Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

OT New driveway questions

Posts

OT New driveway questions

#1

OT New driveway questions

mdclor

>Good evening to all,

Our driveway is currently gravel, steep and about 300 feet long. We get a little snow here in the mountains outside Albuquerque and that makes the driveway dangerously slippery, to the point of sliding down it with 4 wheel drive. Did I mention the 60* curve about 1/2 way down? ;) I would like to get it paved, but here is where the questions begin:

1. Any thoughts as to whether having it paved would make it more or less slick when snow covered? This year I shoveled, but that is no fun at 5am.

2. Is there a preference for black top or concrete? Could concrete be left with a rough surface? I have been told that paving will make it worse. We had blacktop in Upstate NY and that melted off well on the rare occasions that the sun did break through the clouds.

3. Can concrete be colored black enough to facilitate snow melting when the clouds clear, normally by 10am except for rare occasions, so I'm told.

4. What are the pros and cons for concrete vs blacktop? How do they compare price-wise?

5. Any other thoughts, considerations, suggestions?

If it makes any difference, I will need to cover about 5000 square feet to include the flare out for the 2 car garage and a turn around.

TIA,

Merle

Re: OT New driveway questions

#2

Re: OT New driveway questions

Howard Norman

>I live at 6700' in the mountains of AZ but have a gravel driveway. I know one guy here that paved his driveway with concrete. From what I hear he is very disappointed and sorry that he did that. I have a next door neighbor who put in a black top driveway two years ago. He is very happy with it. Once the clouds move out the snow will melt much faster on the black top droveway than the concrete driveway. Of course if you have two feet of snow it doesn't make much difference.

Re: OT New driveway questions

#3

Re: OT New driveway questions

John E in SC

>Can't really answer your questions about the snow being from SC, although I have a concrete driveway, and the one time we got a little ice a few years ago, it was VERY slick - there is a slight uphill from the house, and I tried to get up it with a Durango (2WD, but heavy as a tank) and it just wasn't going to happen. The ice melted on the blacktop road in front of the house before it did on the concrete driveway. As far as the price, I think you will find the concrete will be much more expensive than asphalt, although it's been 5-6 years since I priced anything. I'd probably go with asphalt if I were in your shoes.

HTH,

John

Re: OT New driveway questions

#4

Re: OT New driveway questions

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>How about a bobsled sweep on the outside corner? heheheh

Re: OT New driveway questions

#5

Asphalt in the south???

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Having grown up in the north, I found it very odd looking to see that all the driveways here in the south were concrete rather than asphalt. But remembering those hot days in the summer up north when the sun heated the black asphalt driveways so hot that bicycle and motorcycle stands, and sometimes even tires, sank into the driveways, I realized asphalt driveways just wouldn't work well here in the south.

I really can't recall seeing any asphalt driveways here in the south in the last 14 years. Heck, alot of the highways are concrete instead of asphalt.

Also, having spent all those years years throwing salt and gravel onto driveways in the north to keep from slipping on the ice and snow, I can't imagine how replacing gravel with concrete would be an improvement to the situation.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT New driveway questions

#6

Re: Asphalt in the south???

John K Jordan

>Mark, asphalt is the most common driveway around here (East TN). We had one at our last house and I've never had or seen a heat-related problem. Perhaps they use better quality materials here. JKJ

Re: OT New driveway questions

#7

I think it depends

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>On which contracting buisness the local commissioners brother-in-law was in. Concrete or Ashphalt. Actually the prefrence in a given area can be timing. If the price of oil is way up a lot more concrete driveways go in. Around here (home sites) the area where cars will be parked gets concrete, the driveway if it is of any length get painted black, or red cinders. From a practical point of view, once it gets covered with snow it really doen's make much difference. A hard surface is easier to plow of shovel than gravel, black will melt a bit quicker than gray and is probablly a bit cheaper to install on a sloping site. A few of the steeper driveways around here actually have snowmelt cables or piping in them. but that is an whole 'nother story With a snowmelt system it REALLY needs to be concrete.

glc

Re: OT New driveway questions

#8

A few OT New driveway answers

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I live in NW PA and we average over 85" of snow annually. Currently we are pushing 140" for this year. I have 200+ feet of driveway. It started out as gravel, but we have converted it all to concrete now. I chose concrete for several reasons. Mostly it was lowerer long term maintenance than blacktop.

