Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Poly over paint?

Posts

Poly over paint?

#1

Poly over paint?

Joe in a Cleveland Suburb

>Hi.

I'm making a small table for my dogs dishes (pictured below). It's made from poplar and pine. My wife wants to paint it. It'll be painted with regular interior latex of some sort. Probably a sage color.

We were thinking maybe we should put poly on top of the paint to help protect it from scratches and so on. I was thinking though that the poly would yellow over time. Maybe I should use water based poly?

Is that a good idea? Is there something else we should use?

Thanks.

Joe


Re: Poly over paint?

#2

No problem. I'd use WB poly

Nat Robison

>

Re: Poly over paint?

#3

No problema

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I've used oil poly, water poly, water borne epoxy, and solvent lacquer over latex and acrylic paint with no problems. Go for it.

Clint

Re: Poly over paint?

#4

alternative

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Your dogs have a high standing to deserve a table like that!

I do not see a benefit from the varnish overcoat. Indeed unless you use a non-yellowing vanish the hue will change over time. And, refinishing will be difficult.

I would paint it with a semigloss enamel. When it looked used, I would then repaint it with semi-gloss enamel. The paint, once thoroughly cured which could take a week or more, will be as durable as the varnish and much easier to renew.

Re: Poly over paint?

#5

Re: alternative

jerry mayfield

>I agree how often have you seen varnish put on over paint on a house or a porch or anything else.

Regards

Jerry

Re: Poly over paint?

#6

Re: Poly over paint?

Bill White

>If you're determined to top coat, use a water based poly so it won't "yellow" the painted surface.

Bill

Re: Poly over paint?

#7

Re: Poly over paint?

GalenV in Iowa

>Cats or Dogs = scratches

My zoo of cats and dogs kept scrapeing up a deep window sill watching the birds at the feeeder out over the deck. After refinishing and using a heavy coat of poly I saw things were not going to stop. Cut a piece of glass and set it on the sill. No more scratched wood.

I guess you could use plexiglass overlay but not fitting of your table design. Too slick probably as well.

Just wondering does your dog set on a little chair at his table :>)

Galen

Re: Poly over paint?

#8

Avoid waterborne finishes

Howard Acheson

>Waterborne finishes (acrylic paint or clear waterborne acrylic "polys) do not stand up well in an environment where they will be frequently wet. Waterborne finishes are not anywhere near as water resistant or tolerant to water as oil based finishes.

I agree with Bill. Use a good oil based enamel paint. A good paint is as water and scratch resistant as a consumer grade polyurethane varnish. After all, oil based paint is just varnish with opaque pigments. You gain nothing extra by overcoating it with a varnish.

Re: Poly over paint?

#9

If water borne epoxy

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>can hold up in a shower pan, which it does at my house, or survive a garage floor, for which it's sold, it should be OK for a doggy diner.

Clint

Re: Poly over paint?

#10

Good advice

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Check out Behr water borne epoxy for a bullet proof finish. Super hard, super easy, and can be tinted.

Clint