Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

Posts

OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#1

OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

Barry Irby

>I have been remodeling a house for my cousin. We completely rewired it. Beside the kitchen door we have a 3 way for the kitchen lights and a switch for the outside light at the door. The other 3 way switch is at the entrance to the all. The power to the kitchen lights is fed to the 3 way at the hall. I failed to provide a HOT feed to the box at the kitchen door for the outside light (MY BAD).

What I have is a two wire for the outside light from the box at the door and a two wire that feeds the kitchen lights. And a three wire between the switches across the kitchen and a two wire feed to the 3way at the hall. (Ignoring the grounds for simplicity, but they are there) I have the blacks and reds connected to the switches and they work. In this scenario, the white wire in the three conductor between the switches carried the neutral across the room and feeds it to the kitchen lights.

The insulation and sheet rock are now in place and fishing new wires will be difficult. There is a very low crawl space and a beam under the wall and the roof comes down low over the door, making access tough. AS nearly as I can tell, none of the black or red wires stays hot all the time, depending on the position of the switches. The question is, can anyone think of a way to rearrange the wires and provide power for the light a the kitchen door?

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#2

Probably not.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> The question is, can anyone think of a way to rearrange the wires and provide power for the light a the kitchen door?

I've found the best way to solve all my 3-way switch problems is to draw a quick, simple diagram of how one works (see below—ground and neutral not depicted). With that in view, you can easily adjust for the various configurations (fixture in between the switches, fixture at one end—power at the other, fixture and power at both ends, etc.). Of course, once you've done enough of them, it's easier to visualize it in your head.

I think you'll see that it's pretty difficult to get past three wires in what you've described (just analyzing it mentally—if I put it down on paper as I'm suggesting for you, I might see a different possibility). I suspect you're in for some inconvenient wire pulling. Maybe you'll get lucky and you can use the existing wire as a pull for the three conductor. But think how happy you'll be when you're done.

By the way, I'm sure with your experience and profession you have more than a passing understanding of 3-ways—I wrote most of this and included the diagram for those who might not have that grasp of the concepts. I also know I don't have to remind you not to be seduced into using a ground as a neutral, electrically tempting though it may be…

Rod


img

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#3

Actually

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I've seen it done, but the electrician who followed the work tore it out and pulled a new wire for the new load and switch.

How was it done, you ask? A jumper was put on the two "hot" lead terminals (black and traveler) at the remote switch, one of which is always hot depending on the primary "line feed" switch position. That jumper supplied the hot lead for the new branch circuit. The jumper didn't effect the 3-way's load (provided the two loads don't overdraw the switches). Oddly enough, this was also used to create a branch for outside porch lights.

My electrician opined that whoever did it was asking for a fire, and he would not put his license on the line over 40' of wire and a few patched sheetrock holes.

I would not have seen this nifty bit of shortcutting had we not renovated (just completed) our kitchen and decided to change out several of the 4-way switch sets that the drug addict who built our house seems to have been in love with. This also prompted me to have the other multi-switch set ups in the house (12 in all) inspected by the Sparky to make sure this slick trick hadn't been repeated. Fortunately all passed.

mm

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#4

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

GalenV in Iowa

>If I understand what you have it does sound like you need to get a hot to the outside light switch box or a two line power and nuetral to your light. If the light was in the soffit it might be easier but if in the same insulated wall as the switch it will not.

You could put the outside light on a three way switch by using same black and red feeds. The bad part it does not put the outside light on a dedicated switch position. If you cannot easily see the light from the switch position through a window or door it is a bummer.

I'd try to do it right.

Never lucky enough to have an outlet in the same stud run below switch to pick up a hot?

Galen

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#5

Doesn't make sense Mark.

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Jumpering the 3-way switch terminals will defeat the 3-way's function and render the switch inoperative. Or maybe I just don't understand your explanation.

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#6

Here's a way

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I'm not an elctrician, but I ran across this while looking for an answer to another post. If you connect the new switch and light in the plce of the powered outlet it would work. I have no idea if this meets code.

Lee


img

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#7

Re: Here's a way

Fred Davis

>

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#8

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

Fred Davis

>The question is .. can anyone think of a way to rearrange the wires and provide for the light at the kitchen door?

The answer in my opinion is a "Electrican"

That may sound trite , but after reading the responses it is appearent why.

FredD

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#9

Re: Doesn't make sense Mark.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The 3-way uses alternative hot legs to feed the load through the remote switch. Which one of those legs is hot depends on the main switch's position, but one must be hot at all times for the remote switch to function. The jumper takes a lead off both incoming legs at the remote switch, but allows that switch to still interrupt the flow to the original outbound load because it joins ahead of the switch.

That's how it was 'splained to me after the "WTF?!!" when they opened the wall to reconfigure the 4-gang box this thing was sitting in.

Tell me "you can't get there from here" and I won't dispute you, but the outside lights worked, and I paid for a new feed line to be run for them. Come to think of it, there was an occasional flicker when we turned on the outside lights when the inside light was on. Maybe I dodged a bullet on this one?

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#10

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

GalenV in Iowa

>If the only constant hot in the circuit is at the hall switch ,as I understand, then all there is are switched hots at the door. It takes at least another wire, just depends on where you want to run it.

If the duplex box was a deep box you could put in a miniture latching relay then a normal single pole switch would be position correct for the porch light.

Better than the three way and not know light condition without looking.

Shocking isn't it.

Galen

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#11

Re: Doesn't make sense Mark.

Dutch Keizer

>Does make sense if it was the other way around. Outside would flicker if inside were switched because of momentary interruption while contact moves from one side to the other.

Unless you lit up your backyard like Disney World, I don't think you dodged any bullets, although any inspector would have shot it down.

Being a just retired, livelong industrial electrician I don't know much about res. codes or tech's, but as a longtime lurker I have to shake my head at some of the electrical advice offered here. People like Sam D. and Rod P. usually have it right, but get buried in the B.S.

If you're not an electrician, please do not give electrical advice.

Dutch.

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#12

Re: Doesn't make sense Mark.

Dutch Keizer

>Sorry, meant Dan D.NM

Re: OT Need some 3 way switch Electrical magic

#13

Um, Dutch? NOT Advice

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>If you reread my posts I'm hopeful you will see that I was NOT giving electrical advice, but rather merely reciting what was discovered in my own home during a remodel. I did not wire the damn thing, nor would I have done so, nor would I suggest that ANYONE ever do so. Paradoxically, from the basic res. wiring knowledge I've picked over the years, I also know better than to do so.

I've lived in the house (built '84) for nearly 20 years. Stupid **** like this has tried to kill me on several occasions, and it's not the first dangerous situation that I have found and corrected in a house that was supposedly custom built and properly inspected.

I'm not a licensed electrician and so do not give electrical advice on this or any other forum. The question raised was "is it possible to do", Rod opined that he didn't think so, and I merely related what I had seen that seemed to go the other way while at the same time relating that the example, when discovered, was promptly ripped out and corrected by my electrician. That's not advocating that someone else try to do it.

If anyone else here viewed my post as suggesting it be replicated, please remove that misunderstanding from your psyche, and replace it with

"DO NOT ATTEMPT TO DO THIS, AND DO ALLOW ANYONE ELSE TO DO THIS."

As my electrician said, 40' of wire and a little spackle is not worth dying for.