Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Wood bending question

Posts

Wood bending question

#1

Wood bending question

Pete in Holland, MI

>I am rebuilding a couple really old kitchen type press back chairs for a friend. They want me to put on a pair of the bent oak "L" brackets to support the back. I have purchased a couple pair of bent oak brackets, and they are bent to about 90 degrees out of the package. I need to relax them 10 degrees or so.

Am I correct in thinking that putting them in some boiling water then, as they relax, clamp them in the new angle desired?

Thoughts ?

Thanks !

Re: Wood bending question

#2

Re: Wood bending question

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I think, in general, that's the right approach, but I have questions.

I always have questions.

Wood steam bends best green. These are likely not. Are they finished in some way? A finish would influence how the wood took the steam.

Are they seriously structural, or mostly decorative?

Have you tried to install them as they are, without the steaming? 10* isn't all that much to finesse, really.

Are these heirloom chairs, or are they fixing something that will look different, but OK? You're doing two. How many are there total?

How big a risk is there in trying the steam and having it screw up? And do you have the setup for the process? It's cheap and easy to assemble, but there's a lot of it to do it right, and you'll be at it for several hours. If nothing screws up, that is.

Addy protocol: I've been doing this for all of three weeks in a Windsor chair class, but have watched the video from Michael Fortune and St Roy on doing these... Haven't stayed in a Holiday Inn for some time, now, either...

Re: Wood bending question

#3

JL

Re: Wood bending question

JL

>I would first try and bend them into shape as is - on the general theory "it will fit if you force it".

Steaming or wetting a piece a second time can be problematic. It depends on how they "set" the piece after they bent it. The lignin usually sets after wetting or steaming followed by heating. Sometimes steaming or wetting a piece again can weaken the piece. Not necessarily a good idea for supporting brackets!

I've "resteamed" wood before. I've had a few successes. I was trying to correct the angles and alignment of some crests (fans if you prefer). I screwed up and made the bending form slightly off. I cracked one and successfully rebent three.

If there is finish on the brackets, it would be a good idea to remove it. I'd say give it a try. As you purchased the brackets, you can always buy a couple of spares :).

Re: Wood bending question

#4

Re: Wood bending question

Ralph Lipeles

>You would probably do better to steam them. Less water will get into the wood. If you soak them in boiling water it will probably take quite a while before they are dry enough to stain and finish. Don't forget to bend them a little bit more then you need to allow for springback. Lastly, the pieces are close to an inch in diameter and wood is a poor conductor of heat. Allow a good hour of steaming.

Re: Wood bending question

#6

Sounds like you are making it hard.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Can't you just cut the angle on the ends to what you need. 10� is about 3/8" at 2". If that is too much to take off of the heel of one end, then take 5� off of each end, or shorten its length on the the end, if it looks over bent when you take it off of only one end.

Re: Wood bending question

#7

Re: Wood bending question

Jim Hoeller

>I have replaced several sets on that type of chair and found the easiest and most reliable method is to resaw thin strips (1/8" or less), surface them and glue and clamp them up on a form of the radius needed. Round over the parts with a spokeshave and sand to desired finish. I use 2x construction scraps for the forms.

Re: Wood bending question

#8

Re: Sounds like you are making it hard.

Pete in Holland, MI

>Each leg of the "L" will be about 4-5" long. 10 degrees is more than they can be flexed. Besides, they would be trying to pull the seat back forward rather than supporting at it's current angle. Sanding them to the angle will lead them to be really thin on the ends.

I'll work on making some steam and letting them relax some. Keep you posted on what I encounter.

Thanks for your input !

Re: Wood bending question

#9

While you are waiting for the water to boil

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>I would suggest that you maybe try drawing what you want, and listen to what I am trying to tell you.

If you want to change that angle, by ten degrees, you can do that, and end up with the end looking just like it does now, only the overall length will be slightly shorter, and the thickness will be the same at the heel of the bevel as it is right now, which is where I would expect the screw to exit the part to take advantage of the most captive wood.

I am telling you that the cut which is on the end, can be shifted along that arc, and still look the same, while the angle gets wider as you move around the arc. The part will get shorter, but only by about 11% of its present length.

Also, your logic of relaxing the wood is flawed. When wood has been steam bent properly, the cells have a new memory, in that the cells have slipped by each other, then re-bonded to this new shape. If you try to steam and un-bend it, you will not be able to keep the cells under compression, which will likely cause it to split on the tension side, which will be your top.