I use a snow blower to remove the snow. When the drive way was gravel, I had to set the blower up so that it left 1/2-3/4" of snow behind so I wasn't sucking up gravel all the time. Even so I would still have to rake gravel out of the lawn each spring and the snow left behind packed into thick slabs of ice each winter.

Once it was paved, I was able to lower the snow blower so that I leave 1/4" or less snow behind. I still get some ice build up in shaded areas, but most of the driveway melts off when the sun comes out. If it were black top, the melt off would be even faster. My driveways has some slope and it can get slick after ice storms, but I have never slid off the driveway since it has been paved. The surface is smooth enough to roller skate on.

Concrete can be colored for additional cost which might help with the melting.

If you don't remove the snow and drive over it packing it down, it probably makes little difference whether the driveway is dirt, gravel, concrete or black top in terms of becoming slippery.

Coarse sand spread on snow will aid in melting and make it less slippery. Salt also helps but has down sides.

Lee

Re: OT New driveway questions

#9

By the way

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>I get to deal with snow and snow removal at work most of the year, including several thousand (30-35) square feet of deck and walkways with various kinds of snowmelting systems.

glc

Re: OT New driveway questions

#10

Re: OT New driveway questions

GalenV in Iowa

>You said "5. Any other thoughts, considerations, suggestions?"

My sister has lived in Albuquerque for a long time but originaly from Iowa where we get more snow. Must be why she has three Subaru that are full time four wheel drive though.

From what I see in Albuquerque everyone needs to stay home and off the roads as most do not do too well on snow. Like playing bumper cars on your roads.

You folks have gotten more snow the last few years than you know how to deal with. Hard to believe global warming.

Put driveway cost into woodworking tools then:

Best thought for snow days stay home and turn wood.

Galen

Re: OT New driveway questions

#11

Re: OT New driveway questions

Thomas S Stockton

>In my experiance you will slide even more on ashphalt, but if you get a lot of sun the snow will melt quicker if you can get most of it off. The upside as others have said is it will be easier to remove the snow when paved. I would talk to a couple of paving people and see what they say or do what we do when we expect heavy snow and park at the end of the drive and hike in. Our drive is a little less than 1/4 mile so it can be interesting with a bunch of grocries.

Tom

Re: OT New driveway questions

#12

Ah, I meant south-south

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Oppps, I meant south-south...... Atlanta to Miami... that's the south I know :)

Happy

Re: OT New driveway questions

#13

my experience

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In a similar situation I installed a concrete driveway in 1970. Nothing has been done to it since and it is as good as the day it was installed. Meanwhile, my friends with asphalt are adding sealer every few years and after some time repaving. Comparative cost needs to be determined locally, including maintenance costs.

As far as the black and melting snow consideration, if the driveway is covered by snow it is white and reflective regardless of what is underneath. And if the layer of ice is thin enough to be transparent I think either surface is going to melt similarly. My concrete melted off on a sunny day. The decision really comes down to installation cost and long term cost.

Re: OT New driveway questions

#14

Re: Asphalt in the south???

John in Calgary

>Ah, you (former) easterner's and your salt, I think a few have taken over the plowing and sanding department in our fine city of Calgary. This winter, and last night again, they have been 'pre-salting' our roads. Unfortunately, if you pre-salt (or salt period) the roads when the temperature dives down below -10 C, all you get is a frozen layer underneath the fresh snow. So, 1/2" of fresh ice with 3" of snow on top leads to the ABS working hard in my car this morning trying to slow down before I took out the pedestrians crossing the street - it took half a block from not-very-fast downtown speeds to stop, and that was with a good set of snow tires.

John

Re: OT New driveway questions

#15

Must be

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>When I was in Detroit, years ago now, I had a small (250cc) motorcycle fall over in a parking lot when the side stand sank through the asphalt.

I know Michigan practice with asphalt was kind of casual - Ann Arbor used to "repave" a lot of its streets every Spring by spreading the unadulterated asphalt, throwing 4" of gravel on top of it, and letting the cars push the gravel into the asphalt. So it may well have been weaker, not being properly compressed.

It made for very exciting motorcycling for a couple of weeks every Spring, though less exciting than riding in the winter, when the slush was like riding on a mixture of ball bearings and banana peels.

Re: OT New driveway questions

#16

The question no one asked.......

