Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Best circular saw

Posts

Best circular saw

#1

Best circular saw

Walt Segl

>I'm in the market for a new 7.5" circular saw and wondered what the "best" one is. Obviously a subjective call;-)) I use the saw primarily for "rough" work, framing, ripping sheet stock, thick beams. My 27 yr old craftsman has worked well but finally bit the dust while reflooring a barn. This time around I'd like a saw with some power and a good, strong base that keeps adjustment. Probably go with a sidewinder just because of lighter weight. Considered a 10" for the rare occasion that I need more depth of cut. Any input is welcomed!

Re: Best circular saw

#2

Re: Best circular saw

Gene Gauss

>I'm more than pleased with my Porter-Cable framing saw after having had a mediocre Montgomery-Ward (ran off with a burglar), a pretty good Craftsman (jumped off my bench and broke it's main housing), and a terrible Black and Decker (needed to take a smoke break after its first 15 minutes of continuous cutting). The Porter-Cable has plenty of power and a sturdy and well aligned magnesium base.

Re: Best circular saw

#3

Re: Best circular saw

Pete in Holland, MI

>Have had good luck with the Skil brand over the years.

Word of caution though: Big horsepower saws draw a fair amount of current. Double check that your extension cords are large enough to keep that saw happy on the end of a 100' line, else the smoke will be let out prematurely. Learned this the hard way.

Re: Best circular saw

#4

Re: Best circular saw

Don Orr

>I like my Porter Cable a lot, but would also look at the Milwaukee. Very solid saw with sturdy base that stays put. They used to be built to last a lifetime. Great depth adjustment system also.

Re: Best circular saw

#5

Re: Best circular saw

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>I know you said you would probablly get a sidewinder, but being from the "left" coast I can't imagine framing or rough work with a sidewinder. My Skil Model 77 is still going strong after 35 plus years, (it's old enough it doesn't have an insulated plastic handle). Yes, it is heavy, even heavier than the newer saws with plastic handles. Since I just can't get used to the blade on the right, if I were buying a new framing saw it would be a "mag" worm drive, but I am pretty sure my old Skil will outlast me so I won't be buying a framing saw anytime soon. If I were buying a new "shop" saw I would buy a left blade sidewinder.

Skil 77 35 years and counting.

glc

Re: Best circular saw

#6

Blow the money . . .

steve mackay

>My rule of thumb is to identify the price that would send LOML into orbit then buy the next model UP. Never failed me yet. I saved my pennies and bought a heavy worm drive the first time. Have never felt I bought more saw than I really needed. It IS a beast and won't "quick-draw" like a side-winder but it stays put and easy to guide. I don't chop up crazy, heavy stuff very often but when I need it . . .

Re: Best circular saw

#7

Bosch worm drive

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Best circular saw

#8

Re: Best circular saw

Dave Tenney

>We use Dewalt sidewinders which have really held up great, but recently got a couple Hitachi's that are very accurate. The Dewalts we use are older, but they are similar to the new 368's. I never liked the worm drive saws because the blade is on the wrong side! (Subjective, depends on what you are used to)

Whatever you get, make sure it has a solid base (not stamped steel)

I'm not a fan of Makita and Milwaukee...I don't think that Skill makes a quality saw anymore.

The picture is a deck that my cousin, uncle and myself built for a customer last summer. This is typical of the kind of work we do...The circular saws take a beating.

Dave


img

Re: Best circular saw

#9

Re: Best circular saw

A Wright

>I have two circular saws that I use regularly - a Porter Cable "left-hand" and a Dewalt "right-hand".

I found that the left-handed saw is much better for cutting sheet goods because if I am holding the saw it with my right hand the blade is where I can see it clearly. The drawback is that it doesn't work well for cutting off 2x4s if you hold it in your right hand (so I bought a second saw for that type of work)

Re: Best circular saw

#10

Re: Best circular saw

Fred Davis

>You need no better reccommendation then a framer from the 'Left coast"

Skil model 77 out far

numbers any other brand and the "D" handle puts the blade on the left side where you can see where your cutting.

We typically set up new subdivison jobs with at least twenty saws and forty one hundred foot saw cords.

FredD

Re: Best circular saw

#11

Historical basis

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>It's my understanding that Skil chose to market its worm drive saw on the West coast, and Porter-Cable emphasized the East coast, in the early days of hand held circular saws (early 20th century).

The heavy production orientation of the postwar western housing boom probably clinched it for the worm drive saws out here, but there was already an historical practice that encouraged the trend.

No one can say carpenters aren't affected by tradition.

Even though I was raised on the left coast, I was raised in a sidewinder family (Skil 6", which I inherited with pride from my dad, still working after 60 years and a lot of wood cut), and am most comfortable that way. I'm not sure a worm drive is a sound recommendation for an occasional user - the skill set in using one seems pretty intense.

Re: Best circular saw

#12

Less May Be More

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I have a big honkin' Skill worm drive that is great for field ripping 4x wood, but it rarely gets touched since I got a PC Saw Boss. That little 6" saw blows through sheet goods and 2x stock with equal ease. Control is great, and the weight means a lot at the end of a cutting day.

Now if you're looking for something to cut beams and such, I recommend a Stihl 023 with a 16" bar. Mine's still going strong after 20 years.

BTW, I don't cut s***rock with a saw. Score and snap saws a whole lot of cleanup.

Re: Best circular saw

#13

Re: Best circular saw

Charlie Self

>Skil still makes a 77, I think. That is a top notch saw, if heavy.

I like the new Festool a lot, but I'm thinking it's a tad pricey for rough work. I have an older--flat aluminum baseplate--Porter-Cable saw that absolutely cannot be beat. It's heavy for a direct drive, but will probably outlast two or three of the newer saws, any brand. It came in a steel case, too. I hate blow molded plastic cases that fit so tightly you have to get everything to factory settings and wraps to put the fool tool away.

For homeowner work, once a month or so, Skil and B&D regular line saws are OK. Otherwise, they're not sturdy enough to last long...DeWalt saws are excellent, as are Bosch and Milwaukee. I've never used a Hitachi circular saw, but I love their SCMS models, and figure the circular saws should be on a par. Craftsman saws can be great and no so great. Handle the model you want to check.

Re: Best circular saw

#14

Re: Best circular saw

Fred Davis

>I don't know what you mean by not cutting 2x4 's well.

If you ever watched a Carpenter use a SkilSaw cutting lumber , you may realize you weren't doing it the easy way.

If your 2X4's are laying on a sawhorse , 24 " high then reach down with your left hand grasp the 2x4 , tilt it up so it slants toward you and cut it off.

Your not picking up the weight of the 2x4 since it rest's on the sawhorse.

If your in the field or building without a sawhorse, bend over grasp the 2x4 , lay it across your left foot , tilt up as before and cut it.

Piece of cake.

Fred

Re: Best circular saw

#15

Re: Best circular saw

Dave Tenney

>That's nice to hear about the Skill...I'm glad they still make a few quality tools.

The Festool would be off limits on the job site, I can't see someone dragging one of those $600 beasts up a ladder by the cord! I think the Festool has a 6" blade, which would make it tough to cut a 6x6.

To me a circular saw is a personal thing...it's what you get used to.

Makita and Milwaukee make nice saw, but I don't like the way they feel. I actually had to use a Makita for about a week once, and towards the end of the week I started to get used to it and it wasn't too bad.

Dave

Re: Best circular saw

#16

Re: Best circular saw

Bill White

>Porter-Cable right blade has served me very well since I dropped/smashed a 30 year old Craftsman. Would buy it again 'cause I really like the base shoe. It follows an edge guide.

Bill