Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

Posts

HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#1

HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

Dan Mitchell

>I'm considering this oscillating spindle sander, on sale at Harbor Freight for $99.99 & Woodcraft for $129.99, though the latter source appears to be out of stock. They look to be identical, and the specs are exactly the same.

So naturally, I'm leaning towards the cheaper, available example ;-)

But I'm wondering if anyone has one, or has any thoughts on these in general. In particular, I'm wondering if the fact that you can't tilt the top is a major limitation, or if they may be too small.

HF model: http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/ctaf/displayitem.taf?Itemnumber=95088

WC model:

http://www.woodcraft.com/product.aspx?ProductID=411901&FamilyID=21065

Any thoughts?

TIA

Dan


img

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#2

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

Kirk (KC) Constable

>How often are you going to need it to tilt? I've had the Delta BOSS for several years and don't know that I've ever wished it would tilt. I tend to look at the fixed table as one less thing that can get out of alignment... since on so many of the 'cheaper' tools the tilt mechanism is 'cheesy'.

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#3

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks Kirk, I agree about the alignment issue. EXPENSIVE machines seem to have enough trouble with it, let alone these guys ;-/

Do you find yours particularly useful?

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#4

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

Mark_in_Michigan

>I got the same machine under a different brand name at Menards for $89.99 and think it was a good purchase for me. It has better dust collection than what I thought it would have. I haven't had a case yet where I wish it had a tilting table. I do wish the cylinder oscillated over a greater distance, I just flip the sleeve every time I use it. The table could also be bigger, I am just very careful when I am using it on a bigger piece of wood.

If you are limited to this price range, I think it is a good deal.

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#5

Spend a Bit More For A Lot More

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Dan,

Suggest you look at the Rigid oscillating belt/spindle sander at Home Depot. Under $200 and you get the spindle plus an oscillating 4" belt edge sander plus a tilting table. I've had one for 4 years and it's been indispensable when I do square spindles for mission stuff. It also carries the "lifetime" guarantee which I tested when the oscillator stripped out a few months ago. Rigid replaced the entire motor/drive unit; no charge. The miter gauge is cheesy, so I made a sled with adjustable fence that works very well.

mm

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#6

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

Bill White

>Get the Ridgid. For $200.00 ya get belt and OSS with dust collection (sorta).

Bill

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#7

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies, I'll check out the Ridgid model as well.

Dan

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#8

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Dan,

Well, I have the Ryobi. Mine looks like the other two in size and capability. I seem to remember the Woodcraft tauts a cast iron table. I believe mine is aluminum. No practical difference in the work it does, but lighter is better when I must lift something onto a table from a lower shelf. The Ryobi works very well, and its used on almost every project I do. It would be "nice" to have the table tilt. However, I've been able to work around that limitation. The HF tools I have have had in the past worked well for me, although they all have been upgraded.

George

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#9

Re: Spend a Bit More For A Lot More

John K Jordan

>I second the motion - I've had the Rigid for perhaps 7-8 years now and get a lot of use out of it, especially the oscillating belt sander. It's quick to change between the belt and spindles.

I liked it even better when I caught a clearance table at HD with the sanding sleeves at 90% off. I bought all they had - a lifetime supply for me.

JKJ

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#10

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

While it costs more, I agree with those who like the Rigid. Although I have had the Delta BOSS for 5+ years, if I were shopping today, I would look closely at the Rigid because it also has the horizontal belt sander. I built a fixture to hold my belt sander and use it a LOT. So it would be nice to have both in the same unit. If I was just looking for an oscillating sander today, I would likely look at the JET as it has a smaller (1/4 inch) spindle than the BOSS which I would find very useful for my own use. But it costs a lot more and is likely out of your price bracket. Good luck.

Jim

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#11

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

Kirk (KC) Constable

>A spindle sander is one of those 'right tools for the job' that can make things easier. Lots of other ways to do the same thing.

I have a scroll saw buried somewhere in the shop. I've used it probably two times in the past 10 years... but when I NEED a scroll saw, it's there.

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#12

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

Just reread your OP and saw you asked about the value of the tilting table. IMHO, especially for an oscillating sander, it is not likely to be used a lot, if at all. I built into my belt sander fixture the capability to tilt the table and, frankly, have never used it - although I still think tilting might be potentially more useful on a belt sander, and even more so on a disk sander. And I have used the tilt capability on my 1-inch vertical belt sander. Just some additional thoughts.

Jim

Re: HF/Woodcraft oscillating sander: anyone have?

#13

Thanks Jim!

Dan Mitchell

>