Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Replacing shop lighting

Posts

Replacing shop lighting

#1

Replacing shop lighting

Chris in MD

>I am getting ready to replace the fluorescent lights in my shop and have read the FWW artcile by Mr Lindsey. But I dont have an answer to the question I have.

My shop space is 27' by 27' and before it had 5 fixtures with 2 each 60W 8' tubes. THe lighting was good but better would be 7 fixtures, and I was planning on 8' HO 110W fixtures as opposed to the lower wattage ones from before.

My electrician suggests that I get the energy saver fixtures that are 4-4' bulbs at 34W a bulb. He claims that with the T-8 bulbs that the lights are just as bright and use less energy. I have have nothing to support or dispute this except usually less watts means less lumens and light.

The fixtures at HD do not indicate the number of lumens on the fixture. I suppose I can look at the lamps and calculate.

Does anypone have any experiance to lend to this decision?

Thanks in advance

Chris

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#2

Re: Replacing shop lighting

Fred Davis

>I would opt for HO every time , even tho I know next to nothing about the lights your electrician recommended, HO will light in cold weather if your shop is unheated instantly , standard tubes and ballasts will not.

Ask him if the T-8 compares cost wise initially and performance wise with HO.

Price of replacement tubes are a factor also.

FredD

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#3

Re: Replacing shop lighting

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Don't know if this helps or not, but I recently added a 2 bulb 48" T-8 fixture to my shop and it is a LOT brighter than the older t-12s that I have in other parts of the shop.

The older we get the more light we need.

Bob

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#4

Re: Replacing shop lighting

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>T-8 lamps with electronic ballasts will light at low temps with needing to be high output. T-12 HO or HOO lamps are significantly more expensive to purchase and operate. I am considering a lighting retrofit at work and 4ft 3 lamp t-5's are being suggested to replace big Metal Halide HID lamps, with a decrease in operating expense and increase in lumens

glc

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#5

Re: Replacing shop lighting

wilbur

>The fixtures won't tell you how much light the bulbs will put out. You'll have to get that information from the bulbs themselves.

Here's a point of comparison:

A Sylvania 40 watt 48" T12 Deluxe Daylight bulb puts out 2,180 lumens at 40 watts.

http://www.servicelighting.com/Sylvania-24477-F40-DX-T12-Straight-Linear-Fluorescent-Light-Bulb

The same bulb in T8 form puts out 2,750 lumens at 32 watts.

http://www.servicelighting.com/Sylvania-22175-FO32-765-ECO-T8-Straight-Linear-Fluorescent-Light-Bulb

(Note: when comparing bulbs you have to make sure that apples are apples, and you are not comparing a cool white bulb with a daylight bulb, etc.)

If you are replacing all the lighting, I'd go with T8 bulbs. They do use less energy, and T12's are going to be harder to come by, as they are being phased out.

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#6

Re: Replacing shop lighting

David Sparks

>I recently installed several T8 fixtures in my shop. They are a great improvement over T12 fixtures. They put out more light, don't buzz, and use less energy. The company I work for recently replaced hundreds of T12 fixtures with T8 ones. I thought they were crazy to spend all the money until I researched how little time it takes before the fixtures and labor are paid for through energy cost savings. I think it was less than a two year payback with the savings to continue afterwards.

I still have my old T12 fixtures in my shop, so you can really see how much better the new T8 fixtures next to them are. When I can afford it I'm going to convert my old fixtures to T8s. I've read that the T12 tubes will eventually be done away with completely, but I don't know if that's true or not.

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#7

Re: Replacing shop lighting

Pete in Holland, MI

>Note: Most all new florescent bulbs are in fact brighter when new. Bout half way thru their life span, they drop by 1/4 to 1/3 of their output, then stabilize for the rest of their life.

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#8

electrician was fooled by hype

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>1. You may find my article in the Articles useful.

2. My brother in law is a lighting engineer. He warned me of the flawed "see the lamp is just as bright" claim. The T12 tubes are bigger and therefore they have more surface area (increases with square of radius) than the T8's. Therefore for the same amount of light generation their surface will appear dimmer. By searching some you can find T8's that put out almost as much light.

A large lighting store will have software to design lighting to yield what ever light intensity you want. They may also loan you a light meter and that is the definitive way to know what you have for intensity.

I am very sensitive to flicker so going to the electronic ballasts was a big improvement for me.

