Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

Posts

OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#1

OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

Ralph Lipeles

>My bathtub has tiled walls (1 3/8 square tiles)on the 2 short walls and the long wall. A section about 2 ft by 2 ft has come loose so I have a pretty big repair job ahead of me. There is also a 1 ft by 1 ft section that feels loose and ready to let go. I assume that I will have to remove the tile and sheetrock down to the studs and redo everything. That ends up a section 6 feet high by 11 feet long. One alternative is to go with tiles again. But before I do, I would like to understand the other alternatives, I have seen acrylic 3 wall systems but they look to be pretty thin and do not have a look that appeals to me. I have been thinkuing about Corian or Hi Macs. Has anyone had experience with these materials as bathtub wall coverings?

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#2

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

steve mackay

>I put up one of those "kits" with the sheets and pre-formed corners for the BIL. Just did'nt like it. Seems that if EVERY over-lap or seam isn't PERFECT its going to leak. And it does. Couple years after that the FIL asked me to look at his tub / shower. A couple five or six tiles coming off. BUT I could'nt tell how far the problem had gone BEHIND the wall. I SUGGESTED that he bite the bullit and have a pro re-tile. He did. Good as new and has another fourty years in it. I know the little Hottie on DIY can knock out a tile job in a weekend but I also know I CAN'T.

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#3

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

Curly Smith

>You might look at "Shower Wall Panels"

a quick google search gives these among the vast number of hits:

http://www.onyxcollection.com/new/stand_shwr_walls.html

"Onyx panel is approximately 3/8" thick and is a solid color throughout."

Fixing a Worn-Out Tub Surround

http://www.thisoldhouse.com/toh/article/0,,194327,00.html

"For our bath, we covered up the old yellow-tile walls around a 5-ft. tub with Wilsonart's SSV. The �-in.-thick material..."

You don't have to live with the flimsy tub surrounds that might be the first easy choice if retiling isn't a viable option. And, if you have a Wilsonart dealer in your area then you'll have a large number of color and pattern choices which is either a benefit or a curse.

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#4

Not sure about current methods

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I don't know what the current recommended method is, but several years ago cement board was the recommended material.

When we remodeled our bathroom, LOML wanted the pink wall tiles eliminated, so out came the existing walls and tub. Above teh new tub, I installed 6 mil plastic against the studs. Then installed 1/2" cement board over that. I used a thin set grout mix that used a latex additive. The thin set work well and I could do an entire wall in a day. So far ( nearly 10 years) we have had no problems with leaks or loose tile and some members of the family take steam the wall paper off the walls type showers.

Lee

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#5

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

Bill White

>I have cultured marble panels in our large walk-in shower.LOTS less expensive than Corian, no grout lines, no brainer.

Bill

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#6

Me too.

John E in SC

>Cultured marble shower for 5 years now - very easy to clean, looks great, counting labor, probably not as expensive as tile, no grout, etc. Would do the same thing again in a heartbeat.

John

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#7

Did the cheapy

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I did the "cheapy-fix" to a bathroom in our last house. Those $150 3-piece plastic walls that glue up over the existing tile.

It goes up quickly, looks fine initially, but I expect that they are temporary fixes. We moved shortly after so I don't know how well they last, but expect the need to be replaced on a regular basis.

I've been looking at the "cultured-marble" and Corian and various other man-made panels. Most are about 1/2"+ thick and look very nice in the showrooms.

I'll be watching this thread eagerly to learn more.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#8

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

Howard Norman

>This is my second house with a cultured marble shower. I lived in the first house with that type of shower for twenty five years without any leaks. This shower has been in about ten years now. There was an overlap in the two houses of about five or six years. Highly recommend that approach. The previous house also had the cultured marble surround above the bathtub as you need in your case.

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#9

Around here (California North Coast)

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The stuff I see most frequently in the home centers is "Silestone," which I think is Corian-like.

Haven't used it yet, but we probably will in our second bath remodel.

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#10

Re: OT - Cultured marble

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I SHOULD have done cultured marble.

Instead, I hung large ceramic tile, the hard kind. And it took me ten days to two weeks, with grouting, and sealing and all. And it is a pain to clean, although it looks nice. Only LOML and I care, though. No one else sees that shower.

Save yourself some pain, and see what good looking cultured marble you can find.

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#11

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

Fred Davis

>I lost my reponse Ralph , will get back to you after bowling ;-))

FredD

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

#12

Re: OT - Bathtub walls alternatives

Fred Davis

>Ralph,

we used a product available from any Marble casting shop when the client either didn't like Ceramic tile or liked the smooth surface of Onyx.

Onyx a a couple of advantages over cast marble.

1. It looks better , check both side by side and see if your wife does not agree.

2. It is much stronger structurally .

3. It is opaque , light will shine though it , if your checking to see which product your looking at.

4. There are mouldings of the material to cover the top and side edges , making them appear to be much thicker.

5. The corner over lap pieces look much neater then cast marble.

6. if you opt for either the Onyx or Marble , let the shop install it, for the reason that if they misdrilled some fixtures holes, it is on them ;-))

I have a custom made vanity sink top made by a caster in Belvue , Kansas, that my wife picked out , it has roses on each edge of the sink, garners many good comments. If you wish I will post a Pic.

In any event , if you have to replace Sheetrock , use WR board ,generally a light green color and water resistant and required most places.

FredD