We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Now that the new law about lead in toys is not going to be delayed for a year, how does this affect small quantity toymakers? I make what I consider to be heirloom quality toys and sell a few at local craft shows and give the rest as gifts to relatives. I use only wood finished with polyurethane and wax which to my knowledge contain no lead. Would I have to have them tested if for sale? Obviously, I couldn't do this because of the cost, so it would effectively end my toymaking. What are the toymakers out there going to do?
>How about selling them UNFINISHED for X amount of $$$. Or selling them finished along with a disclamer, "Not to be used by children under the age of?"
>If you're selling toys without any certificate of testing are the local police going to confiscate your goods? Unlikely. For the small scale builder/seller I wouldn't worry about it.
>If you try to stay current the best way is check with the product safety commission web site. Sounds like even though law you can continue till Feb 2010 as long as you think the finishes would meet standard. Since most paint manufacture are meeting similar safety standards you can probably consider them safe to the best of your knowledge. Just don't use zinc paints or probably other metallic. Wood is allowable in table B so just insure the accessories are to. The out seems to be the age of 12 so sell as collectables like someone noted.
Since anyone can sue you for no good reason you are at risk just getting up in the morning.
>several places. Please, no one jump me for my opinion but I too find it hard to belive there will be toy police showing up at craft shows. It SEEMS to me the regs ( I HAVE NOT read the actual regs in detail )are aimed at imports from other places that did and continue to import banned finnishes and materials. Not Garage Joe Wood Worker. I BELIVE ( just me, now ! ) its an honest reg aimed at protecting the public. Also, I agree that it is probably an area that Gov should'nt have HAD to get involved with but . . . yadda, yadda, yadda.
Doesn't look like you have anything to worry about *LINK*
John E in SC
>as long as the toys aren't painted. Just read this article today. Looks like a little common sense has finally prevailed, and toys made out of wood will be exempt (as long as they're not painted). I would think you would be fine with any type of clear finish. Bottom line for me, I'm just not going to lose sleep over this.
>>> How about selling them UNFINISHED for X amount of $$$. Or selling them finished along with a disclamer, "Not to be used by children under the age of?"
Won't work. If they are or are intended for children 12 or under, they must be certified. Makes no difference if they are unfinished or not or whether they are finish with what the maker purports to be "lead free" products.
Re: Doesn't look like you have anything to worry a
Howard Acheson
>>> I would think you would be fine with any type of clear finish.
Not so sure of this. After all, oil based paint is just varnish with opaque pigments. True, lead was used as a white pigment to make almost any color more opaque reducing the number of coats of finish that would have been required.
The Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA) is a sweeping new law that impacts a broad spectrum of our economy. From manufacturers of toys to the kids that play with them, everyone is affected in some way -- even those who make and donate products to hospitals and charities.
There are new rules to be understood and adopted for everyone from the largest global manufacturer to the crafter working in the family workshop to the mom-and-pop shop on the corner�
Question�: I work part-time in my home making clothes and toys for kids. Am I affected by this law?
CPSC's Answer: Yes, the law covers all manufacturers and importers -- large and small, domestic and foreign. All businesses, including handmade toy and apparel makers, crafters, those making charitable donations, and other small business must take appropriate steps to be sure that their products conform to all aspects of the law and safety standards, including the new lead content and phthalates limits and mandatory toy standards.
>According to the article I posted above, the question is not if the law "covers" small business people. but rather what the "enforcement" will be. True, the law may technically apply to ANY manufacturer, but if the CPSC itself says it won't be ENFORCED for products known to be safe from lead, whether tested or not, wood toy manufacturers shouldn't have anything to be concerned with.
>The problem is that it was probably aimed at the problem toys, but the law makes no distinctions. It is also possibly true that no one is going to go after the little craft shops, but per the law, what you would be doing is illegal and you are just assuming(hoping) that no one prosecutes you. All it would take is a local prosecutor out to make a name and your life is ruined. Is it worth the risk? I think the thing to do is get the law fixed.
It is my understanding that not only is it incumbent on the manufacturer (like you) to test the material going in to the toys , it mandates testing the toy for the same thing after it is made from those test approved materials.
If this legislation doesn't qualify as dimwitted , what would you call it?
>one opportunistic shady shyster in search of a willing client and we'll have a class action against ALL manufacturers. I can already hear the gears turning in some of those cunning, unscrupulous minds, looking for an easy payout!
>In other words, if you are making a toy and the components have been tested before you get them, do you have to have the finished toy tested again ? If not, then it's just a matter of getting material safety data sheets from the suppliers, such as the paint supplier certifying that their paint doesn't contain any harmful agents, right ?
Re: Can someone explain how the testing part works
Dan Donaldson
>Unfortunately, it does not work that way. You still have to have each type of product tested after manufacture. Hopefully, there will be enough backlash that some ot the bad parts of the law will get fixed.
>This was discussed on another forum where I came across this link. Within material in this link, there were additional links to letters written by the current and incoming chairs of the CPSC responsible for enforcing this law.
If you read between the lines, it is easy to see that (1) the tremendous outcry from toy makers of all ilks made a difference, at least temporarily; (2) the chairs point out that they did not write the law and only Congress can change it, but they (the chairs or their staff) realize the unintended consequences and are prodding Congress to make changes; (3) certain materials are deemed to be "lead free" including wood (no mention of finishes); and (4) while the law is actually in effect, the Commission will only take action if actual injury is caused, and that, in the exact words of Commissioner Moore, "...If you have been making products without receiving any safety-related complaints, you should go on selling your products."
You can read the original article and get to the links at this link...
>(The Commission generally will not prosecute someone for making, selling or distributing items in these categories even if it turns out that such an item actually contains more than 600 ppm lead.) Sellers will not be immune from prosecution if CPSC's Office of Compliance finds that someone had actual knowledge that one of these children's products contained more than 600 ppm lead or continued to make, import, distribute or sell such a product after being put on notice. Agency staff will seek recalls of violative children's products or other corrective actions, where appropriate.
So, as long as you do your level best to make sure that you're making a safe toy, sounds like you're not really at risk. If you dye the wood with something like food coloring, or probably even a good aniline dye, and then treat it with poly/oil, not only will it be colored, it'll probably look a lot better, too. AND, not have lead in it.
One more thing, prosecutors who are trying to make a name for themselves generally go after someone/something familiar to the public eye, that will yield a windfall profit for themselves and for the community. Going after a small business toymaker who was really trying to make something nice is really not going to help them, or the community, with anything.