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>The question that everyone was too polite to ask.....

If there's snow on the ground, why would you want to leave the house in the first place??? You must have left New York to live in New Mexico for a reason, right? :)

Did I mention I was swimming at a water slide park with the kids two Sundays ago. And snorkling, too? Oh, sorry, that was in Miami :)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT New driveway questions

#17

We can do that here in year round

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>We have an in door water park here in Erie, PA so we can go swimming and water sliding year round in compfort and it never rains at the park.

Lee

Re: OT New driveway questions

#18

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

One exception...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>LARGE gravel--like the ~2-3" stuff (I don't know the materials-supply name for it). The breaks in its surface are large enough that ice won't fill them in. I've been on a few new-construction sites where the drive was done this way and never cleared. I've never owned a 4WD, and never had a problem getting up and down those driveways, even after everyone else packed them down good.

Jason

Re: OT New driveway questions

#19

Re: OT New driveway questions

Bill White

>If you go with asphalt, make SURE that the road bed is properly prepared, and that you have an adequate thickness applied. Some of those squirrels will give ya a cheap quote then fudge on the material and prep side.

Bill

Re: OT New driveway questions

#20

What sort of.....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>What sort of exotic reef fishes can you see swimming in the indoor pool? ;)

Sorry, I had to ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT New driveway questions

#21

Re: OT New driveway questions

Ellis Walentine, Host

>We had a steep, quarter-mile long gravel driveway for the first 30 years we lived here. Every year, more and more gravel and grit would wash down to the parking area between the barn and the sheds and the drive would get rutted and nasty. After grading and graveling it every year or two, we finally coughed up for blacktop and it has really made the approach more civilized. Now people with nice cars can come visit us without losing their exhaust systems or getting their tires punctured by sharp stones. That isn't to say that concrete wouldn't have been appreciated as well, but the cost would have been quite a bit more.

Regarding traction, I think the gravel offered more traction in thin snow cover, but once there is a pack or a glazing of ice (as there always seems to be here in eastern PA), I don't sense a lot of difference. The amount of money and aggravation that we save in tire wear and suspension parts is helping to pay off the asphalt.

A couple notes: Blacktop comes in several grades. We had the smooth grade installed around the house and barn areas and what they call "airport mix," which is coarser but still pretty smooth, from there to the road. One drawback to the smooth asphalt is the "black ice" conditions you get every time it rains and freezes. I've taken a few headers and it's no fun.

Ellis

Re: OT New driveway questions

#22

Re: OT New driveway questions

mdclor

>Thanks for all the input. LOML doesn't even like roller coasters so the bob sled suggestion won't "fly". The difference between here and NY is that the sun rarely shines there and almost always does here. Also 100 " snow vs maybe 20". I like the idea of snow melt cables and will have to explore that further. Unfortunately, staying home on snow days, while very prudent, really isn't an option for another few years or longer depending on the economy. Bill's suggestion of doing concrete once and forgetting it really appeals to me. Maybe I can get it colored black enough so it would melt off as well as asphalt. Thanks for the help.

Merle

Re: OT New driveway questions

#23

Re: OT New driveway questions

GalenV in Iowa

>My sistere lives in Albuquerque and I think it is funny she owns three Subaru full time four wheel drive vehicals. Think it is from her roots here in Iowa. I hear from her all the time that none of you should be allowed to drive when it snows! Like running bumper cars till the snow melts. Your city is not set up to handle snow!

It seems global "warming" has given you a lot of snow the last few years and it stays around more! I was going to move down there but not until you get back to correct warm weather. Guess it is in the 70's today and she has the house open for fresh air!

I know you will not take my advice but for my sister's sake stay home and turn wood when it snows!

Galen

Galen

Re: OT New driveway questions

#24

Time to remove the OT from this thread

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>They don't call me a tooljunkie for nothing :)

Happy Woodworking!


img

Re: OT New driveway questions

#25

Re: OT New driveway questions

mdclor

>Galen,

I agree that the natives can't drive in snow and get absolutely crazy when there is an inch or two on the road, but being from Upstate NY and having a 4 wheel drive vehicle, I feel very comfortable and safe driving around the people doing 20 mph at the roaring speed of 30mph. Not only are they driving way slower than necessary, but they insist on driving in the middle of the road. I think the natives should stay home so the rest of us can safely get to work.

Merle