Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

9.5 KM per Liter OT

Posts

9.5 KM per Liter OT

#1

9.5 KM per Liter OT

Dustmaker Mike

>OK I have heard this one to many times.

First off in Europe the octane rating of low grade gas is 95 and high grade is 98.

To get this high an octane in the US you will have to go to an Airport. The price of MO gas at the airport is ~4.00$ a gallon which equals 1.05 a liter. The price of 100 octane is ~4.66$ a gallon which equals 1.23 a liter.

My truck has a 5.4 liter engine in it which gets me ~21 MPG which equals ~9.5 KM per Liter.

My friend has a car in Europe with a 2 liter engine that gets 12.5 KM per liter.

Please check my math because my truck is a lot bigger then his A4, and I don't think this is a bad thing(-;

So why do I always hear we are not paying as much for gas and we need smaller cars like they do in Europe?

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#2

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

Howard Norman

>Mike, a quick check didn't find any problems with your math. Doesn't mean their isn't any just means I didn't find any.

I think the A4 would be more fun to drive than your pickup but I think your pickup would be a lot safer in a car accident.

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#3

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

Alex Grigoriev

>I guess not that many people drive 2L in Europe.

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#4

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>My memory is not sharp as it once was, but isn't 1 U.S. gallon equal to 3.824 Liters

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#5

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

Andy Halterman: No play time

>You actually get 21 mpg from a 5.4 V8 in a truck? I guess Ford has done something since '97. I've got that motor in a 15 passenger 350 van and if you reverse the mpg numbers you get, that is what I average here.

It drops down to 8-9 mpg with the 6x12 box trailer behind it.

Hard to pull all that equipment on a bike trailer.

Andy Halterman

The "no replacement for displacement" rule extracts more of a toll than I'd like in Hendersonville, NC�

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#6

Check your math

Paul Woolson

>1 US gallon = 3.78541178 liters

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#7

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

Clay Foster

>Mike,

My eyes glaze over when you get into math. The only part of the metric system that ever caught on in Texas is 9mm.

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#8

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Hi Mike,

I think the question that many North Americans would have to ask themselves is why do they need to drive a big truck around with an empty box 99.5% of the time?

The answer is that they don't need to, and they could save themselves a ton of money and reduce their impact on the environment by choosing to drive smaller vehicles.

Now for a look at the costs...

21 mpg is great fuel economy for a truck, more like the economy I might expect from a diesel truck. I picked a 4WD Ford F150 to look up, which is rated by the US EPA at 14 mpg combined driving cycle. Most people achieve worse than EPA fuel economy. I can believe 21 mpg if you are mostly driving on the highway. http://www.fueleconomy.gov/Feg/bymodel/2009_Ford_F150_Pickup.shtml

Your 21 miles/US gallon converts to 8.9 km/L, not 9.5 km/L. In metric, 8.9 km/L would conventially be reported as 11.2 L/100 km, which is very good for a truck. Most medium size cars only achieve 8 to 10 L/100 km.

Next, the price of fuel is MUCH higher in Europe than $1.23/litre. Probably more like $3 or $4/litre, so when looking at driving costs in Europe you have to use European fuel prices, so you're doing a bit of comparing apples to oranges.

Third, in some places in Europe that I'm familiar with, there are steep yearly registration fees for vehicles with large engines (typically > 2 L, that's why so many Euro cars have 2 L engines). These rego fees can be thousands of dollars a year.

Fourth, I would guess that most people in Europe are driving much more fuel efficient cars than your friend. The three Germans and two English people I regularly work with all drive small diesel cars, averaging around 4 to 6 L/100 km (approximately 50 mpg). The quality of the diesel fuel is excellent compared to what we get in North America.

So, if I compare my numbers for a person in Europe...

Big Truck, like Ford F150

Can carry 4 people, but some configurations are 2 people only.

Vehicle cost amortised over 10 years ($40,000/10) = $4000/year

Yearly registration $2000/year

Fuel cost for driving 15,000 km/year @ 14 mpg (16.8 L/100 km) & $3/litre fuel = $7560.

Insurance = $2000/year.

Other costs like tires are also higher than for small cars. Not to mention that you could never find a parking spot for a big truck in the centre of Tallinn. On top of that the emissions required to produce a ton of steel to make this large vehicle are also larger than for small cars.

Total cost = $15,500/year

Greenhouse Gas Emissions = 12 tons/year (EPA Estimate)

Next, a small car such as a VW Lupo or VW Golf (which is considered a mid-size car by my German friends).

VW Golf comfortable seats 4 people; tight leg room in the rear seats.

Vehicle cost amortised over 10 years ($30,000/10) = $3000/year

Yearly registration $500/year

Fuel cost for driving 15,000 km/year @ 6.4 L/100 km & $3/litre fuel = $960

Insurance = $1200/year.

Even with a small car you still can't find a parking spot in the centre of Tallinn, never mind that you don't have a cell phone to pay for parking...(long story)

Total cost = $5,700/year

Greenhouse Gas Emissions = 6 tons/year (EPA Estimate)

So, at the end of the day you can have a nice comfortable vehicle to drive you around safely in both cases. One case costs $15,500 per year at 12 tons/year GHG emissions. The other case costs $5,700/year at 6 tons/year GHG emissions.

