Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

Posts

Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#1

Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

Damon

>During the remodel of my house, my father decided it would be a good idea to basically cover these exposed Cyprus beams that we put in with "stainable" wood putty. He also let the putty sit on them for approximately 4 months as the beams were covered during the drywall. He sanded some off it off but he left quite a bit of the putty on in big chunks (pictured below)

I have tried sanding it off but am terrified and pretty confident it is going to look like crap if I try to stain them. The more I sand, it seems as if it is just impregnating the fine particles of putty into the grain of the wood. I have been using 100 and 150 sandpaper so far...

There is a slight greenish/yellowish hue (marked by the arrows on the pictures below) in an area that I have tried to sand the wood putty away, but the hue is still there =(. It is the same color as when I start sanding on another area where there was/is putty. I cant seem to get rid of it. This terrifies me of what it would look like with stain on it.

I have read a few people mention bleach on various forums. My concern and question here is if I bleach a part of the beam wont that cause discoloration there? Wouldn't I have to bleach the whole beam to have it uniform to apply the stain to it???

What do I do to reclaim these beams. They were supposed to be a major focal point of my house and now I am so scared they are RUINED!!!! What should I do??? BTW, they cannot be replaced, they are also structural.

I have also attached pictures of what I am afraid it will look like after being stained =(

This is a nightmare. Please help me, all help is greatly appreciated..


















































I am afraid if I stain the beams, they will turn out horrible like the below pictures!!!




















Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#2

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I

John K Jordan

>Damon,

I have no direct experience that would help with that, but when remodeling this timberframe house a friend suggested "sand" blasting the exposed pine beams. The beams had a light-colored pickling (pigmented) wash which he wasn't sure he liked. He said they can blast not with sand but with something softer - can't remember but seems it was some kind of grain husks. He saw some old beams in a restaurant restored that way.

I chose to leave the beams alone and they look great now once we added a little color to the walls, but perhaps the blasting is an option. (My friend loves them now!)

Also, have you considered pickling the beams? That would cover up the putty and the wood to some extent, but not completely - you can still see the grain. (We have wood beams, posts, walls, and ceilings!) The lighter beams makes for an entirely different look, but a glance at some of the timberframe showcase magazines indicates this is a fairly popular treatment. Comparing my house with some other, the lighter pickling makes the interior is MUCH brighter than those with stained or even natural wood finished beams. I'd be glad to post a picture if you'd like.

Oh, I just remembered, we DID patch some of the posts with putty. The guy who built this house lived here with 30 cats and they used the posts for scratching! We patched perhaps ten 6" posts that had horrible deep groves, sanded lightly, and added picking wash. You can't tell even looking closely.

JKJ

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#3

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>A few more ideas for you ...

Cover the surfaces with thin cypress boards.

Use an electric hand plane to take 1/16" off the offending surfaces. Clean up with a high quality random orbit sander like a Festool 150. I wouldn't try a belt sander on this work; it would be very difficult to keep a surface flat.

Use some of that putty on a test piece, then sand it off and stain it. See if your fears are justified. (I think they will be.)

Hire a pro to paint over the bad areas. A good furniture restorer is what you want.

Good luck, and keep us posted!

ERd

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#4

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I

mike from american sycamore

>I hate to be so direct but why are you trying to get a furniture quality stain on a paint grade material?

If I really wanted to stain that material I would start with 60 grit and work up to 120. 60 grit should remove most of the filler your father used. Then I would check with a pro shop selling stains. In my area it is Sherwin Williams. I am thinking that a glazing stain would be the answer. What do others think? Good luck and remember it is only wood!

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#5

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I

RobV

>Honestly the beams look fine - I wouldn't do anything with them. If you want to seal the surface look into one of the (I hate to suggest it, but...) water based clear finishes - the water based finish won't add any color pigment to the wood. I hate them because they raise the grain, but on the beams 10' up this isn't going to be as much of an issue as it would with a piece of furniture. If you're intent on staining them take a look at gel-stains - they will not penetrate the surface like conventional stains and will sit on top the wood and better cover any putty and other defects.

The only real issue I see in those photographs is the door jamb - it just wasn't sanded enough. The only putty you should have left after sanding is what is covering the nail hole. It looks like you still have some putty on the surface where the satin wouldn't penetrate. Again, a gel-stain can better deal with these issues.

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#6

addendum to "do nothing with the beams"

RobV

>Just for my own curiosity - did the "stainable wood putty" happen to be "Plastic Wood"?

I've had problems with the solvent in Plastic Wood leaching into the wood and not taking stain no matter how much sanding is done.

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#7

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I

Fred Davis

>Damon,

all is not lost , especially if Dad learns from it.

John was thinking along what we have done in the past , concerning sandblasting , Limed oak effect and like that.

Sandblasting can be very attractive and a Mccloskey's Limed Oak over it would be a look for sure.

I believe for myself if the sandblast texture is not what you prefer , I have had woodwork done locally here by a talented painter who has a interior shop and he is a master at graining the wood to look exactly how you wanted it in the first place or even another wood , like Oak or Mahogany.

I was in George Lucas house in California when he was driving a Carpenter Foreman nuts with his mind changing.

One thing that happened there was his insistence on using Redwood milled right on the property from his trees and at the head of the stairs was a rotunda like effect with windows set in Redwood , done beautifully by his construction crew and then George changed his mind....

