Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

router bit question

Posts

router bit question

#1

router bit question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I just got my bits back from the sharpener and noticed one of them is getting a little on the thin side. I think the sharpener got a little carried away and took off too much carbide. This particular bit had only been sharpened once before.

Anyway, is there some standard for how much carbide there needs to be left to be sharpened again?

Thanks

Bruce

Re: router bit question

#2

Re: router bit question

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Your sharpener will tell you when there isn't enough material left. However, if you think he took off too much, you might want to look for another sharpener, unless he had to remove some bad nicks.

Lee

Re: router bit question

#3

Re: router bit question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Thanks, Lee. I had to use a new service because my usual one closed shop. I thought they were a bit heavy handed. Might have to do more shopping.

Bruce

Re: router bit question

#4

a data point

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I use Misenheimer in Morristown TN. They make tooling for the furniture industry, or at least what is left in these parts.

When I visit I check the bucket of stuff that is going to the dump. It is usually full of router bits judged to thin to use, as well as pieces of tool steel that I make lathe tools from. So there is some standard for scraping a bit, but I don't know what it is. The pieces scrapped have about 1/16-1/32" carbide left.

If you bit was used well beyond when you should have sharpened it then they will have to grind a lot of material away to get past the rounded over edge.

Re: router bit question

#5

Re: a data point

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Thanks, Bill

It wasn't really dull enough for a good sharpening. I was sending in a batch of other bits and a saw blade so I figured I'd just include it with the rest.

bruce

Re: router bit question

#6

Re: router bit question

Fred Davis

>Bruce ,

It had always amazed me the difference from shop to shop for sharpening services and the amount of carbide removed from blades and router bits and shaper cutters, until I took the time to find out.

Large shops and some small ones with up to date equipment ( read automated)set the profile on a automatic grinder and let it do the job , which invariably will mean a lot of carbide removed.

When the old man who started Bay Area Carbide shop in Concord , Ca got going he took care in sharpening only enough to bring the edge back to factory sharpness.

This meant in the case of good bits like Stanley, they had to be honed with a 600 grit diamond cup wheel. Mirror finish, any less then the bit wears faster, heats up quicker and does not clean itself as well.

So , when I moved back here in 97 and the closest thing to a professional sharpening service was about 35 miles away in Salina, I talked to the owner , a thirtyish or so man who was intrigued with the idea of only removing as much sa necessary, so I asked him if I paid for him to acquire a 600 grit wheel , would he use it on my stuff and no others , unless he started to use that grit all of the time .

So he did and I am happy.

Unless you chip the bit , it is not only not necessary to grind off a major chunk of carbide , but it costs you money in shortening the life of the bit. Ask you guy how he sets up the profile grinding and what grit wheel he uses.

I bet he uses a 200 or maybe 400 grit. ;-))

FredD

Re: router bit question

#7

Re: router bit question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Thanks for your response, Fred,

What happened was that I used a local branch of a very large corporation (worldwide) that specializes in bits, blades, etc. They did an outstanding job - only had 4 guys working there and they took their time to do it right. When they did my carbide saw blade last time, it was the best it had ever been sharpened. Same for the router bits. Well, that shop closed so I figured I would get the same treatment at their regional center in a different state. I figured that I should be getting about 4-5 sharpenings per bit, at the very least. Since this had been sharpened once before I figured it would be good for at least 3-4 more times. But there is not quite 1/32" carbide left (3/8" bit), so it seems to me that they pretty much used up 3/4 of my bit and that this is the last time it can be sharpened. Actually, I'm not sure if I can even use it safely. I only have a fractional calipers so I can't give an exact decimal measurement.

This is a 1/2" shank DML bit, and I've had very good luck with this brand before, so it's not like it was a cheapie to start with.

Thanks for your reply.

I'm getting a bit fired up about this. A complaint is going in today.

Bruce