Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Staining maple to look like cherry?

Posts

Staining maple to look like cherry?

#1

Staining maple to look like cherry?

Terry Alexander

>Still building our house.

We are at the cabinet selection phase.

Due to cost....we are wondering if we can buy unfinished maple cabinets and stain them to look like cherry.

Might be a stupid question....but finishing wood is not my strong suiit.

As always...TIA

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

#2

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

Chuck in ND

>Sherwin-Williams is who I would recommend.

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

#3

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

Fred Davis

>A Professional Painter is who I would recommend.

Maple is a difficult wood to stain without blotching and probably not the wood or project to make your first attempt on.

FredD

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

#4

I wouldn't go there

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>If you're going to source and install the cabinets yourself, check out Ikea's offerings. They're the top price/performers on the market. Many styles and finishes, solid wood faces, and presision engineered. Any criticism you hear will be from those who have no direct experience with them.

Clint

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

#5

Gotta be a nay-sayer here...

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Terry - I've been building furniture for nearly 40 years; first for family and friends and, of late, for customers. One thing I've learned by hard experience is that in woodworking, you can't make a silk purse out of an all cotton blend.

Maple is a beautiful wood and finishes quite nicely. Cherry is a beautiful wood, my personal favorite, and finishes quite nicely itself. What doesn't work, at least in my experience, is trying to make one look like the other. Grain, texture and several other factors make the two incompatible.

Have you thought about cherry faceframes or using maple with a blond finish?

Maybe I'm way off base here; just one man's opinion. YMMV

Have fun with your project any way you decide to do it.

Doug

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

#6

Re: Agree with Doug on this

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>The best finish for maple is shellac, at which point the wood looks like beautiful maple.

Every time I've tried to dye, stain, gel stain or tint maple, I've been disappointed. And none of it looked like cherry.

I've mixed cherry and maple in the master bath, and gotten a nice mix. The finishes are, however, a wiped varnish, and it looks like the maker intended it.

Are you buying the cabinets, or building your own? Because the material costs are not that significant, really, for the face frames, doors and drawer fronts. Labor, marketing, shipping and 'oops factors' cover a much larger portion of the costs than materials.

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

#7

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

Tony - Memphis

>Our cabinets are maple and they are stained to look like what most folks outside the woodowrking world call cherry. Its really more the color of cordovan shoe polish (kind of a reddish brown color). Nice color, but not "cherry." I'm not sure exactly what they used, but they sprayed it on. Its almost more like paint. I assume that's how they get around the issue of blotch prone maple. You can still see the grain. In fact, we got a few pieces of curly maple. I'm not crazy about the look, but it works and looks nice. I had to stian some cherry once and I used a gel stain. That worked pretty well and I didn't get too many blotchy areas. I applied a first coat of clear gel and then the color. I think that helped. We couldn't afford solid cherry. The cost was close to double and our cabinet shop didn't even build cherry cabinets very often. He was experimenting with some stains to get a more true cherry color, but he wasn't ready to try it on an install yet. One thing I don't care for about our cabinets is that they are too dark. Oh well. Good luck with your project. Do some experimenting and find something that works. Don't forget that glazes can really make a big difference.

Tony

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

#8

Bart Goldberg

Agree with Tony

Bart Goldberg

>When you say you want a Cherry look, this is not real clear. As Tony states, his cabinets have a solid color applied that probably hides what the native wood is underneath. If that is the look you want, then it probably doesn't matter what type of wood species you use. If however, you are striving for the look of natural, unstained cherry, then I doubt you can get it by dyeing Maple.

My 2 Cents

Bart

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

#9

Re: Agree with Tony

jerry mayfield

>While you may be able to match the color of cherry today(aware that true cherry will age beautifully)the only way to have the benefits of cherry is to use cherry.

Regards

Jerry

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

#10

yes and no...

John in NM

>As others have said, it depends on the final look you're going for. If you want the look of clear coated or oil finish cherry, then no, I don't think you could do it easily with maple.

If you want the look that most cabinet manufacturers sell as "cherry", that dark maroon stained look, yes you can do that with maple using a variety of techniques. Your results will naturally vary and it usually requires a great deal of experimentation with any given technique to achieve a consistent result.

I would probably approach it with gel stain, with or without sanding sealer to control the penetration of the stain, followed by a varnish oil or a urethane varnish. Others would tint some variety of spray varnish and go over it with a clear conversion varnish (this is how the big factories do it, so will probably end up looking most like what you see in cabinet show rooms).

Under no circumstances would I pay for actual cherry to be finished with that dark red stain. Could be poplar under that stuff and no one would know the difference.

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

#11

Re: Staining maple to look like cherry?

Steve Silca

>Terry,

I didn't do it myself, but when renovating my kitchen I decided to go with maple cabinets and chose a dark stain to make it look like cherry. These were made by Kraftmaid. This choice saved me several thousand dollars.

Although I know this is more than you want to spend (since you're even pondering the horrific experience of finishing all your own cabinets - I can't imagine), the results were really outstanding and exactly what I was looking for. The grain was somewhat covered by the deep stain, but it's not a solid coat as some have alluded to here.

Again, it was done professionally, not by me. I have pictures - email me if you want me to send them. I don't know how to make a picture small enough in file size to be posted here.