Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

Posts

Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#1

Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hi, all -

My inlaws gave us an old secretary this weekend. Belonged to my wife's great-grandfather. Inlaws think it's mahogany, but it sure looks like walnut to me. Anyone able to tell from these pics?





Thanks,

Scott

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#2

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

Charlie Self

>Looks nutty to me. I'd say beautifully figured walnut at the stage where it starts to lighten in color.

Wonderful piece, by the way.

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#3

Walnut

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#4

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

Ralph Lipeles

>Walnut

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#5

Alan Young

Looks like Walnut but say Mahogany if it means

Alan Young

>you'll loose it! Somethings aren't worth being right over:^)

Alan

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#6

mahogany

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>for a positive ID you would have needed a more close up picture but the crotch panel pattern and the style says mahogany.

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#7

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>It looks like a walnut veneer to me, but you need to look more closely at the grain to tell for sure.

Lee

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#8

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

Robert Lemon - Sacramento CA

>Scott, I did some enhancements of your pictures. The pieces are veneered over a lighter wood. My guess is the veneer is Walnut.


img

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#9

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood? 

Robert Lemon - Sacramento CA

>


img

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#10

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood? 

Robert Lemon - Sacramento CA

>


img

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#11

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

Robert Lemon - Sacramento CA

>Scott, It looks to me like the drawer has been refinished and has dried residue on the end of the front. Also has some shading on the side of the drawer, possibly sprayed on toner. That is a beautiful secretary! Bob


img

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#12

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Looks like walnut to me, although on the continuum from expert to ignoramus, I'm over toward the ignoramus end. We have a mirror (four feet high, originally mounted atop a chest of drawers I suspect) and headboard veneered in similar woods, and the pieces of solid wood on them are clearly walnut; filled grain, so it's less obvious in the modern world, where so much walnut is finished open-grain. On ours, entertainingly, they stained the back side of the mirror so well that I didn't realize the secondary wood wasn't walnut until I drilled holes in it for the french cleat that holds it on the wall. Same with the headboard, but by then, I knew.

I really love that they veneered the flap with that gnarly, knotty piece - kind of a marriage of Nakashima and veneer, if that's not too oxymoronic.

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#13

compare your crotch....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I seem to be loosing the popular vote on this issue so I will provide supporting data for my conclusion. Forget the color as mahogany was always colored in those days. Compare the details of the crotch on your right door to the one in the attached picture. Walnut crotch just doesn't look like these crotches. Furthermore look at the long figured pieces on the top and drawers. Again, this is classic figure for mahogany. And finally, the style of the piece, again typical of a mahogany piece. I have one similar.


img

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#14

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

Fred Davis

>Scott ,

Apparently the first reply didn't stick.

On first glance I felt that the piece is Walnut Veneer, over what is any body's guess.

What I know for sure is your wall receptable is wired to modern code , ground up . ;-))

FredD

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#15

I'm with you.

Steve Schoene

>Looks like mahogany to me as well. After they have some age, the two woods are very hard to distinquish.

If you really, really need to know you can send a piece to the USDA Forest Products Laboratory. in Madison Wisconsin. They identify wood with no fee (!!!) for up to 5 samples in a year.

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#16

Re: I'm with you.

John K Jordan

>> send a piece to the USDA Forest Products Laboratory.

This works - allow 6 weeks. They need only a very small sample.

Or find a place where you can shave the end grain and examine it with a 10x magnifier. R.Bruce Hodley's book "Identifying Wood" has photos of end grain of various species. You can guess all day from photos of the piece and still be wrong.

JKJ

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#17

Please cite

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> What I know for sure is your wall receptable [sic] is wired to modern code, ground up.

Just constantly repeating that doesn't make it so. Please cite the paragraph in the NEC that specifies ground up or ground down.

Can't do it? Want to cite a local code? Go ahead. That doesn't make it so for the rest of us. Ormond Beach, Florida is perfectly happy with ground down. They're the only ones I care about.

And by the way, my GFCI receptacles are labeled to read both ways. If it was an NEC issue, they wouldn't be.

Rod

Some people have thirty years of experience, others have one year of experience thirty times.

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#18

Unless Scott's fooling you

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>and turned the secretary over before he took the picture.

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#19

Re: Unless Scott's fooling you

Fred Davis

>Never thought of that Bill , lol ;-))

FredD

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#20

Re: Unless Scott's fooling you

Fred Davis

>

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#21

Still waiting for that cite.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Shouldn't be too hard to come up with for someone with your knowledge and experience.

Rod

Re: Help ID'ing antique secretary wood?

#22

Re: Please cite *LINK*

Fred Davis

>Rod,

Time is short and for some, pictures work better then technical text.

The NEC is a huge code , subscribed to by most building code jurisdictions in the country, perhaps your area is a little backward.

NEMA 5-20 (North American 20 amp/125 V. grounded )

In new residential construction since about 1992 ,a 20 amp receptacle with a T-slot for the neutral blade allows either 15 amp parallel blade plugs or 20 amp to be used.

The above is a direct quote from, Wikipedia with the female receptacle shown with the ground pin orientation up in a picture.

The link I furnished is pages from a Hardware catalogue showing NEMA'S

male plugs and female receptacles and you may note , all are shown with the ground pin orientation up.

NEMA is the manufacturing standard in this country for outlets and plugs in working in conjunction with the Fire Underwriters Board which is the code formulation panel of the NEC.

I bet you knew this anyhow , but what the heck , some don't.

AS a licensed builder which you never were, I know that Jurisdictions vary not only from State to State code wise , but from county to county and municipality to municipality and from year to year for the specific code adopted by the various governing bodies.

Having stood more rough in and final inspections on residential units then I could ever count , the inspection did not vary in any of the five bay counties I contracted in and ran work for developers in on this particular subject in the state of California which is where my career in building was done.

I presently reside north of Abilene , Kansas where I own several single family homes for rentals and I happily noted that Abilene subscribes to the same electrical code requirements I have always been familiar with.

I say happily because north of town in the county where I live , there is no code enforcement of any kind chattel housing wise , one can imagine the upgrading done here when we rebuilt the place.

Building permits are required , only so the tax assessor can monitor your improvements for purposes of tax assessment. No inspections or code enforcement officer exist I am sad to say.

You have a nice day and stick to what you do best.

FredD


http://www.frentzandsons.com/Hardware%20References/plugandreceptacleconfiguratio.htm#20%20Amp.