Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Frame and panel door question

Posts

Frame and panel door question

#1

Frame and panel door question

Jonathan in Minneapolis

>I need to make about 25 frame and panel doors. The panels will be flat panels made from 1/2" cherry ply.

I can do M&T joints at each corner but I don't really have a good setup for doing the 100 mortises required. So is there a downside to gluing the ply panels into the rabbets? Normally panels are not glued to account for wood movement in the panel, but the ply should have minimal movement. Glueing the panels would add strength to the door and minimize the need for full M&T joints at each corner (I would still do stub tenons into the rabbets.)

Re: Frame and panel door question

#2

Couple things...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I would not recommend rabbeted construction. There isn't enough strength in an open, cross-grain rabbet joint to resist more than light-duty handling. One good rap can break the door, even if your panels are glued into the rabbets.

If you want to pull up short of using tenons, dowels or biscuits to reinforce the joints, the next best thing is to use tongue-and-groove construction or cope-and-stick construction, and to rabbet the back edges of your plywood panels to form a tongue all around. This is not only more professional looking than rabbeted construction, but it is also a lot stronger. Glue the panel in place and you should be okay. I'd guess that most kitchen cabinet doors are built this way.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Frame and panel door question

#3

Ellis, could you elaborate???

Barry Irby

>I have been thinking about your response for about an hour. I was completely wrong in my thinking according to your response. I would have thought securely glueing the half inch panels into snug rabbits in the frames would have made a pretty good door. Essentially long grain joints all the way around. Could you explain your reasoning a little better and what you thought would work better? I am not tracking on your description.

Re: Frame and panel door question

#4

Reconsider task

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There isn't any economy in doing wood work half a****. I tried it early in the game and it didn't pan out.

The only joint that has stood the test of time for a frame is the M&T joint. They can be made just fine with a $100 drill press hollow chisel attachment or a $400 bench top M&T hollow chisel machine(less if bought used). You are creating a lot of value making 25 doors. Spend some of it on the machinery to do it right and you will have the ability to do it again in the future. If this is for sure a one time affair then buy the doors already made from the numerous places that sell custom made kitchen cabinet doors. .

Alternatively, and possibly at some greater expense, would be making the doors with router bits (coped joint) as Ellis suggested. Most kitchen cabinet doors are made this way.

Re: Frame and panel door question

#5

Re: Frame and panel door question

Jim Dillon

>Jonathan,

While you did not mention the size of your doors, for pantry-sized doors I think your approach is very doable. In fact, Mario Rodrigues (a noted woodworker and author) has a very nice article in FWW describing what you want to do. He actually used 1/4 inch plywood for the door panel (glued all the way around) coupled with deeper than normal stub tenons set into the 3/4 inch deep stile and rail grooves. He used 3/4 inch thick x 2 inch wide stock for the stiles and rails. He also added an attractive interior bead to make the door more attractive. I don't have the exact FWW reference, but you can probably locate it at FWW's online magazine index. However, it is in FWW's Essentials of Woodworking series "Woodworking Techniques", Taunton Press, 2000, pp 76-78. I have used his approach on several shop doors and it works well and is fast. The only caution I can see it to make sure your plywood is reasonably flat to begin with to avoid twisting the final door frame. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Frame and panel door question

#6

Re: Frame and panel door question

Tony - Memphis

>Do you mean a rabbet or a groove? Maybe we have a terminology issue here. If you mean a groove, I have done this many times and never had any issues. All the cabinets in my shop, garage, etc. have been built this way and I am not real careful with them. My garage cabinets have masonite (hardboard, whatever - the brown stuff) glued in the grooves. That has help up great over ten years. I've been impressed with how strong a glued in panel door is and it is also not too heavy.

Tony

Re: Frame and panel door question

#7

Re: Frame and panel door question

Jim Dillon

>Jonathan,

Tony raises a good point. Did you mean rabbet or groove?? Big difference between the two when constructing doors. I missed the use of the word "rabbet" in your original post. Sorry. If you did mean a "rabbet", then I would agree with the other posters regarding the need for a something like a mortise and tenon (fixed or loose) to reinforce the corner joint.

