We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>When I built my workbench a few years ago, I patterned it off of a typical european cabinetmakers bench. It has a front vise at the left front corner and a tail vise built into the right front corner. I am always trying to use just a tiny corner of the bench and find the tail vise uncomfortable. I am left handed.
While doing some reading about workbenches, I think my problem is that I should have reversed the vise locations. I believe, virtually all benches are set up for people who are right handed.
Should I have reversed the vise locations? I am needing to rebuild the base anyway (I underbuilt it and it wobbles now) so as part of my bench rehab project I could switch them.
>The only issue I can think of is that if you are into using molding or plough planes, they often only come in right hand configurations, and having your workbench set up for "lefty" use might make workholding issues a little more difficult.
On the other hand, I'm right handed, and I often find myself using planes left handed and backwards just to deal with grain reversal because I'm too lazy to reposition and reclamp the board.
>I made my bench "opposite to normal," with the face vise on the right, tail vise left. Interestingly, I find this occasionally gets in the way. Example: My shop is small, so I haven't figured out how to put in a saw bench yet (I could, but it would mean getting rid of the table saw, a move I'm not quite ready for), and I from time to time do large cutoffs off the left end of the bench, at which time the tail vise gets in the way.
However, for grunt planing - edge jointing, face planing between bench dogs, stuff like that, it's nice to have the face vise on the right and tail vise on the left, because (a) in planing edges, it's good to go toward the vise, because any tendency to vibration is damped out, and (b) in planing faces flat on the bench, it's better to plane toward a dog than toward the vise, because the dog is more rigid. Sometimes, you don't even need a vise - planing toward the dog is sufficient to hold a board in place.
This gets into a whole discussion of whether you need a tail vise at all - Chris Schwarz makes some pretty strong arguments in his workbench book that other techniques have some advantages - but that goes beyond your question, and I have no direct experience with non-tail-vise benches, so I'll stop after raising the question.
Like most lefties, I've learned to work right handed when I need to - as Wilbur Pan mentioned, molding planes and a lot of the fenced planes in general (rabbets, for instance) are designed for right handed use. These tend, though, to be lighter work, so planing toward the tail vise is not a big issue.
>I am left-handed as well and I have my front vise in the typical left corner.
I toyed with the idea of mounting on the other end (many years ago), but decided on the left side because of years of built-up habits (it's a right-handed world and us left-handers live with that daily).
On a somewhat related note, a few years ago I started shaving and brushing my teeth with my right hand (scary I know). At first it was very awkward but now it's second nature. I did this after skimming a book on mental gymnastics as a means to prevent diseases such as Alzheimer's. I can't remember the book anymore though.
>I am left handed and built my first bench right handed. When I built my current bench I went left handed and like it much better. It just seems to be "right" to me, more so than the other way around.