Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Electrical Question - An easy one

Posts

Electrical Question - An easy one

#1

Electrical Question - An easy one

Gabe Doyle

>This should be an easy one for the experts here:

My garage outlets and lights are all on the same 15 amp circuit, and I need to run a dust collector along with my table saw while I cut a bunch of MDF pieces. I think my saw is about 13 amps, and the dust collector is 12 amps. I know that ideally, I'd have dedicated circuits for each machine, but for once-in-a-while situations, are there any problems with swapping the 15 amp circuit breaker out with a 25 or 30 amp one and using both machines that way? If so, I guess I'd just run an extension cord from inside the house for one of the machines, which isn't the end of the world.

Thanks,

Gabe

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

#2

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

Dan Donaldson

>The breaker is there to protect the wiring, not what is plugged into the outlet. Putting a larger breaker in is inviting a fire if you have any marginal connections. Also, the wire is undersized for the load you would be pulling and this would more than likely lead to voltage drops that could damage the motors. In a nutshell, don't do it. If you have a 20 am circuit somewhere, get a good 12 gauge extension cord and run it that way.

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

#3

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

Gabe Doyle

>Will do. I definitely don't want to burn the house down - my wife just had it painted and she would kill me.

Thanks.

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

#4

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

RobV

>Chances are that your saw does not pull 13 amps unless you're close to stalling the motor, same is true of the dust collector. While it's not ideal, I think you may be fine running both of them on the same 15A circuit. Start one of them, let it get to speed then start the other one.

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

#5

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

Tom MacGregor

>When a motor starts the amp draw spikes an average of about 30% and then settles down to the "running amperage". Increasing the load on the motor (a blockage in the dust pipe, binding or heavy cutting on the saw) will increase the amp draw also. Trying to draw too much amperage through too small a wire generates heat which is why there's a maximum breaker size for a given gauge wire that shouldn't be exceeded. IF you have 12 gauge copper wire you can install a 20 amp rated breaker and outlet, but for temporary use a 12 gauge extension cord of the shortest possible length plugged into a different circuit (I'd use it for the collector) might be the best bet.

One note of caution: We just had an electrician do some work (it had to pass code) and neither the electrician nor the building inspector noticed that he hadn't gotten a couple of neutral wires tight enough under the lug inside the breaker box. Two neutral wires overheated from the bad connection (which acted the same as a too-small wire) and burned back about 4 inches. Having a good hot and a bad neutral connection took out the $130 control panel for our dishwasher!

There are a lot of fairly simple electrical things you can do yourself, but missing one small detail can cause a lot of trouble.

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

#6

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

RobV

>> When a motor starts the amp draw spikes an

> average of about 30% and then settles down

> to the "running amperage".

Yeah, the success in running both of them from the same 15A circuit may rely on the order in which they are started. My suspection is that the table saw may produce a very high initial spike over a very small amount of time and the dust collector will have a higher draw over a longer period of time as the fan gets up to speed.

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

#7

Small Details

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I have my 3hp (real) compressor set up in the unheated garage for noise abatement, and it's fed with its own 10/2 wire from a 25 amp circuit (needs a higher amperage draw for a cold start in winter). As part of our kitchen renovation, we had to have an expanded sub panel put in. When the sorcerer's apprentice reconnected the compressor circuit into the new panel, he over-tightened the box clamp and cut through the insulation on the compressor wire. When the sub went live, the fireworks at the service panel were neat for about 3 seconds. I wonder if the boss took the cost of a new panel out of Mickey's pay that week. Fortunately I had left enough play in the compressor line so that they didn't have to put in a splice box or pull a new feed out to the garage.

The guy learned the hard way that a few extra turns on that clamp can be way too many.

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

#8

Re: Small Details

Bill Howatt

>You make at least 2 good points in your post.

1. The clamp is there more as a bushing and to just slightly hold the wire; it is not there to moor the Queen Mary in case it floats into your house. They are often over-tightened.

2. Leaving a bit extra slack in a wire is a good idea. Last job I had done by an electrician had small loops between the staple close to the box and the box bushing. If the wire broke in the box which sometimes happen if a wire-nut connection is remade there is plenty of wire to easily fix it.

Bill

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

#9

3rd Silent Point

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>When doing a full renovation with new appliances, etc., hire outside licenses to do the mechanicals. They carry the insurance. Sparky, Puddles, and Rocky all got call-backs on this job, but everyone smiled for the birdie in the end.

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

#10

Re: Electrical Question - An easy one

Fred Davis

>Dan points out the consequences of what your contemplating and they all are significant.

Pushing the envelope on electrical requirements,might put you in the position of giving your Homeowners insurance company a loophole that would leave you holding the bag and your wife a endless supply of ammunition.

Consider upgrading the garage/shop convenient outlets and have a electrician survey your breaker panel for different configurations of your circuits.

Looks like Mark can testify to the inadvisability of having a amateur or unsupervised apprentice do the work.

FredD