Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Posts

Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#1

Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Jerry Samsen

>I used to pride myself on how I mentally prepare for each table saw operation. So this last weekend I as behind on my own personal schedule and had messed up a cut which forced me to make a trip to purchase some replacement stock. I was in a hurry and had to rip two pieces of 4/4 cherry to width. I made the second cut and for some reason looked to my right as I was removing the second piece. I felt a "vibration" on my right index finger. Took a second to interpret the feeling as having hit the blade. Looked over and saw a mangled finger tip. First thought was "what have I done" second is "that was stupid". All this a result of being in a hurry and having my head not in the operation.

I don't use a blade guard as the original was crap. I figure if I do this long enough I may not be so lucky next time. So I'm looking for recommendations for after market blade guards. I have a Delta 34-444 contractor's saw with 30" fence, use a zero clearance insert with after market splitter.

I've looked at the Delta/Biesmeyer.

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#2

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations *LINK*

Stew Pharis

>Jerry,

The fact that you're able to type a message leads me to hope that the damage won't be too bad and your recovery will be relatively quick.

I've used the Excalibur Over Arm Blade Cover and an after-market splitter for about 9 years. It keeps the blade covered for most operations, although I do have to remove it for really narrow rip cuts. All in all, I've been happy with it. I've included a link to the Excalibur on the Woodcraft Website.

Stew Pharis


http://www.woodcraft.com/product.aspx?ProductID=834091&FamilyID=21140

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#3

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Tony - Memphis

>Sorry to hear about your finger. Glad it wasn't worse. I bought a used Brett Guard for my Delta 34-444 (Redmond and Sons in Atlanta). I liked it so much I kept it when I gave the saw away and just installed it on my new PM2000. The PM200 guard is ok, but when ripping less than say 4", the guard gets in the way.

Tony

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#4

Another vote for Excaliber

Neal in San Jose

>I mounted mine on my SawStop (I'm serious about keeping fingers attached) and really like it. The effective dust collection is a real benefit as well.

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#5

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Fred Davis

>Jerry,

look at your momentary loss of focus and regard it as a wake up call.

I seriously doubt you will repeat that incident , but go for a blade guard , it will make you feel better, but...don't let it take the place of your innate vigilance .

FredD

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#6

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Jim Dillon

>Jerry,

Hope your finger (and pride) heals fast. Ten years ago I bought the Brett-Guard for my 10 inch cabinet saw and like it a lot. At the time I was shopping, I learnt that there were two philosophies behind blade guards: one is having a rigid, nonmovable guard to keep your finger(s) out of trouble, or two, a "movable" guard to serve as a warning if you touch it. Both, to me, seemed reasonable approaches. I guess a third approach would be having no blade guard at all, but I really didn't consider that option - given my accident-prone nature. I ended up with the Brett-Guard when I ran across a thread somewhere that described using the Brett-Guard in a woodworking shop for BLIND people. I figured if a blind person could safely use a TS, then there was hope for me 8-). So I went with it and have been very pleased. I combine the Brett-Guard with a Beismeyer splitter, as the Brett-Guard built-in splitter is worthless. I did look closely at the Excaliber and thought it was very nice as well - plus having built-in dust collection. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#7

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I recently replaced my overhead guard (older model Excalibur) with a Shark guard. I'm happy with the change. You could make arguments for an overhead in some cases. But, the fact is I use this one more often. It's easier to take off when necessary. It also does a better job at dust collection. The overhead guards looked like a better solution to me at first, but when I would have to take it off for an operation, it was longer and longer before putting it back on. Once I decided that I never wanted it back on, I got the Shark.

Jay St. Peter

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#8

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Jerry Samsen

>Thanks. I told my wife that it wouldn't happen again but she doesn't believe me. Said she is expecting that some day I will walk in holding my fingers. She told be to go out and buy a $2000 Sawstop contractor's saw but that seem excessive. Especially when a $400 blade guard would do the trick.

