Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

Posts

bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

#1

bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

Grant in Iowa

>Hi all,

I am about to try my hand at a bentwood lamination using a vacuum press and bag.

The finished part will be a gently curved Red Oak part about 6" wide and 3/4" thick. The bend will be along the flat side of the board (Like a bent ruler, not like a horseshoe). I'd estimate the radius of the curve at around 10 feet, and the part will be about 48" long. I am planning on making the thickness of the laminations just under 1/4".

The part will form a barrel vault on a fireplace mantle for my home, so I'd like to make the glue lines as invisible as possible

I have the press figured out, and a form made.

Now the question: What type of glue to use. I have titebond yellow glue, West System Epoxy, and two part formaldehyde glue on hand.

Which would be best? I am leaning towards Epoxy with filler added, but am looking for input here.

Thanks in advance,

Grant in Iowa

Re: bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

#2

Questions.......

Barry Irby

>I have done a number of bentwood laminations but have never used a vacuum system. So I can't help with that. (I used yellow glue and Gorilla Glue, and Epoxy and they all worked, but I have no experience with using them in a vac bag.

My questions are about the vacuum system. Have you done a practice run to see if the bag will bend the pieces as you describe them? Again, I have never even seen such a system in person, but my gut tells me this won't work.

I have been wanting a bag system but times are tough and I have never gotten one. If it will do this I will even more inclined to get one.

Re: bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

#3

JL

Re: bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

JL

>Why do you feel you need a vacuum press? I've never really found it necessary for large parts. I just bend to the form and clamp it. I do have to clean it up afterward.

I don't know if your laminate layers are thin enough. You would have 3-4 layers with a total thickness of 3/4". Even though your curve is gentle, I'd worry about breakage with a 6" wide 1/4" thick piece. I'd prefer ~3/16" or less. You could have five layers and less chance of spring back.

Re: bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

#4

Re: bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Grant, I have done lots of vacuum bagging of curved parts for over 20 years. Thickened epoxy is my favorite adhesive for the process. Epoxy has all of the right properties once it has set, and works like a lubricant while making a hard bend, which isn't a problem for you, but for some projects it does matter.

Probably most people include the form inside the bag, but I usually leave it out, because it is easier to make when you leave it out. Go for it, and get that bag warm after you get the vacuum drawn. Epoxy won't cure if it is too cold.

Re: bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

#5

Re: bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>Hearkening back days of teaching the woodworking vacuum clamping class, let me offer this for your thinking.

We used Weldwood resin glue. Dark glue lines. You want a glue with long open time, and non-elastic cone cured.

Laminations need to be lots thinner, around 1/8" to 3/16" max.

Red oak is kinda splintery for this. Plan on a high failure rate. Prepare lots of pieces. Consider soaking in really hot water or steam until the wood fibers are the most pliable.

Vacuum is a good way to go because it provides 100% surface contact. Your platens need to be perfectly matched for the best success. A couple of the vacuum pump companies have videos that are helpful.

Hope that helps.

Re: bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

#6

A couple thoughts

Ellis Walentine, Host

>My rule of thumb is this: Optimal laminate thickness is the thickest that will bend to the final radius with moderate hand pressure. A 10' radius is pretty forgiving, and I think you could get away with 1/4"-thick laminates, but you'll need less clamping force with 1/8" or 3/16" strips, as others have suggested. The thinner the laminates, the less tendency for wood memory (stiffness) to cause springback, which is more of an issue if the finished lamination is freestanding and not bound or incorporated into another assembly that constrains its shape.

As for glue, you want a glue that is clear so the glue lines won't be obvious. Epoxy and two-part urea-formaldehyde glue are good choices. Powdered plastic resin glue will show dark glue lines. PVA glue will eventually creep and you'll be able to feel your glue lines on the edges of the lamination.

Regarding clamping, you can get away with a single form (either male or female). The trick, if you're not using a vacuum bag, is to distribute the pressure equally to the entire length of the lamination. I've found that a great way to do this is to use strips of Masonite as a caul, built up to a thickness that is equal to half the spacing between the clamps. And, on a 6" wide lamination, use 6" long x 2 x 2 clamping blocks between the clamps and the Masonite.

My 2�,

Ellis

Re: bentwood lamination w/ vacuum press

#7

Thanks and more info. *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

>Thanks for everyones responses and for relating applicable experience. Based on the responses, I plan to reduce my layer thickness to under 3/16", and use thickened epoxy in a heated space for the job. I will probably also do a test glueup with scrap wood before the real deal.

It is true that this type of work can be done with clamps and forms, as I have done that before. I decided it was time to take it to the next level.

I am considering this project a stepping stone to making waterskis, small boats and other more complex projects such as veneering and formed pieces in other materials. All of these aspirations are the real reason I have invested in the vacuum press and bag setup. This will be my first vacuum assisted clamping attempt. Though I have had the pump assembled for about two years now. I have only last week ordered a bag to complete the setup.

I built a venturi type vacuum pump using plans and parts from "Joewoodworker.com". The pump was a big success, and I have played with using visqueen as a bag, which met with only partial success. Too many leaks around the taped seams to be workable for an actual glue-up. It did pull my test parts tightly to the form, however, so I am sure the concept of bending in a bag over a form is sound.

An interesting fact is that 1" of mercury(Hg) of vacuum pressure can create 70 pounds of force when distributed over 1 square foot. This means that my pump, which can deliver up to 28"Hg can deliver nearly a ton of clamping force per square foot...and vacuum does this much more evenly than almost any other solution. All of this also means that the form needs to be very well made.

For anyone interested, I will try to take some photos along the way and may submit them for a Shop Shot or two when I am done. Obviously I am no expert on the process, but sometimes the best time to write a how-to article is when you do it the first time. This approach ensures you don't gloss over necessary details.

By the way, the materials for the vacuum pump cost about $140 or so. I built the "V2plus" venturi pump, designed to be used with a medium to large air compressor. The 4'x 8' bag was about $170 with shipping. Smaller bags are available for much less money if you want to do smaller projects.

If you been interested enough to have read this far, then you might want to head over to the attached link to learn more on the subject than I am qualified to say.

No interest in JoeWoodworker, except that I am vary happy with the service and products. Joe personally answered all of my questions and is a friendly, courteous small business owner. I believe Joe owns both "JoeWoodworker" and "Veneersupplies.com". Lots of good information there.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


Joe Woodworker