the trouble with multiple submissions.
Joe Hurst
>Hey Brian-
Good to hear from you! Woodcraft magazine is rooted in Parkersburg, WV, but we've got branches all over the place...I'm living in Birmingham (my wife teaches opera at UAB); our ed-in-chief, Jim Harrold, still calls Des Moines home. We also enlist writers and editors from all over the U.S. Better living through technology.
As for the "why don't they share lists?"; sometimes we do, but only after the fact.
Despite what you might think, it has less to do with our desire for the scoop, and more to do with the lack of hours in the day. Multiply the number of emails it would take to verify a 3 page tip department (plus alternates)...with every magazine...and you're looking at another story assignment.
I find it easier, and more direct, to contact the contributor directly and ask if that tip has been previously submitted. If so, I'll ask that he notify the competitor and inform them that the tip has been selected for another magazine.
I don't know the situation about your double-appearance, but you need to watch out for yourself. Call it "once burnt, twice shy," but editors may stay clear of guys who do are offering the same tip to different magazines at the same time. Better to offer one tip to X and a different tip to Y. Wait 6 weeks or so, then flip the tips.
If the magazine asks to use the first tip after it's already been submitted to another, kindly tell them what you did. Most guys will appreciate your honesty.
-Joe