Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Band saw motor size question

Posts

Band saw motor size question

#1

Band saw motor size question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I bought a used Delta 20" band saw which I am about to reassemble. I intend to do occasional resawing with the machine.

The saw came with a huge 1 HP motor. I can barely lift it. Will this size motor handle the occasional resawing, up to 12"?

I am wary of looking to see what is on new saws of this size as any guide to what will work OK. Delta table saws now come with 3 or even 5 HP motors. I have never found the 1 1/2HP on my old Delta lacking power for anything I ever called upon it to do.

Re: Band saw motor size question

#2

Re: Band saw motor size question

Pete in Holland, MI

>My 14" has a 1.5 hp unit on it and it is pretty happy with what I do with it. On a 20" would tend to think it could use a heavier motor pretty easily. Check the net for new saw motor specs verses the blade speed. You have to know blade speed while figuring your motor.

Kinda also depends on how fast the wheels are geared to run. With $0 investment, put the original motor back on it and see how it performs for you. A smaller motor will typically mean that feed rates will have to be backed off is all.

Let us know where you ended up.

Your 1hp motor has value in the world of wood workers, so don't just toss it away. Could help pay for your newer motor if you head that way.

Re: Band saw motor size question

#3

Re: Band saw motor size question

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Bill,

I'd put that 1 hp motor on the saw and turn it on. You may do some resaw work with it as a test. I suspect it may be a bit slow, but very adequate none the less: fully suitable for occasional resaw work. You can always upgrade later as necessary.

George

Re: Band saw motor size question

#4

Re: Band saw motor size question

paul waddle

>There was a lot of cast iron in old motors,but new ones are more efficient. I should advise going to a 2hp motor. If you go much larger,you'll need beefer switches,220v(not a bad idea anyway) wiring,ckt breakers etc. I've never stalled a 2hp motor in a resaw,but I can only go 12". One can twist the blade and get a stall,but I mean with correct operations and sharp blade. Get a Baldor 2hp motor and you'll be set-albiet,about 350$ poorer. pw

Re: Band saw motor size question

#5

Re: Band saw motor size question

Howard Norman

>Like George says I would try the 1HP motor that came with the saw before I invested in a new motor.

h

Re: Band saw motor size question

#6

JL

Re: Band saw motor size question

JL

>I'd think about replacing the motor. Yes, the 1 hp motor will probably work, even if it would be slow. I've got the 18" Rikon 10-345 - it has a 2 1/2 hp 220 V motor. The extra power is nice and so is the speed.

Re: Band saw motor size question

#7

Re: Band saw motor size question

del schisler

>the big heavy motor may work better than a light weight one with more horse power I have a 1 1/2 hp on my delta 6" with 6" riser and no problum I use a 1" dia pulley on motor and a 6" pulley on drive all daul belt drive Cast iron pulleys Mfd by browing The motor is 3450 rpm It has been doing the job for probly 10 yrs or so I have sawed 11" with no trouble with bogging down I use 1/2" resaw blade wood slicer over those yrs I cut any type of wood i need to work's for me

Re: Band saw motor size question

#8

Re: Band saw motor size question

Barry Irby

>I have a 14" Delta with a riser block and whatever motor came on it. I think 1hp would be generous. I resaw with it on a hobby basis. Sometimes ten or eleven inches. With a new/sharp blade it works OK, but a little slow. I would like to step up to 2hp, but it would require a new circuit in the shop and probably new wiring on the saw itself. I have a 2hp motor but it has the wrong mounts and the wrong speed, so it would require all of the above and new pulleys and jury rigging the mount.

I would try my saw if I were you and keep my eyes open for a deal on a bigger motor. I would also buy excellent resaw blades.

Re: Band saw motor size question

#9

There's no mechanical reaosn why you

Forrest Addy

>There's no mechanical reaosn why you can't use a motor up to any reasonable sized motor to say 10 HP. At band speeds the working forces and belt tensions are well within the safe loading of the bearings and shafts.

So while your 1 HP motor will work probably work just fine, most real band saws of that size come furnished with 2 HP. Makes sense. Not enough HP is a PITA where saw dwell rapidly reduces blade life. Plenty of HP is a blessing as there is no hesitation when you have a HP intensive cut and when you don't need it you don't notice it.

You will need a 230 volts single phase service for honestly rated 1 1/2 HP motors and above.

