Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

OT - XP or Vista?

Posts

OT - XP or Vista?

#1

OT - XP or Vista?

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Sorry to ask again what has been hashed and re-hashed.

My Wife finally ordered a new laptop after me badgering her for months to do so. She ordered a Dell dual core hot-rod, and it comes with Vista. It's supposed to be delivered tomorrow.

She mostly plays games like Cubis and Jewel Quest, but she also uses it to do our taxes and keep her resume up to date. Oh, and we have been using our home network a lot more the past year between our three computers, storing stuff on our desktop computer but using it on the laptops.

I do not like the idea of Vista, yet many people I know who have gotten new computers with Vista, tell me it is really no problem. But if we were going to switch to XP, now, when it's new, would be a good time to do it. So I ask you all, the people I trust, Should I stay with Vista, or trash it and load up XP?

Thanks!

Scott.

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#2

Stay with Vista

Mike Farinella

>I bought a new computer when Vista came out. Yes there were growing pains but with the Service Packs, the OS is now pretty stable. You may have some issues running older software but that can be overcome by running them in the XP mode. Just my $.02 worth.

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#3

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

Curly Smith

>If your laptop has enough memory then I'd go with Vista. They released SP1 last spring, you should never buy a Microsoft OS until after the first major upgrade, and the second upgrade will come in the summer. In other words, Vista's problems have largely been solved.

How much memory is enough? MS says you need 512 MB for XP and 1 GB for Vista. But your performance will suffer unless you have 1 GB for XP and 2 GB for Vista. The more memory the better (Vista seems to have a 4 GB "sweet spot") and with Vista a better video card with more video RAM will greatly enhance your gaming... make that computing, experience.

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#4

Re: Stay with Vista

Ken Romines

>Scott

I have two sons who make a living with computers. One is a programmer with Disney, the other has a computer company and is a Microsoft VIP. They both say that the problems with Vista are a thing of the past. The hospital I work at will not let you even connect to their system if you use Vista. So, if you use Vista and do not have to connect with someone else's big system you are probably ok.

Ken

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#5

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

Tom Rex in TX

>My wife has embroidery software that will not run on Vista.

I would make sure that any software that you us will run on Vista.

Personally, I do not like Vista.

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#6

Re: Stay with Vista

Nick Tuzzolino

>I bought a HP with Vista when it was a new thing. I have talked to repair people in India more than my own family. Lots of problems, eventually resolved.

What are Service Packs and what is "OS"? This sounds like it may be of help in the future. TIA Nick

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#7

Windows 7?

Jerry Nicholson

>I won't touch VISTA but I am playing with the Windows 7 Beta on a single core Athlon 2400 system with 1gb RAM and I am fairly well impressed. On that system, Win 7 is a little slower than XP SP2 and on a par with Ubuntu 7.10 and LinuxMint 5. (Yeah I know - Linux is supposed to be faster than XP but that has not been my experience at all). BTW I tried Win 2000 on some REALLY OLD machines (300 or 400 mhz with 192 to 256 mb RAM) and it works at least as well as Win98SE and far better than any of the dozens of versions of Linux that I tried on those computers.

I have had some first hand reports that Win 7 (Beta) has far fewer compatibility issues than VISTA. You probably won't want to wait for a computer with Win 7 though - it might be 6 months before it is released.

Jerry

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#8

Personal opinion—not a fact in sight

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I was not a big Vista fan. When I bought a couple of computers after the rollout, I went to the trouble of getting XP versions straight from Dell (bypassing the big boxes). My reasoning (both for the decision and the availability) was that I couldn't imagine that any of the huge corporations with huge IT departments were going to gamble on an "A" model of any OS fresh out of Beta. I was right, which solved the availability issue. I don't think very many of them (the corporations) have flocked to Vista yet.

I'm glad I did what I did. In my opinion, Vista is turning out to be the ME (Millenium Edition—perhaps the most despised OS of any century) of the end of the decade. I have never been an early adopter and the wisdom of that paradigm has never yet been compromised in my personal experience.

Rod

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#9

Thanks!

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>I may have her try the Vista. It sounds like it may work. I will keep my fingers crossed! Most of her programs are really pretty current, except for maybe her old version of MS Office which she will want to carry over.

She got 3gb of memory, and I think this one had an upgraded video "card". I will do a clone of her current hard drive onto an external drive tonight. Then we will just start loading stuff onto the new laptop when it gets here. Wish me luck! She has even come up with a use for her old laptop! She wants to load it up with music and take it to work as kind of a portable music player.

Rod - The county courthouse where I work won't allow Vista in the building yet, either. But then it amazes me that they've adopted Windows already, instead of DOS, and don't even ask me how they feel about the Internet! ;-)

Thank you all! To infinity and beyond!

Scott.

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#10

Re: OT - XP or Vista?MN: Buy a Mac

Justin Szeliga

>

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#11

I agree, Rod.

Dan Mitchell

>I build my own PCs. My current setup is a dual-boot configuration with XP Home on one hard drive and XP Pro on another. At one time, I also ran the betas of Vista in both 32 and 64 bit as 2ndary OS's on this machine. Also, about 1 year ago, I had to select a work laptop for my wife, with her employer to pay the tab. A that time, only Lenovo & HP had laptops with the features she wanted running XP. We went with Lenovo.

I've know several peoply who've had difficulty with Vista, particularly regarding existing applications. There's just no advantage to adopting an OS right out of beta testing, and a lot of reason not to.

Dan

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#12

you must have missed the question

John K Jordan

>I don't think buying a Mac would help with Scott's question.

