Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

Posts

Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#1

Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

Randy in Iowa

>Hello Fellow Sawdust Nuts:

I'm building a Harvey Ellis style console. The 5' console will be used to support a flat screen TV. The length of the console will be divided into equal 1/3's - the center section will be open and will house the center speaker and some electronics components. There will be two sections on each end behind doors. The doors will be inset style. I am concerned since the majority of the load will be in the center of the piece....especially since the doors will be inset - I don't want the piece to sag. I'm thinking that I might place another bottom stretcher a few inches behind the arched stretcher - this would allow me to MOSTLY visually hide some additional supports in the center at the bottom of the project. I'm wondering if there may be a better solution that I hadn't considered?

Thanks bunches

Randy


img

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#2

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreci

Randy in Iowa

>Here's a photo from the end perspective.

Thanks

Randy


img

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#3

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreci

Doug in Denver

>I'm not quite sure what other structural compenents you are adding based on the design. What sort of dividers will divide the three sections? How will they be attached? How will the top be attached and how thick? If you put a top on it right now and loaded it up on the top only with a tv plus you sitting on it, braces on the bottom where you suggest will make no difference because the weight will all be transferred out to the corner posts. If you put speakers etc on the base as currently designed, I don't think you have a sagging problem because that looks plenty strong. If you will have a sagging problem it will be because your top has such a long span, and not a lot of structure holding it. But braces below won't cure that. But a couple dividers should be all you need.

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#4

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreci

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>You have cause for concern!

The Sagulator says your design will sag 1" with a 3/4" cherry top, 1/2" initially and another 1/2" over time assuming a 100 pound TV. A plywood back will stiffen it up if you are planning to have one, and the dividers and lower stretcher will offer some support but it's still a saggy situation.

You can use the Sagulator to calculate how wide your extra bottom stretcher needs to be to support the weight. I assume the TV weight will be carried down throught the dividers onto the extra stretcher(s).

Another possibility is to put an additional foot under each divider. These could be placed half way between the front and back so they're not visible.

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#5

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreci

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>A piece of steel C channel across the 5' span should do the trick.

Clint

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#6

I disagree - assuming dividers

DouginDenver

>I disagree that you have a problem. The sagulator is for unsupported shelves. I agree it will sag if you put a top on it as it is now - but again, supports on the bottom will do NOTHING to remedy that. But if you put in two strucutral dividers to divide the case into thirds, and securely fasten on a top, you and your family will be able to stand on that without it sagging. Really.

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#7

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreci

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Randy,

I too like the idea of extra feet beneath the dividers. The weight is directly supported, so no sag. Further, its an invisable fix, and an uncomplicated one to accomplish.

George

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#8

Re: Plus 1

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>You can hide the steel pretty effectively, too. If not C channel, then double angle steel. Those legs are sturdy enough to carry most TVs.

I don't THINK Clint was speaking tongue in cheek. I'm not.

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#9

Nope; I was serious

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#10

Recently built a similiar one

Marvin Horn

>White Oak 66" long, 18" wide, 13/16" top, two vertical dividers.

It will support several hundred pounds with no visible deflection.

As always, I overengineered it.

My 52" TV only weighs 71#

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#11

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreci

Michael Wilkins

>I recently completed a TV cabinet very similar to your design, with 2 dividers in the middle for components and speaker. You should not have any concerns with structural integrity, unless you park your pickup truck on the top. This type design, with dadoes, and a plywood back screwed to the back gives the piece lots of strength.

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#12

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreci

Randy in Iowa

>Thanks a bunch guys!!!

Yes, I do plan to have a plywood panel across the back and yes, there will be 2 center dividers.

Again, I really appreciate your thoughts.

Randy

Re: Console - Structural Concern, Opinions Appreciated

#13

Re: Console - Structural Concern: My solution

Pete in Holland, MI

>Built something similar in January. Similar concerns. Cabinet was divided pretty much into 3rds. Doors on the outer two cells, open in the middle with adjustable shelves.

Yes, the plywood on the back does help (glued & nailed), but the front has very little structure.

With a scrap sheet of 1/4" plywood, I created a box beam out of the lower 3/4" deck. Added 3 1" spacers withwise and around the edges, then glued & stapled the plywood. Created a hollow-core door type thing. Cabinet is rock solid now. Much stronger than a wood beam for the thickness too !

Look me up if you have further questions.