He wanted the Redwood taken out and replaced with Oak.

His Carpenter Foreman pleaded with him not do this and they settled on a guy the Foreman knew who did wood graining.

When the painter was done , you could look at it closely and not tell it wasn't Oak.

What you want to avoid is not doing anything since the wood putty and wood will age to different colors and really become noticeable.

Also you can buy a Sandvik brand scraper that will let you bring the putty areas into more of a wood look before you do anything, that is a lot easier then power sanding.

Talk to a good interior decorator or a painter that they use who does this work and him look at it.

This should let your anxiety die down a bit ;-))

FredD

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#8

The door jambs ...

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Damon,

I've got no input on how to remove the putty other than sanding.

However, stain /varnish first when you're working on the door jambs, then fill in the holes with putty, sand off excess putty and, finally, re-stain the putty/final coat of varnish.

Going this way avoids the blotching you show on the stained doorjambs.

Perhaps there might be a message in there for the beams?

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#9

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I

Barry Irby

>Shoulda, Coulda, Woulda won't help you now. (Should have sanded the wood, stained it and sealed it and them applied the filler to match the stain.)

I would suggest two things. Find some scraps of the same wood and practice. Put the filler on them and let it sit a while. you don't have four months to play with this, but let it dry a few days and try to fix it. Much better than taking a whack at the real thing and screwing it up.

On the beams, I would sand them better (or more) with a random orbital sander. You may find it wise to sand the entire surface or at least a large area around each defect, not just the spot. I have a five inch ROS and it is a work horse for me in my shop.

One of my experiments would be to try a sealer, perhaps shellac, and then stain over that.

If you sand blast you will have to blast the entire surface of all the beams.

If you try graining or painting the spots artistically, you will have to do the entire surface or the spots will show over time because they will age differently from the part that was not grained.

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#10

Seal the surface with Zinsser's Seal Coat........

Art Silva

>dewaxed shellac, and use a Gel stain in the color of your choice. You will have to play with the jambs to see if the putty can be blended in with color.

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#11

Re: Seal the surface with Zinsser's Seal Coat.....

Rob Stokes in N. Vancouver

>I second Art's answer. Sealcoat, scuff with 320 (scuff, don't "sand") to remove the raised grain and apply/remove/even the gel stain with a rag.

As always, try it in a discreet location first.

Rob

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#12

Re: Seal the surface with Zinsser's Seal Coat.....

gary peterson

>May help, may not. Had situation where I made a walnut dresser and filled the sides(before assembly, thank the Lord) with a "stainable" wood filler. NOT. Filler stayed white after sanding and staining. Solution from a reader said to use the non-toxic stripper Peel A Way then brush with grain with fine wire brush. Worked quite well, the little white left hardly noticable. If you can keep that cedar's natural look, that would be nice.

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#13

About the door frames

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>How much is your time worth? I would probablly just re-trim the doors, and either stain ths casing before installation and use color matched putty and a very good saw blade, or stain then putty after the install. It MAY be a lot quicker than trying to fix whats there.

glc

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#14

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I

Fred Davis

>Maybe I was unclear again.

Sandblasting would naturally entail all of the beams, it could be done in a much shorter time then you have already spent on quick fixes.

Sanding is a laborious task with little hope of a uniform appearance unless you have the time and the patience to get down to bare wood , unspoiled by putty.

That being said , "graining the wood " by someone who makes a living at it is very fast, gives a look you would never have otherwise, even if the beams were not plastered with putty.

If you do this approach , then you or the painter can use a lightweight fast drying filler on the cracks and crevices that will sand smooth with a stroke or two of 150 grit sandpaper.

One leading brand of this crack filler/Spackle is Red Devil.

Gary is right that doing the door trim over is faster and better then experimenting on the first ones.

However , this again is where wood graining shines.

Also sandblasting or wood graining is done by those who do it daily for a living , not you as homeowner.

Do yourself a inexpensive favor and contact one and get their advice after they look at the job.

FredD

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#15

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I  *LINK*

Fred Davis

>This web site should answer any remaining questions about the efficacy of wood graining your beams and or door trim.

Pictures are truely worh a thousand words

http://www.painting-effects.co.uk/workshops.htm

FredD


http://www.painting-effects.co.uk/workshops.htm

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#16

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I *LINK*

Fred Davis

>try this one,slightly different address

FredD

http://www.painting-effects.co.uk/wood-examples.htm


http://www.painting-effects.co.uk/wood-examples.htm

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#17

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I

DouginDenver

>I don't see this as a huge problem. If you don't have one, go spend $80 on a random orbit sander at Home Depot. You could start with 80 or 100 grit, and quit at 150. Less than an hour to do that beam. The filler will stay in the big holes, but you'll remove enough wood it won't be in the grain anymore.

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I do?!

#18

Re: Please help w/ Wood Putty DISASTER, what do I

Damon

>I guess there might have been some confusion. The beams are the only thing that is mine. The door trim and all the other pics are what I was afraid it would turn out like.. what I am trying to avoid.

I took a ROS to it last night and planning on doing that for a few nights this week. All I have is time, I will just sand until I am at a point I feel like I am o.k. with it. The good thing is they are 8' up in the air.. that gives a little bit of slack as they aren't at eye level..