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#9

I Have T-8s

Mike Fitterling

>They are my shop lighting with the exception of a 3 light track light of halogens over the workbench, that I only turn on when doing critical bench work. The shop is 24 x 28 with white eight foot ceilings and white walls. I have six T-8 units, each comprised of four 4' tubes. The light is very good in the shop and my eyes have to readjust to the dimmer light when I go inside the house after being out there. Instant on and no hum. I built the shop in 2003 and have yet to change a tube. I have T-12s in the attic over the shop and it is a pain to go up there because of the wait for the lights to come on. I didn't make that mistake again when I rebuilt the garage after the hurricane knocked the old one down and I put T-8s in there, too.

Cheers,

Mike

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#10

Re: Replacing shop lighting

Tom MacGregor

>Four foot T-8's are the way to go, but not all bulbs are the same. The color of the light varies. Look for a K number in small print on one end of the bulb. A 3100K is a cool white that is generally prefered for living or bedrooms. A bulb up around 5000K or more gives a whiter light that appears brighter. I find them better for the shop.

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#11

more on comparing T8 vs T12

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Much of the comparisons being made in these posts is nothing to do with the T8 vs T12 lamp and everything to do with the ballasts in the fixture. Old T12 fixtures have a different ballast than the modern T8 fixtures. It may well be that one can't even buy an old style ballast in a modern T8 fixture. The old ballasts hum and flicker and the hum can cause the lighting fixture to vibrate in a most annoying fashion. I hate them and have gotten rid of them about the house and shop.

If you already have T12 fixtures and want the benefits of the ballast in a modern T8 fixture then all one has to do is spend a few minutes changing the old ballast in the T12 to an electronic ballast. The result will be no hum, no flicker and more light.

There are some benefits to the T8 lamp. If your shop is too bright, changing to the lower wattage (and less light) T8's is a valid choice. In doing so you may save a dollar or two a year in shop lighting. Also, the interventionist government intention is to phase out the T12 lamp. It may actually happen some day. Sometime in the future T12's may become less available and more expensive. Given this situation it makes little sense installing T12's in new construction. If the T8 fixture doesn't provide enough light then add more fixtures. I have 12 lamps above my bench to get the 200 ft cd at the work surface that I need for detailed work.

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#12

T8 = more lumens/watt - not hype

wilbur

>T8 bulbs overall are more efficient than T12 bulbs. If you look on the GE website for their fluorescent bulbs, and look at the 32 watt T8 4 foot bulbs and compare them to 40 watt T12 four foot bulbs, the T8 bulbs put out anywhere between 2385-2660 lumens, while the T12s put out 2775-2910 lumens, although one of the basic T12 bulbs they list only puts out 1870 lumens. Working through the math, you'll see that the T8 bulbs put out 74-83 lumens/watt, while the T12s put out 69-72 lumens/watt, which is a 7-13% increase in efficiency in favor of the T8s.

Is a 7-13% increase in efficiency worthwhile? Judging by the lines I see at Woodcraft when they have their 10% off everything sale, I would guess so. :@)

And in some cases, like the one I mentioned above, the T8 bulb actually puts out more lumens than its T12 equivalent.

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#13

Re: T8 = more lumens/watt - not hype

wilbur

>Forgot to add: here's the GE lighting website.

http://genet.gelighting.com/

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#14

Rick L

Re: T-5 is the best you can get...

Rick L

>but the T-8 are good and affordable. Surprised no mentioned the T-5. Unbelievably bright and high on the kelvin scale to match daylight. The higher the K rating the closer to daylight. T-5's blow away T-12's.

Re: Replacing shop lighting

#15

read original post

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>"He claims that with the T-8 bulbs that the lights are just as bright and use less energy."

There is no argument that 32 watts is less energy than 40, so that clearly was not the hype I was criticizing. Your own data shows that the T12's produce more light although the T8 lamp itself appears brighter because it is smaller. The electrician's statement has become a common myth in lighting.

As far as comparing efficiency between lamps there are two factors that must be considered. Efficiency must be compared between lamps with identical phosphors and lamps powered by equivalent ballasts. So I don't know if T8 format is inherently more efficient either when the lamp is new or after a few weeks of use when the efficiency degrades. It is not a significant factor to me.

For most home owners the quality (color balance and temperature) and amount of light are what is important. I pay more than $10 for 4' lamps to be able to get a fluorescent light that matches incandescent lighting in the living area. These lamps also happen to be especially bright. They are lights, more is better.