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#9

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Neal in San Jose

>Jay (or anyone else with an Excaliber): You say you needed to remove the Excaliber for some operation. I've only had mine for a year or so, but so far have not found it necessary to remove it. It slides out of the way on the dust collection/support tube, and I made a hook to hold it up out of the way when it is in the way, like for very narrow cuts, but I haven't found any operation that requires complete removal. Could you elaborate on what operation required you to remove it? I do most of my cross cutting with a sled, and it isn't in the way, and for ripping it is just where I want it. TIA Neal

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#10

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Robby Wright

>I bought the PSI "dust collector" overhead guard that is similar to the Excaliber. I can't say it is a total waste, but right now, I use it mostly to hang my hearing protectors on it.

The original guard setup has the guard device side mounted to the overarm parallelogram that moves it up and down. The side-loading of the guard caused it to bind so it wouldn't move up and down properly. I redid the mount so it was directly under the parallelogram. After fussing with counterbalancing and such, it moves ok. It doesn't pick up the dust as well as I would like because the front of the guard box doesn't come down to the surface, so the dust escapes beneath the front of the guard.

The main reason I don't like it is that it gets in the way and is hard to see through. I found myself removing it more and more and finally just took it off the arm. I recently saw some designs for the guard box part that I like and am thinking of adapting to my overarm unit.

I have a Biesemeyer splitter and after taking off the pawls, never saw without it. I like that I can remove it quickly if doing dadoes and such. I recently purchased the improved splitters from Shark Guard and am looking forward to trying them.

Hope your hand heals perfectly.

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#11

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Robby Wright

>I bought the PSI "dust collector" overhead guard that is similar to the Excaliber. I can't say it is a total waste, but right now, I use it mostly to hang my hearing protectors on it.

The original guard setup has the guard device side mounted to the overarm parallelogram that moves it up and down. The side-loading of the guard caused it to bind so it wouldn't move up and down properly. I redid the mount so it was directly under the parallelogram. After fussing with counterbalancing and such, it moves ok. It doesn't pick up the dust as well as I would like because the front of the guard box doesn't come down to the surface, so the dust escapes beneath the front of the guard.

The main reason I don't like it is that it gets in the way and is hard to see through. I found myself removing it more and more and finally just took it off the arm. I recently saw some designs for the guard box part that I like and am thinking of adapting to my overarm unit.

I have a Biesemeyer splitter and after taking off the pawls, never saw without it. I like that I can remove it quickly if doing dadoes and such. I recently purchased the improved splitters from Shark Guard and am looking forward to trying them.

Hope your hand heals perfectly.

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#12

A blade guard is good but

North of the Broder

>did you use a push block or shoe?If not, that will help you prevent a repeat of the accident - with or without a blade guard. A splitter, a blade guard plus a push shoe will be as close as a SAWSTOP.

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#13

Shark Guard

mdclor

>I just got mine about a month ago and wish that I had purchased it years earlier.

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#14

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>Yeah, it can be moved out of the way to some extent. But, frankly it was always in the way. When I moved it out of the way to the right, it was usually because I was using some form of tall jig. I like to use my right extension table to hold the parts I'm working on. Trying to swing the parts into place was often blocked by the guard, so just pulling it off the other direction was the easiest thing to do. It was/is so nice not having it there.

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#15

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

Stew Pharis

>Oops--sloppy writing. What I intended to say was that I have to lift the guard up for narrow rip cuts, leaving the blade unprotected.

Stew

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#16

Thanks Jay

Neal in San Jose

>Different methods of work. So far, so good for me; but now that you've mentioned it.....

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#17

Re: Thanks Jay

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>I was positive about the overhead guard for a few years. Over time I slowly left it off the saw more and more.

The shark guard is very new, so we'll see in the long run. But, so far I think it is the best possible solution for me. I already used a splitter, so it isn't much of a stretch. DC is also way better, on and off in seconds.

Re: Aftermarket TS blade guard recommendations

#18

Re: A blade guard is good but

jsamsen

>I do use a push stick or the Grrippper. However, I grabbed the finished piece from the back of the saw, turned my head to right and took my eyes off the saw area, and continued to move my hand. That sloppiness brought my finger into the blade.

Thanks all for the suggestions. I am looking at the Shark Guard very seriously.