Cherry sapwood, yes or no?
JL
>I'm making several legs for a settee. I am probably going to finish the chair in natural rather than stain it.
Do ya'll think the presence of sapwood in a chair leg would be detrimental or just a good accent?
TIA
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Cherry sapwood, yes or no?
JL
>I'm making several legs for a settee. I am probably going to finish the chair in natural rather than stain it.
Do ya'll think the presence of sapwood in a chair leg would be detrimental or just a good accent?
TIA
Re: Cherry sapwood, yes or no?
John K Jordan
>JL,
Seems to me that some light sapwood in just one leg of a chair might look odd.
JKJ
Re: Cherry sapwood, yes or no?
Rob Hix - King George, VA
>Well, in my opinion I would go ahead and use it. I personally look at furniture in the furniture store and think about how much wood was wasted to get all heartwood. I like the contrast, even if it is in only one leg. To me it adds even more proof of a hand-crafted, custom made piece. After all, you won't find that in the furniture stores.
So, go ahead and use it. It will be something you will be proud of.
Rob Hix
Re: Cherry sapwood, yes or no?
wilbur
>I agree with John that sapwood on one leg would look odd. If you really need to use the sapwood piece, I'd actually make the sapwood more of a design element. I don't know what your settee will look like but if I were to use sapwood in the settee in this picture, I'd incorporate it into the center piece of wood on the back, so it was clear that I meant to use it as a decorative element, and that I didn't just come up short in my cherry stash. :@)
Six legs (two in center).
JL
>I am making a Windsor style settee. Seat out of cherry with cherry legs and stretchers.
I would...
Ellis Walentine, Host
>...probably use it if I didn't have anything else, but I'd orient the sapwood so it is not visible from preferred vantage points. IMO, it isn't a feature that complements the design. A little judicious sap stain would solve the problem nicely.
Ellis
Re: I would...
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>I'm with Ellis, I wouldn't use it unless I had no other option, then I would problaby stain it, bearing in mind that the cherry will darken with age and the stained area will not.
Even so it is more a matter of personal tastes, mine just happen to run toward not using sap wood in my projects.
Lee
No, unless you plan to mix it in throughout
steve antonucci
>Personal preference is heartwood only unless the sapwood is going to be featured throughout. Not a defect, but always looks "funny"...
steve
You Own The Project
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>Good Morning JL,
Far be it from me to disagree with others. I incorporate sapwood in my work. The last time I did so, I wound up not liking the "look". However, my wife and kids asked that I not change it. They liked it fine. Your choice is the best choice.
George
Re: Cherry sapwood, yes or no?
Bill Roland (Mt Juliet, TN)
>Here is my sapwood added entertainment center after about 9 years.
So ya'll won't be buying a pig in a poke..
JL
>here is a completed leg and the blank in question. I've parted it down to 2". It looks like the tip of the bulb would be the only place the sapwood would show. The greater bulb diameter is 2" - even if it doesn't look to be that dimension in the pic.
JL, I think it would be insignificant
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>
Re: You Own The Project
Fred Davis
>You weren't alone George, no less a woodworker then Sam Maloff made scrumptious dining tables out of Walnut , Sapwood and all and in addition a poor grade of Walnut to boot.
FredD
Re: You Own The Project
Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA
>Shoot Fred, a poor grade of walnut is all that is available in California, as I recall.
I have seen Sam's table in person. Lovely. But then that man can make lovely things out of firewood.
Not to compare myself to Sam Maloof.....
Barry Irby
>I met Sam Maloof, and I am no Sam Maloof, but
I had some walnut logs sawed and it killed me to throw away the stuff that had sapwood on it so I asked the sawyer to square it up and save it for me, thinking I might use it for interior parts of walnut furniture.
I made a dining table for my cousin. I had set aside the mixed planks to get to the good stuff. (used it for weight on the pile) She came to look at the project and said, "NO, this is what I want for the top." The top came out probably 20% sapwood. She loved it. Me, not so much.
Re: Not to compare myself to Sam Maloof.....
Fred Davis
>sounds like your client had a firm idea of what she and since you provided it , you now have a happy customer who will speak kindly of you to other prospects ;-)
Not to put to fine a point on this thread of sapwood or no sapwood, no less a expert finisher then George Frank once said "if you want a uniform color and one dimension look you can always paint it".
FredD
I'm sure she loves you for yourself
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>regardless of how much or little sapwood you have.