Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

Posts

OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#1

OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Not wanting to further hijack the Antique Secretary Wood thread, I'm creating this new one to address the subject above from a thread a couple of weeks ago. The original question was “why are hospital outlets ‘upside down’?”

There were lots of answers, some actually correct. Mainly, unless you're wiring a hospital or your AHJ says something different, it's personal preference.

And there was this one: If I remember correctly, NEC started mandating ground on top in the early eighties. The same poster later wrote: Ground down is not a argument or a cosmetic preference, it is a code requirement in the State of California. In the same post, he further stated: Beyond that , take a look at a GFCI receptacle, install with the ground down , makes the test and reset labels upside down.

Since I'm pretty sure (from extensive research) that the NEC doesn't address this, I asked several times for a cite from the NEC supporting the poster's position. You've no doubt seen the very condescending response finally offered, which not only doesn't cite the NEC, it doesn't provide a cite from the California codes purporting to require ground up.

He did cite wikipedia (is there any less authoritative a source than wikipedia, which is only as good as the most recent edit and which is just as likely to be made by a 12 year old XBoxer as anyone with an actual clue?) and a distributor's picture page as evidence, but let's look a little deeper.

There are lots of electrical fora on the internet. One can choose to heed or ignore the content as one sees fit, but here's one example:

a WC-like electrical DIY forum. And here's another: an electrician referral page. But don't take my word for it—do a search with the string receptacles ground up ground down and you will find that the internet is rife with debate akin to our own pins/tails first or grounding PVC debates.

Probably the most respected electrical forum is the Mike Holt forum—sort of the “John Bridge” of the sparky world.

To save you a lot of linking and reading, here's a quote from the Mike Holt link above:

Mike Holt�s Comment on Ground Up


No the NEC does not have any requirement for the orientation of the receptacle ground terminal. No the NEMA diagram does not apply. Device manufactures do not have requirements for the orientation of the ground terminal.

Note: I call[ed] Pass and Seymour a year ago on why they place the word "Top" on the metal mounting yoke of their receptacles. I spoke to an engineer there and they said that they recommended this practice. I ask her to send me something in writing. Her response was that they didn�t have anything in writing.

The definitive answer is the NEC has no requirement (outside of possibly hospitals). Local codes can obviously supersede the NEC, which is why the one answer better than the correct “NEC doesn't care” is to check with your AHJ.

No, I was never a licensed builder (hangs head in shame), but neither am I ignorant nor unable to draw reasonable conclusions from knowledgeable sources. And, no, my area isn't “a little backward,” thank you very much. My point is, A) you can't cite NEC on this, because they don't have a position, and 2) you can only cite five California counties (maybe) and one Kansas area (maybe again) as having a position on the subject. Without a cite from those sources, your word on the subject isn't, shall we say, definitive.

“You have a nice day and stick to what you do best.” Well thank you. What I do best is expose the uninformed when they misrepresent. When I can get them to choke on their misinformation, it's the best of all.

Rod

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#2

We Must Be Backwards Too

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>As there's no such requirement in New Jersey.

Funny thing though, every one of my outlets has the volt/amp ratings cast into the face of each socket such that to read the numbers and letters "right side up" you have to install the device "ground post down", and the GFCI's all have the word "top" on the mounting flange such that the ground terminals are at 6 o'clock. My supply house actually has GFCI's with the sockets rotated 90 so the device can be installed horizontally while keeping the ground wire on the bottom.

Seems like a lot of extra money being spent by device manufacturers if they have to make special units just for California and other more advanced areas.

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#3

Re: We Must Be Backwards Too

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I also spent 26 years in the apparent electrical backwater of the nation because it doesn't use the NEC—Chicago.

My GFCI receptacles have the Test and Reset buttons labeled both right side up and upside down. Does anyone think that would be the case if NEC had a position in the matter?

And don't forget, you were never a builder.

Rod

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#4

A Tale of Two Builders

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>A man is flying in a hot air balloon and realizes he has become lost. He reduces height and spots another man down below. He lowers the balloon further and shouts, "Excuse me, can you help me? I promised my friend I would meet him half an hour ago, but I don't know where I am."

The man below says, "Yes. You are in a hot air balloon, hovering approximately 30 feet above this field which is located between 40 and 40.5 degrees North latitude, and between 58.75 and 59 degrees West longitude, at about 435 feet above sea level."

"Ah. You must be an ARCHITECT," says the balloonist.

"I am," replies the surprised man on the ground, "How did you know?"

"Well," says the balloonist, "everything you have told me is technically very correct, but your information doesn�t bear on my current problem. While I have no reason to doubt you, the information is not in a form that is usable, I have no idea what to make of what you have given to me, and the fact is, after receiving the information, I am still lost."

The man below says, "Oh. You must be a CONTRACTOR."

"I am," replies the now-surprised balloonist, "but how did you know?"

"Well," says the man, "you don't know where you are, or where you are going. You have made a unqualified promise which you had no idea how to keep, your ability to keep it is subject to factors beyond your control, and you expect me to solve your problem merely because I happen to have more familiarity with this particular place into which you have dropped yourself. The fact is, you are in the exactly same position as you were before we met, but now it is somehow my fault even after I have given you the precise information you requested."

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#5

Let's just make everybody happy

Henry Higginbotham

>Except Fred and Rod, of course. ;-)

Or is it (-; ?


img

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#6

Great Job!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I could actually use a few of those |:-}}}}}

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#7

JL

Need a big receptacle box though.

