Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT Question on HDTV

Posts

OT Question on HDTV

#1

OT Question on HDTV

Barry Irby

>Friend of mine bought a 52" TV and got FIOS to go with it. Says he can't tell the difference between the shows on the HD channels and the regular ones. I know nothing about this and don't have either a HDTV or Fios, but this doesn't sound right. Can you definitely tell the difference? Has he made some sort of mistake setting it up?

(Does Thelma and Louise come out better in HD?)

Re: OT Question on HDTV

#2

Re: OT Question on HDTV

Jim Pugh, Elyria, OH

>I have no idea why you aren't getting HDTV but in my case, I am connected to Roadrunner and they have shifted all of their HD channels to a different location. Standard channel 5 became HD channel 405. Might check to see if something similar is happening on your system. And yes, there sure is a difference. The standard digital picture won't fill the screen and HD signal will.

Re: OT Question on HDTV

#3

Re: OT Question on HDTV

David Anderson PacNW)

>Make sure that he is connected to the right inputs on the back of the set. Mine has 6 differant inputs- 3 for HD, Anolog, Svidieo and digital. It takes 18 to 20 hours to hook up all the componets

Good Luck

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

Re: OT Question on HDTV

#4

Re: OT Question on HDTV

Kirk (KC) Constable

>We recently got two new flat panel TVs. The difference in the picture is incredible over the old sets... whether the signal is HD or not. I can switch back and forth between (for instance) HGTV hi def and regular HGTV and don't see any substantial difference. But it's waaaaay different than the old TV.

Re: OT Question on HDTV

#5

Re: OT Question on HDTV

Bill Howatt

>I have a HDTV but I only get non-HD service from my satellite. There is a huge difference in the picture quality compared to the old CRT TV it replaced and I often think this is a bit part of what a lot of people see as HD is a lot better. Don't get me wrong, real HD programming is sharper but for my eyes there is more than enough detail in what I'm getting now with the better and larger image. I can see plenty of warts and pock marks that weren't there with the old TV.

And as I always say, I've never turned off a program because it lacked resolution, only because I didn't like the program itself.

Bill

Re: OT Question on HDTV

#6

Re: OT Question on HDTV

Marvin Horn

>Many channels are not true HD but a "Upconverted" signal of standard definition. Some of these are hard to distingish from standard definition. If you can't see a difference between true HD and SD something is definitely wrong-big time.

Re: OT Question on HDTV

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I agree

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Just looking at a TV, I can tell whether the picture being watched is HD, SD or stretched/zoomed SD. Often, with cable/satellite/DVR/tuner boxes, there is a setting that needs to be made so that you the box is sending the proper signal to the TV. If it is set to only send an SD signal, HD signals will be downconverted. If it is set to send an HD signal, then SD signals will be upconverted (there may be some improvement in their quality, but not much), and HD signals will pass through.

There's another aspect to this. Right now, there are essentially 3 types of HD signal--720p, 1080i and 1080p. 1080p will only come from a Blu-ray or HDDVD player, though some lesser DVD players may upconvert to this signal by interpolation. Cable and satellite may come in either 720p or 1080i, and you may be able to find out which. I prefer to let the TV do the converting, but that depends on which you decide does the better job of conversion--the TV or the cable/satellite box.

Jason

Re: OT Question on HDTV

#9

Re: OT Question on HDTV

Jerry Nicholson

>Even though the channel might be HD, the program might not have been recorded with HD equipment. In the case of older shows, old movies and reruns, that is definitely the case. Only one of the local channels in Wichita has upgraded to HD studio equipment for the news, weather, etc. The news and weather on the other channels really look bad in comparison. I very rarely watch sports but I have noticed significant differences of sports broadcasts in HD. Some of them are obviously using old equipment.

Jerry

Re: OT Question on HDTV

#10

Re: OT Question on HDTV

John in Calgary

>There is definitely a huge difference in quality between a true HD show and its non-HD brethren, but it has to be produced in HD.

Look for an HD version of one of the CSI shows and you will see what I mean - one of our local channels started broadcasting in HD over the air and we only pull in what we can over a set of rabbit ears. When I heard they had started broadcasting over the air in HD, I tuned in the right channel and was blown away by the picture quality and colours.

John

Re: OT Question on HDTV

#11

Lee Gordon

Re: OT Question on HDTV

Lee Gordon

>I think the most obvious way to compare SD vs. HD is with sporting events. Tune in a baseball, football or basketball game on a standard def station and switch back and forth between that and the same station's HD channel. If the difference isn't obvious you may not be getting a proper HD signal into the set.