OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>Not wanting to further hijack the Antique Secretary Wood thread, I'm creating this new one to address the subject above from a thread a couple of weeks ago. The original question was “why are hospital outlets ‘upside down’?”
There were lots of answers, some actually correct. Mainly, unless you're wiring a hospital or your AHJ says something different, it's personal preference.
And there was this one: If I remember correctly, NEC started mandating ground on top in the early eighties. The same poster later wrote: Ground down is not a argument or a cosmetic preference, it is a code requirement in the State of California. In the same post, he further stated: Beyond that , take a look at a GFCI receptacle, install with the ground down , makes the test and reset labels upside down.
Since I'm pretty sure (from extensive research) that the NEC doesn't address this, I asked several times for a cite from the NEC supporting the poster's position. You've no doubt seen the very condescending response finally offered, which not only doesn't cite the NEC, it doesn't provide a cite from the California codes purporting to require ground up.
He did cite wikipedia (is there any less authoritative a source than wikipedia, which is only as good as the most recent edit and which is just as likely to be made by a 12 year old XBoxer as anyone with an actual clue?) and a distributor's picture page as evidence, but let's look a little deeper.
There are lots of electrical fora on the internet. One can choose to heed or ignore the content as one sees fit, but here's one example:
a WC-like electrical DIY forum. And here's another: an electrician referral page. But don't take my word for it—do a search with the string receptacles ground up ground down and you will find that the internet is rife with debate akin to our own pins/tails first or grounding PVC debates.
Probably the most respected electrical forum is the Mike Holt forum—sort of the “John Bridge” of the sparky world.
To save you a lot of linking and reading, here's a quote from the Mike Holt link above:
Mike Holt�s Comment on Ground Up
No the NEC does not have any requirement for the orientation of the receptacle ground terminal. No the NEMA diagram does not apply. Device manufactures do not have requirements for the orientation of the ground terminal.The definitive answer is the NEC has no requirement (outside of possibly hospitals). Local codes can obviously supersede the NEC, which is why the one answer better than the correct “NEC doesn't care” is to check with your AHJ.Note: I call[ed] Pass and Seymour a year ago on why they place the word "Top" on the metal mounting yoke of their receptacles. I spoke to an engineer there and they said that they recommended this practice. I ask her to send me something in writing. Her response was that they didn�t have anything in writing.
No, I was never a licensed builder (hangs head in shame), but neither am I ignorant nor unable to draw reasonable conclusions from knowledgeable sources. And, no, my area isn't “a little backward,” thank you very much. My point is, A) you can't cite NEC on this, because they don't have a position, and 2) you can only cite five California counties (maybe) and one Kansas area (maybe again) as having a position on the subject. Without a cite from those sources, your word on the subject isn't, shall we say, definitive.
“You have a nice day and stick to what you do best.” Well thank you. What I do best is expose the uninformed when they misrepresent. When I can get them to choke on their misinformation, it's the best of all.
Rod