JL

>Love the pic.

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#8

Re: Let's just make everybody happy

Howard Norman

>Henry, who makes that triple outlet? I know a couple places where I would like to use one of them.

Howard

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#9

Funny....

John in NM

>I've seen the exact same thing with engineers and managers.....

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#10

I've got to agree...

John in NM

>If one is going to claim "its required by code", better be prepared to cite chapter, section, and paragraph, or else be a good sport and admit you made a mistake. It happens to all of us, and the rest of the world judges our character not by whether we never make one, but by how we handle it when we do.

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#11

Universal

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I didn't write it (got it from a contractor friend who's a balloonist), but the same thing would apply to any two people engaged in different phases of any industry or endeavor.

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#13

Wow! I thought Henry PhotoShopped it…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…and, if you happen to click on "Duplex" on the left, the select either 15A or 20A, guess what? A manufacturer's (one of the largest) illustration of a receptacle with the ground down!

Haven't they heard of Fred?

Rod

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#14

Fine Print

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Rod,

You obviously missed the fine print

"not available in California and Kansas"

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#15

Yup

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I'm gonna git me soma does.

Up, Down & Sideways 'bout covers it any whichaway.

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#16

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Check under the surge protective...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...receptacles on that page. There is a sixplex receptacle that fits in a double-gang box. Essentially one of those triplex connected to its Siamese twin.

Jason

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#17

Re: I've got to agree...

Fred Davis

>John ,

in the areas of the country that do insist on ground pin up , who do you think is doing the insisting , surely not the code if you subscribe to Rod's rant. Maybe it's just a personal cosmetic preference of the home owner, home builder , or a DYer gone wild ??

I left a voice message with the Ormond Beach Electrical Inspector's office and he had the good humored grace to call back and we talked about ground pin orientation.

For his jurisdiction in that town , he said "until the NEC clearly states a preference for the orientation ,then they would do it anyway you want"

When I asked him if this meant say, alternating orientation from outlet to outlet , he laughed and said "absolutely"

How about a double gang fourplex with up and down in the same box, "he said if that's what you want "

On a personal preference , he would go with the pin up purely for safety issues and he said many builders there do, but not by code requirement.

So that is the current state of affairs for down there , but obviously not everywhere. Certainly not the cutting edge I guess you could say.

For the people who know me , there is no issue with my credentials, for people who don't , they can draw their own conclusions.

It serves no useful purpose to keep up a thread that has become a personal attack on me, especially by a person who is a amateur in my field of endeavor ,simply for the reason that he has no professional standing in it.

end of discussion from me on this . Like the Ormond Beach electrical inspector said , "put them in anyway you want them".

FredD

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#18

Nope, and here's an even stranger one

Henry Higginbotham

>I wish I were that good with Photoshop. Meanwhile, here another interesting critter. 120V and 240V in one duplex. Not only is it real, but I have one in service in my shop and another half-dozen or so in a box somewhere.

Our local electrical inspector (now retired) wasn't fazed by it, though he had a reputation as a real stickler sometimes.


img

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#20

That is strange

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Years ago I was amazed when an electrician friend procured a duplex 20A 240V receptacle for me. Never saw one before. I installed it in my ham shack, primarily to power an amplifier, but on the odd occasion when I might run a multi-operator/two-transmitter contest, we'd get a second amp in. Naturally it had its own circuit. Both phone and CW (Morse code) are relatively low duty cycle draws, so no sweat on the load.

Yeah, I've been playing with this stuff for over 40 years. There are still things to learn.

Rod

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#21

Re: I've got to agree...

Rick Christopherson

>I noticed the original thread, and I thought it was a rather foolish discussion on its face, and this second thread is even more foolish. There are more important things to discuss than this, and that is why I didn't bother posting back in the original thread.

However, I do take issue when people make an argument that something is dictated by either local or national code when it is highly unlikely (and known to not be in the NEC). There have been far too many cases where a person has called a local inspector with a specific question, received a specific answer, and then later posted to the internet that what they heard was dictated by local code, when in fact it was just an answer they heard from a single source.

I don't agree with the tone and intent of this thread, but I do agree that if you are going to claim that something is dictated by a local code, then it does in fact become necessary to cite that code.

Instead of calling the Oramond inspector, you should have called your own inspector and asked for a reference from local code.

I cannot begin to count how many times someone has claimed that their local code precluded multiple 240 volt outlets on the same circuit, only to discover that it was a misinterpretation of information from a single source, such as calling a local inspector with a specific question. That may not be the case here, but until a citation is given, I do have to weigh in with my skepticism. (Rod, don't take that as being supportive of your original posting.)

Re: OT Ground Up/Down—Facts & Hogwash

#22

Tempest in a teapot

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I'd like to urge everyone to resist the urge to get personal with your criticisms of others' observations. There are plenty of misconceptions on a lot of topics, and thoughtful discussion and sharing of experience and expertise are expected, even if not everything said is demonstrably factual. Few things, in woodworking or electricity or anything else are absolute, least of all local bureaucrats and squishy regulations.

The power of a forum is to provide enough corollary information and differing opinions on a topic that we get really close to the "right" answer, as opposed to a magazine article, say, where one author's facts are all you have to go on. Nobody is right all the time, and that's okay. The trick is to correct or challenge misconceptions dispassionately and not make it a personal matter.

Thanks for understanding.

Ellis