Jim

Re: Frame and panel door question

#8

Re: Frame and panel door question

Fred Davis

>Johnathan,

in addition to what Ellis points out , if you like the look , I routinely do what is called in the cabinet trade a "recessed panel door ".

I have a PM stationery mortiser which I don't use on cabinet doors because biscuits and a 1/4"plycore panel attached to the back with glue and staples is easily strong enough "for the ages".

This procedure coupled with a lipped door edge gives a architectural look , because of the depth of the panel,.. 3/4" deep.

I like the lipped edge because it overlaps the face frame and removes the edge of the 1/4" plycore panel from view.

In addition using clamps with 1/4" spacers to hold the frame together , lets you use the panel to effectively square the door frame while you glue and staple it to the back of the door.

I have not had a failure in the frame joints ever, and some have been around a longgggg time, counting thousands here.

On the other hand , this works best with the lipped door approach, which you may not like.

Using 1/2" thick panels is unnecessary for strength and bulky looking in the finished product.

I will post some pics if you wish.

FredD

Re: Frame and panel door question

#9

Re: Frame and panel door question

Jonathan in Minneapolis

>Doh! Sorry about the wrong terminology - I clearly wasn't thinking this morning. I meant a 1/4" groove 1/2" deep all around the inside with a 1/2" tenon on the rails. I would do a rabbet on the back of the panel to make it fit in the groove and be flush with the back of the rails/stiles.

Based on the feedback here, I'll go ahead and not do the full mortise/tenons and just do stub tenons but glue the panels all the way around.

Thanks for your help - sorry for the confusion.

Jonathan

Re: Frame and panel door question

#10

Re: Frame and panel door question

Jim Dillon

>Jonathan,

No problem at all. I'm the guy who still mixes up "rabbet" vs "rabbit" 8-). I understand what you are doing and think it should work, although - if I were doing it - I would make the groove deeper than normal thus dictating that your "stub" tenon be longer than normal to give you more strength. Say something in the range of 3/4-inch deep. That, coupled with a glued-in-place plywood panel should give you lots of strength. Good luck.

Jim

Re: Frame and panel door question

#11

Re: Frame and panel door question

mamc

>Coping router bit set is one of the best "tools" I have ever bought and it was not that expensive $100-$125 I think. With a good Router table and home made sled, 100 Rails and Stiled is nothing.

Result is a more professional looking front, strong, oless fussing around joints, and easy to do when producing longer runs like a room of kitchen cabinets etc.

Its the way to go IMHO

Re: Frame and panel door question

#12

Cope and Stick

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Jonathan,

For doors, I use mortice and tenon or cope and stick on the router table. I tend to favor the cope and stick. Either way, you will have sufficient glue area for strength and rigidity assuming your frame isn't whimpy.

George

Re: Frame and panel door question

#13

Lee Grindinger

Re: Ellis, could you elaborate???

Lee Grindinger

>Here's a pic of what Ellis is referring to...,it's a very common way to make production frame and panel doors and panels. In the case the original poster is asking about he can glue the panels in place since it's plywood. In the pic below it's a solid wood panel and only the centers were pinned. I made the grooves deeper to accommodate longer tenons.


img

Re: Frame and panel door question

#14

Re: Frame and panel door question

Fred Davis

>Johnathan,P

Pardon my slowness , but I am sure if you use 3/4" thick stile and rail material and make the back of the panel flush with the backs of the stiles and rails, you wil only have a 1/4" reveal or inset from the front and that in minds eye looks funny.

On a slightly different note, I have several different styles of Cope and Stick cutters and having repaired many doors made this way by others, it is my opinion that the stub tenon on the cutter is a pitiful excuse for a tenon, not nearly long enough.

Long as a biscuit you say,well this is true , but the biscuit has a mechnical lock on the joint as well as a glue lock , the cope and stick variety of joints doesn't.

FredD

Re: Frame and panel door question

#15

Re: Frame and panel door question *LINK*

Fred Davis

>Johnathan,

sometime pictures are better then words.

Vanity and Medcine cabinets by me , with the type door construction I was telling you about.

Vanity top is a custom made Onyx casting by a firm in Belvue ,Kansas , who ship all over the country.

I stumbled across then right down the road from Kansas Hardwoods sawmill where I buy my stock.

