Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Which method is stronger?

Posts

Which method is stronger?

#1

Which method is stronger?

lee beeden

>Pocket screws or Biscuits for face frame construction?

Two identical cabinets, both face frames attached to the sides using biscuits.

However the face frames construction differs in that one is built using biscuits and the other with pocket screws (no mortise and tenons).

My instincts says the biscuits

Any comments appreciated

Thanks

Lee

Re: Which method is stronger?

#2

Re: Which method is stronger?

paul waddle

>I would go with pocket screws as stronger to attach faceframe to box. This just MHO,no scientic supporting docs.For the frame itself,I'd go with pocket screws and glue. pw

Re: Which method is stronger?

#3

Re: Which method is stronger?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I would tend to agree with you, if only because you don't have the variability of the screw driving. Bear in mind that my training is in economics, not engineering, and that I like the pace of biscuits vs pocket screws, and the fact that glue can be used elsewhere, and the joints adjusted, if I'm willing to mess with carrying all the big clamps out to the glue up space...

Both work, BTW, in my limited experience. Glue is better with !#%$#@^ing Chinese plywood, though.

Re: Which method is stronger?

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Which method is stronger?

Dale Lenz

>Recall reading many moons ago comparing end to side grain joint and think M/T came out on top. Floating tendon, close a biscuit, somewhere below M/T, but above the pocket screw.

Re: Which method is stronger?

#5

Re: Which method is stronger?

Fred Davis

>Biscuits in additional to the glue bond , have a mechanical bond that pockets screws don't even though they are screwed together , they can come loose , biscuits have many applications that pocket screws can't approach and in narrow rails , they remove a large amount of wood which can over the years in drawer openings for instance , cause the rail to split .

This is the area where I have experienced the most repair work , done by others with pocket screws.

But on the other hand , you can disassemble a pocket screw joint , not easy to do with biscuits without damage to the wood.

FredD

Re: Which method is stronger?

#6

Re: Which method is stronger?

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Fine Woodworking # 203 (February 2009) has an article on this. They found that the pocket screw joint was stronger than the biscuit joint. I'm surprised at this result!

Re: Which method is stronger?

#7

Re: Which method is stronger?

Thomas S Stockton

>My guess would be the screws if glue is used in the joint and your talking about a 2" wide face frame. The reason being is that to join something that narrow you would be using FF size biscuits which have very little surface area. I think the best way to reenforce the joint is to make sure the face frame is glued to the cabinet face. Most cabinet shops just nail them on or use as little glue as possible.

Tom