusion hinges that have no interference so you can actually have more room since the face frame isn't taking up space. I think your cousins problem was with not knowing what was availble hardware wise. You can run into the same problem with face frame cabinets if you don't put visible handles or pulls on them, this is more a design problem than faceframe vs frameless.

I think you should decide on which style of cabinet you want based on what you want design wise because there are plusses and minuses with both systems.

Tom

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#6

Euro-style

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I use only euro-style carcass (non-faceframe) construction in both my home and my office, as well as in my shop. They are every bit as strong as face-frame when properly mounted and joined, and give full access to the interior of the "box". I also use Blum hinges which are self-closing and silky smooth for all my overlay doors. My full extension office file drawers are inset and can carry up to 125lbs. Naturally these cases are all cabinet-grade veneered plywood with solid door panels; no flakeboard allowed. Pulls are either brass or stainless.

In my view, face-frames are fine for movable pieces, but waste space to get a modest but unnecessary increase in cabinet rigidity for units that will be wall-mounted. If you do inset doors and drawers (as I do with my Craftsman style pieces), you'll loose even more space with a face frame.

YMMV

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#7

I have to disagree too.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Back when I started building cabinets in the late sixties, they were all face frame, but since I switched to the 32 mm system back in the mid eighties, I don't recall ever having had a problem like you describe. All of my customers know that if they have a problem, all they need to do is call me, and it will be fixed for free. I am not getting any of those call backs.

As for more useful space, there is no way that all of the space wasted behind those unnecessary face frames can render more usable space.

Fred, you really ought to look into the system closer.

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#8

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

Jim Dillon

>Lee,

Paul Levine's book "Making Kitchen Cabinets" was very helpful to me and its focus is on the European-style of cabinet your client desires. I think they can be quite attractive in the right setting. Pick up a paper copy of Woodworkers Hardware (WWH) catalog to see all the hinge options that are available - and there are a LOT. I used the ones that allow the door to swing 120 degrees (Blum), and you can get them that go up to 270 degrees. They take up roughly 3/4 inch in the interior. You will likely have to buy a proper sized forstner bit for the hinges, which is not inexpensive. And there are a bunch of guides and jigs that might help you - all available from WWH.

I actually ended up using the hybrid approach advocated by the late Danny Proulx and described in his book "Build Your Own Kitchen Cabinets. It combines a traditional face frame (at least it appears that way when the doors are shut), with the space-saving European-style of a flush interior. But your client wants the traditional European style, which is fine. Made my cabinets from 3/4 inch plywood with a 1/4 inch plywood back stapled and glued in place. Added an interior "picture-frame" at the top to further reinforce the cabinet, instead of a solid top, at least for the lower cabinets. They are plenty strong, even without the hybrid face frame. You should have no problem at all.

Jim

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#9

My Only Kitchen, My Initial thoughts..

Jim Rahbe

>Lee,

So far I have made one set of kitchen cabinets and they were the frameless, euro style. Here are some of the things that I did not fully understand before setting off to build them.

1. When you install face-frame cabinets between two walls, you can make the ends wider and scribe them to the walls for a perfect fit. With frameless cabinets you can add a spacer, but it will never be seamless.

2. With face-frame cabinets, the doors are generally set in from the edge and inch or so. With a frameless cabinet, the space is more like a � inch. Doors on cabinets that are installed against a wall will not open all the way to allow for sliding trays etc.

3. With face-frame cabinets the edge of the plywood or particleboard are covered. With frameless cabinets, you generally use Edgebanding tape of some type. I found the edgebanding to be expensive to buy, a pain to install, and it just has a �cheap� look to it. I even bought a hot air edgebander and the edge and end trimmers, but it still took me most of the project to get even reasonable good at installing it. So far, so good, but I�m not at all convinced as to how long it will be before pieces will start to fall off.

4. I like the open box at the bottom of each cabinet, when using the face-frame design, as it gives you a place to hide under-cabinet lighting. You don�t get that feature with the standard frameless design. You can add a piece of trim, but in my mind, it does not look right.

5. I really do like the 32mm system. The only downside is that you have to buy or, as in my case, make a pretty accurate drilling jig to make the necessary holes. The other day some one here was asking about installing drawer slides in kitchen cabinets. Using the 32mm system, nothing could be easier, as all the holes are predrilled.

6. I also like the idea of no center stile, especially on cabinets that have sinks. Really makes getting in and out very easy.

Please remember this is my one and only experience with anything other than shop cabinets, so there may be answers to all my problems that I am just not aware of.

Jim R.


img

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#10

Get This Book

Bricofleur

>My suggestion is to get this book from Danny Proulx. He covers all the aspects from frames to hinges, slides and drawers, material and hardware, pull-outs and toe-kicks. Another good related book from him is Cabinet Doors and Drawers.

I made eight floor frameless cabinets in my workshop following his advises and I'm very happy with the results.

Best,

Serge

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com


img

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#11

This is experience !

Bricofleur

>Jim, you did a very good job. Your kitchen cabinets turned out great and your kitchen looks awesome. Your experience doing it really sounds.

Best,

Serge

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#12

Beautiful job Jim!

Jim Dillon

>

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#13

Re: another opinion

Fred Davis

>My cousins problem Tom, was her pardners insistence on that particular look in the case work, and they both without knowing all of the aggravations associcated with that cabinet syle signed off on it .

Nothing to do with me , except I learned early on to carry a screwdriver with me when I had occasion to visit her , because some or even most of the doors were out of alignment, rubbing each other or dragging because the hinges like all Euros I have seen were adjustable , which in her case meant they always needed adjustment.

I have never been at a loss for work doing traditional casework and since I have now reduced the work to plumb picking , I seriously doubt I will change spots anytime soon.

As for the cabinets being as "strong as faceframe style cabinets after you attach them to the wall" , many upper cabinets do not have a wall to support them, island and pennisula cabinets as you well know are attached to the ceiling and in many cases have doors on both sides which adds to the strain.

With all due respect ,it seems to me that statement falls in the same catagory as that of Barry's friend who said to him, I butt joint all of my drawers, staple them together and havn't had one fail yet" or something like that.

So to each his own , but my personal preference will always tilt toward Architectural detail, and a flat refusal to take shortcuts , however clever the hype may be to do it.

I will now shut up on this particular thread. ;-))

FredD

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#14

Re: My Only Kitchen, My Initial thoughts..

Fred Davis

>Jim ,

for a first attempt I must say it looks like you have been doing it awhile and you seem to be making a learning experience from it.

They look as good as that style can look and would look even better and give more storage and hide the vent if that style permitted the cabinets to go to the ceiling. ;-))

That is not intended as a criticism, since you have done the best you can with what you had and judging from your list the next set may be entirely different.

FredD

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#15

We reviewed it! *LINK*

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Barb Siddiqui did a nice review of Danny's book back in 2003. He was an excellent and prolific woodworking author.

Ellis


Danny Proulx: "Building Frameless Kitchen Cabinets

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#16

THANK-YOU FOR ALL YOUR COMMENTS!!!

lee beeden

>

Re: Building cabinets without face frames

#17

So True...

Jim Rahbe

>Fred,

This kitchen was done in a house I rehabbed for my daughter. The initial plan was to add black molding at the top, to match the bottom, with over-cabinet lighting. This would have hid the vent pipe as you suggested. But that final detail just never got done.. Sigh!!

Still better than the original kitchen..:-)

Thanks for the input..

Jim R.


img