1) His wife already bought a Dell.

2) XP and Vista are not engineered to run on a typical Mac processor.

Scott - One of our computers has Vista (and works fine), but I personally don't like the way Vista operates and the way it handles resources. It works fine for my wife who doesn't know and doesn't want to know what's going on inside.

I purchased this Dell E6400 laptop with XP Pro and I'm quite happy with it. I actually prefer Win2000 and use it on my 3D graphics and video workstations, but it's hard to find these days.

JKJ

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#13

Re: Stay with Vista

Mike Farinella

>There is one Service Pack that came out some months after initial release that fixed a myriad of problems. OS = operating system.

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#14

Trash 'em both and buy a Mac.

Ed in Lawrence, KS

>

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#15

Re: Trash 'em both and buy a Mac.

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Ditto!

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#16

Thanks!!

Nick Tuzzolino

>

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#17

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

BobP

>Scott,

I have been using Vista on my laptop for over a year now and it has served me well. I will admit that I do not play games (other than the MahJong that came with Vista) on my computer so my comments do not cover the gaming. The "loog & feel" of Vista is a bit different. This annoyed me in the beginning. There are options to convert things over to a "Classic" view which makes things look more like XP. Vista has enhanced security built into the operating system's kernel (core?) and as such you will be asked if you realy, realy want to do a particular task. This comes up when you are installing new software (and at other times as well). All you have to do is click "continue" to confirm that you realy want to write the new program to the hard disk. If a malicious program or malicious web site tries to load a program you will know about it because the OS will ask your permission to continue. Some folk find this annoying but it is a small price to pay for a bit of extra security.

You mentioned sharing info that is on other computers on your home network. I do the same using "Remote Desktop" from my laptop to my desktop PC that runs XP. Vista can access the XP computer and use its resources (via remote desktop) but the invers is not true. It appears that the security of Vista will not allow the "older" XP remote desktop client to access its resources. This OK for my needs because I am usualy sitting with the laptop wanting to get resources from the XP unit.

Vista and I have learned to get along just fine but it did take a while for me to "let go" and accept the fact that it was not XP.

Enjoy to new toy ;>)

BobP (retired computer guy for a large university and computer skills teacher for senior citizens)

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#18

yikes, even more who misunderstood the question

John K Jordan

>

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#19

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

Fred Davis

>Glad to hear from a expert Bob, I was starting to feel like a second class citzen running Vista Home Premium. ;-))

FredD

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#20

Re: yikes, even more who misunderstood the questio

Justin Szeliga

>Nah, understood the question, just as a member of the Cult Of Mac, I just shoot that answer out to any PC OS problem. From the stuff I've read about Vista & it's problems, not in depth but a bit here & there, it seems analogous to buying a Pinto with the recall body work around the gas tank having been done. Might be OK now, but I'm leery about buying things that need so much repair to work properly. Went to a Mac in 2002 after listening to 2 guys talk for hours about MS-Dos & Windows related crashes, viruses, & related problems while another guy kept chiming in "doesn't happen with a Mac!"

Smugly

Justin

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#21

Re: yikes, even more who misunderstood the questio

John K Jordan

>I spent years doing tech support for 3D graphics software to a worldwide audience, all PC based. (The best 3D software will not run on a Mac) Read the forum messages and you'd think all PC operating systems were a cesspool of problems.

However, I ran multiple computers and NEVER had a crash in three years. The difference: I was careful about what I loaded onto my machines. I often didn't reboot for months.

I worked in a department where most of the artists used Macs AND PCs. Guess which had the most problems with stability? The Macs. Crashing all the time, strange lockups, pains in the neck.

Talk to enough people and you will find stories on both sides, for and against. I think either will do the job.

JKJ

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#22

Re: OT - XP or Vista? Follow-up

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Here's another big thank-you to all who responded! Yes, even you Mac guys!

First of all, I am amazed what you can buy nowadays for $500 if you're a careful shopper! This new laptop is a slick, fast machine!

When we unpacked it and turned it on it asked about doing an easy transfer from an old computer, so we tried it. It wasn't all that easy, and it sure was inconsistent about what it transferred, but it did eventually get most stuff over. We also have the network and E-Mail working, but they took a couple of tries. The one game she has loaded runs great. So, all things considered, everything is good so far! I remember when we got our first machine with windows, and it was kind of scary then, too!

My next project is to start gathering components to build up a new desktop computer! One of the computer guys at the county where I work is willing to help me. Wish me luck! And suggestions are quite welcome!

Scott.

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#23

Re: OT - XP or Vista? Follow-up

Dan Donaldson

>Run Linux on it ;-)

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#24

Lee Grindinger

Vista, here I come

Lee Grindinger

>Circumstances have compelled me to get a new laptop with Vista, I've no other options but Mac and we have a Mac I don't care for. This new machine has 4 gb ram so it should run fine, at least better than my current machine with Alzheimers. If it's too bad I'll switch back to XP at my own expense but I wonder how much is hype and how much is real..., I clearly remember the early XP criticisms.

Lee

Re: OT - XP or Vista?

#25

Re: Vista, here I come

Howard Norman

>Lee, I am glad to see someone post that they are not satisfied with a Mac. I used Mac for many years but eventually found them wanting and switched to a PC about ten years or so ago. I worked for Motorola and at one time we were required to buy Mac's at work because we were suppling the processor chips to Apple along with IBM. I have no experience with the currant Macs but I have always felt that Mac users were mainly a cult, that includes myself when I was using a Mac.