FredD


http://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/gX2jtlXzM9Plyd4ecnNh6w?authkey=r6dGM5Qs0Qw&feat=directlink

Re: Frame and panel door question

#16

Re: Frame and panel door question

Nathan

>Hi Fred:

Please post some pics if you can find time. I'm going to make our kitchen cabinets this year and would like to use your method of door construction.

Nathan

Re: Frame and panel door question

#17

Excellent

Ellis Walentine, Host

>

Re: Frame and panel door question

#18

No absolutes

Ellis Walentine, Host

>There are mainly two reasons to prefer a tongue and groove joint to an open rabbet. One is appearance. The other is that in a t&g joint you get twice the glue surface plus a mechanical aspect that you don't get in a rabbet. This is even more of a potential issue with plywood, where the main face glue surface is a very thin layer of veneer.

Ellis

Re: Frame and panel door question

#19

Saw the pictures, Fred, but questions remain

Nathan

>I found the link to your pictures, Fred, but from the one picture it seems that the cabinet doors are not "lipped" as you described - the edge of the 1/4" plywood panel seems to be visible.

Also, I don't understand the role of the 1/4" spacers for squaring the door during glue-up.

If you care to explain further, that would be great. This method seems much simpler than capturing the panel in a groove.

Nathan

Re: Frame and panel door question

#20

Re: Saw the pictures, Fred, but questions remain

Fred Davis

>Nathan ,

glad to explain.

if you will notice , the inside leading edges when closed are left square , without a lip, because they close to each other rather then on to a stile.

Lipping that edge on each door would look like a mistake when open .

The 1/4" spacers are little pieces of 1/2" plycore about four inches long and 5/8" wide.

I shim the clamp pads out from the edge of the door frame while clamping so you have a 1/2" wider space then the door frame and back to slide the back into.

Another way to look at it is the clamps never touch the plycore back , it stays loose enough , that you can square the door frame to the back and never have a out of square door.

So here's the drill , I cut the stiles and rails to size , cut the biscuit slots , lay the frame pieces face down on the bench, glue the biscuits , slide the frame together , face down on the bench, put a spacer top and bottom on each long side and clamp with just enough pressure to keep a tight joint,

Then after running a zigzag glue bead down the back face of the door frame while it is in the clamps, I carefully slide the 1/4" back into place from one end, staple that end down and check the frame and back alignment for square , staple the other end and both sides.

Remember to keep the back facing down since your working the door face down.

Fill the staple hole slots and set the door aside to dry and keep going on the others.

Getting into the finer details, I pay attention to the flatness of the door stiles and if they have a hump , I place that hump down to keep any slight bowing of the stock facing outwards on the cabinet.

I also use plain sliced veneer ,generally Ash and for pairs of doors closing on each other , match the grain.

Also keep the Cathedral grain either up or down on all doors, your choice.

This is done to keep the light reflection the same for each door.

Need any more information , just ask.

FredD

Re: Frame and panel door question

#21

Re: Saw the pictures, Fred, but questions remain

Fred Davis

>I meant to say that the 1/4" spacers are pieces of 1/4 " plycore rather then the 1/2" I mistakely wrote.

FredD

Re: Frame and panel door question

#22

Re: Frame and panel door question *LINK*

Fred Davis

>Here you go Nathan,

I did out kitchen over about 2-3 year ago and a lady poster here was about to do hers and was wondering about Microwave configuration I believe.

Sent these to her , you will notice the microwave is recessed flush with the cabinet front, I developed this method about 1974 in response to a housewife client that didn't like the typical bulky microwave cabinet or having it set on the counter.

Thanks to her , dozens of other clients opted for this approach , which frees up counter space and gives a uninterrupted look to it.

The cabinets are Ash , plain sliced for the doors , couldn't get it in 3/4" plycore for the cabinet carcass, so those are rotary cut veneer which I think is to wild , but you settle for what you get around here.

The Hutch which got into the pics is local Hackberry which as you can see is very similar to Ash in appearance.

Countertop is John Boos and company Hard Maple product , which by the way is the only brand of wood countertop in the nation approved for food processing directly on it.

Any questions are welcomed.

FredD


http://picasaweb.google.com/FredD17209/KitchenPictures?authkey=oBdsqYAeXXU&feat=directlink