One of these cases (you pick) makes a lot more sense for most people. If you cut the cost of fuel down to North American levels, the small car still makes much more sense unless you are a contractor or have 10 kids.

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#9

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

Charlie Self

>I'm sticking with my old S10 5 speed. It gets between 21 and 24 MPG, and still hauls sheets of plywood, though not flat--but, then, it's only about 11 miles home with the wood. The 2L engine is not dead, but it ain't any too lively either.

Our 2L Stratus pushes 30 MPG on the road, 27-28 MPG for just local driving, but we live in the boonies, where it's about 10 miles to anything, whether a grocery store, HD, or city hall.

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#10

driving a "big" truck to Walmart

John K Jordan

>>do they need to drive a big truck around with an empty box

>99.5% of the time? ... the small car still makes much more

>sense unless you are a contractor or have 10 kids.

I agree with this - many (perhaps most) who drive bigger vehicles don't really need them. However, there is a good reason some people "need" to drive a big truck empty most of the time. My personal transportation is a a huge 3/4 ton diesel truck. I use it to pull the horse trailer, transport the tractor, move goats, haul beehives, carry bags of feed, haul hay. This truck will carry an amazing weight comfortably - I carry water in a 325 gallon water tank in the bed and I recently hauled home over 2000 pounds of stall mats for the horse barn. A truck is almost essential for farm/rural living.

We do have a fuel-efficient family vehicle, but when my wife has it at work, that truck is what I drive to the drugstore or the bank or doctor. So yes, mine is one of those empty much of the time.

Once a person from Germany on another forum blasted all Americans as shamefully irresponsible for owning such vehicles - he thought they should be banned, unconditionally, except for commercial operation. He was so irate that if he had seen me on the street driving my truck empty he would probably have thrown a rock at my windshield - his sphere of experience and closed mind allowed no place for such a vehicle.

BTW, my diesel truck averages about 18 miles per gallon, about $2.25/gal at the moment. My wife's car gets over 25. My big flatbed truck with a gasoline v8 gets about 8 MPG so it sits idle 99.5% of the time - it sure is great for hauling logs home to saw, though!

JKJ

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#11

Re: driving a "big" truck to Walmart

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I am as large and taller than Bill Grumbine! I drive a '04 F-150 because I FIT in it. I have been in about ten other vehicles in the last four years, including the largest SUVs. It is impossible to drive when your knee cap is touching your adam's apple. When we are restricted to 2L matchboxes, I will claim federal disability. Can't work, can't get there.

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#12

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>Let's talk economic reality here. In your example above, I'd have to add in the cost to rent a truck for the 0.5% of the time I actually NEED a truck to do what I need to do ... or pay for delivery ... not participate in many activities that I enjoy and/or make extra money doing ... etc.

I actually happen to have a 2nd vehicle. My truck gets 17MPG, other ~30MPG. Right now, the truck is the nicer vehicle, but that'll reverse as the truck gets even older and the car gets replaced.

Even when gas was it's highest, it still costs me significantly more to have the 2nd vehicle than it saves me over just driving the truck. Better for the environment ... yes, better for my wallet ... not even close. Bottom line, I'd be better off with just the truck than any other solution. If you need a truck a couple times a month, the best economic solution is to drive a truck, even if it's empty most of the time. Not to mention the messy driveway factor.

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#13

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I'd agree that it doesn't make sense to have a second vehicle for the 99.5% of the time you don't need a truck.

But the economics of paying $50 for one or two deliveries a year, or renting a truck at $100/day for a couple days a year - compared to the extra thousands a year in costs for driving a big truck around every don't compute.

Convenience is, of course, priceless.

I'd love to have a truck one day a year to haul some plywood home, but it's just not worth it (for me).

quote "for the 0.5% of the time I actually NEED a truck to do what what I need to do ... or pay for delivery ... not participate in many activities that I enjoy and/or make extra money doing.". For me, a small car does not prevent me from doing any activities that I need to do or that I enjoy, and I do not make an extra money with my vehicles. Not all people agree with this assessment and are willing to pay huge amounts of extra money for a bit of extra convenience.

99.5% of the time I get away with doing this:


0.5% of the time I do this: (actually I've only rented a truck and/or paid for delivery three times that I can recall in he last five years):


Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#14

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

Chris Friesen

>There's no real reason why high-octane fuel needs to cost all that much more--it's a supply and demand thing. Octane itself is fairly cheap. Therefore the whole octane comparison is a red herring.

Currently in Saskatchewan/Canada I pay around 0.72USD/liter for regular. In England currently they're paying around 1.29USD/liter.

Also, your friend's car can probably do a lot better than that if driven carefully. My Toyota Matrix gets better than 17 km/liter (40mpg, or 5.9 liter/100km) on the highway.

Re: 9.5 KM per Liter OT

#15

Steven Antonucci

I love the Hybrid folks...

steve antonucci

>They feel all eco-conscious because they get 35MPG and are low pollution, but they never recover the cost of their initial investment. I think the average Hybrid vehicle costs $7K more than it's gas equivalent. Over 35,000 miles, that's $.20/mile.

My Nissan Frontier gets 23MPG highway, which is a majority of my driving. In July, it will be 4 years old, and I've got 32K miles on it. If you want to worry about saving money/the planet/whatever- don't drive unless you have to! When I go out, I make all of my stops and I maintain my vehicle.

Much ado about nothing.

Steve