Re: Band saw motor size question

#10

Re: Band saw motor size question

William H. Falberg

>I don't think you can have too much HP aside from electrical supply considerations, but you can waste money on more HP than you need. What puts a premium on HP is when you're ripping long and steadily through thick timber and when you're running wide blades that require lots of tension. 3/4", and above, blades put increasingly heavy loads on the motor due to the high tensioning and 1HP, in my case at least, isn't enough to run 3/4" blades for much time at all before it starts over-heating. You most likely have enough frame and wheel capacity; but do you have enough *spring* capacity to properly tension a 3/4" (or more) blade? It's like links in a chain and the harder the cut the sooner you'll bump up against the weakest link. My guess is that it will be the spring but there's a lot of variables involved and you should consider them first before going the Binford 990 route. It's a lot like hot-rodding; you put a blown hemi in front and end up replacing the whole drive line. Then you find the tires can't handle it either. Then the frame comes apart. There's no end to it. For proportion; I used to use 3/4HP motors to drive my 1/2" blades through timber all day every day but some customers started complaining that the motor was bogging and overheating. I replaced them with 1HP motors and everyone seems to be happy with that (even though the saws are a bit heavier now) So unless you're planning wide blades or lots of heavy ripping -the 1HP would probably be plenty.

Re: Band saw motor size question

#11

Re: Band saw motor size question

Fred Davis

>Reading though the reponses may want make you want to ask Delta , I have a hunch they have a clue.

FredD

Re: Band saw motor size question

#12

I suggest you call Delta to get the "Born" date...

Art Silva

>for your saw. The newer models have bigger motors than 1 HP. If that is the original motor is it by any chance a Leeson? If it is a Leeson 1 HP, you will definitly need help picking it up. I have a 1 HP Leeson in my 1964 Unisaw and nothing has ever slowed it down. When Delta started putting 3HP motors in the Unisaw I called Steve Sutton at Delta and asked if it would be worth while to upgrade to a 3HP. He laughed and said: "Calm yourself my friend, the Mint could make pennies for a year with the copper that is in that Leeson". I have been running the "wheels" off that beauty for 45 years.

Re: Band saw motor size question

#14

Motor woes

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Getting the motor in and adjusted is a couple of hour job so I didn't want to do it more than once. I found a rebuilt Leeson, 1.5HP. It had some issues like lacking capacitor cover and wire box plate. Fabricated these items and wired it up. Rotated the wrong way. Rewired. Began installation and thought to check pulley to be sure it fit ok. Gasp! Someone had turned the motor shaft down a small, but significant amount. Undid everything and installed the original monster 1 HP motor. It weighs at least 100 pounds. Given the effort involved getting it located and everything hooked up it is going to stay put until I have a compelling need for something bigger.

Anyway the tires were trued and everything aligned and it runs smoothly. Tomorrow I still need to install the doors and table and I will be ready to saw something.

Re: Band saw motor size question

#15

I hate it when that happens......

Barry Irby

>There I am, proud of my bargain and proud I have the skills to make the simple repairs necessary to get that treasure up and running. Right up to the point the wheels come off. Then I'm ticked at myself for getting sucked into yet another useless bargain.

I have a 2hp motor my Dad gave me maybe thirty years ago. Such a deal, free. Can't use it on the bandsaw because it has the mount where you bolt into the end of the motor. Can't use it on the Performax because it runs a 3450 rather than 1725. Someday I will find a use for it.

Can't you get a pulley turned to math the shaft? Find one with a smaller hole and have it turned out to match? Would shim stock work? (NOT) How about a sleeve? You can see how my thinking works. $700 dollars worth of time and effort and I can save that bargain $200 motor.

Re: Band saw motor size question

#16

Back then...

wilbur

>Looking at a 1957 Delta machinery catalog, for single phase power that bandsaw only had an option for a 1 HP motor.

You could get a 1-1/2 HP motor back then, but only for 3 phase power.

Which suggests that for the most part, 1 HP is all you need, even for resawing. After all, I'm sure they were resawing 12" board with this machine back in 1957.

Re: Band saw motor size question

#17

It runs!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Finally got everything adjusted, some more issues solved and by dinner time I sawed a piece of wood. I'm done with messing with machinery for a while. I'll deal with the motor if I need to later, like in a year. Compared to my 14" saw there are a bewildering array of adjustments on this thing and the all interact.