Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

Posts

Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#1

Dale Lenz

Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

Dale Lenz

>to customers. Often get ask by potential customers what's the difference between satin and high sheen finish. My reply is the high sheen is akin to a new car's a paint job, very shiny and smooth. Still have a difficult time with satin. Have used the terms: eggshell, closer to the wood, primer texture like on metal (always get a high sheen order out of that one, : ' >). Try to refrain from negative words like dull and such. Can some of you folks help me out on this issue?

TIA

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#2

My take on the degree of shine

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I've never used the term "high sheen" so not sure if this helps. I used to paint boats and motorcycles with wet sanding and rubout being part of the process. The shine increased during that process. Most paint finishes follow the following order from lowest to highest degree of shine.

Flat: This is like your contractor wall paint. Also like the spray on metal primer. No shine whatsoever.

Eggshell: This has just a tiny touch of gloss to make wall paint womewhat washable. No real shine, but if you look at it sideways, you can see a bit of reflection. Roughly equal to 300 grit wet sanding an automotive paint coat.

Satin: This has more gloss than eggshell, but still very mild. About equal to a rubbing of finish with 0000 steel wool. Also about equal to 600 grit wet sanding an automotive finish. Many folks find this very appealing for wood finishes on furniture or floors.

Semi-gloss: Now we're starting to get some gloss. Subtle, but definitely has reflective properties. Gentle enough gloss that inperfections do not jump out at you, but it looks very pleasing. This is about the equivalent to the first rubout stage of an automotive finish with rubbing compound. I also find this to be the most pleasing wood floor finish.

Gloss: This is the upper end of shine. High gloss reflections. Too shiney for normal furniture in my opinion, but many disagree. Not really applicable to wall finishes. Equivalent to the final compound rubout on an automotive finish. Think of your family car finish.

Super-gloss: This is the finish that looks two feet deep. It's achieve by applying multiple coats, wetsanded in between to build depth and fill all imperfections. You probably sand off at least half of everything you apply to achieve perfectly flat finish layer. Think piano finish. Think show car glass-like shine.

Hope this helps

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#3

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

GalenV in Iowa

>Dale

Just my opinion but the best thing to do is make samples of the finishes and on the woods you use. I sure do better in picking when I see the real thing. Also shows them the quality you can produce on finishes.

I fall back on what I used before on home interior and exterior paints cause they use so many terms and even then the color can make a difference and that is not trying to show the surface features like with wood.

Galen

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#4

Re: My take on the degree of shine

Chuck in ND

>Also, starting at semi-gloss on down to flat there is silica sand mixed in to dull the finish, gloss and super-gloss do not have any sand in them and are considered the most durable. I use almost allways a semi-gloss on furniture, and gloss on floors.

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: Revision

Dale Lenz

>Thanks for the information so far. Ninety-nine percent of my customer are Internet customers. I do have a picture of high sheen product on my website. Really don't think a potential customer cares How I do my finishing, they only care about the finish results.

So my revision is how to describe verbally or over the phone the differences between high sheen(grand piano type) vs. "satin" finish on wood.

TIA, once again,

Dale

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#6

Re: Revision

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I would say that satin is in between gloss and flat and leave it at that. If they persist I'd say it's shinier than flat but not as shiny as gloss.

Another tactic is to tell them which of your sheens is most popular. They might then make a choice based on popularity.

Ed

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#7

Re: Revision

GalenV in Iowa

>Dale

The high gloss photo you have shows the high quality of your high gloos finish. Can you duplicate the photo with your other finish and see how much it shows the difference? Maybe the reflective quality will help define. Over the phone refer them to your web site if they heard by word of mouth.

Galen

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#8

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

Fred Davis

>Dale,

I find that samples of finish on wood are more helpful in explaining a finish to a client, then trying to paint a picture with words.

Also you are mixing terms when you use "Eggshell" to describe a clear finish appearance when it is actually a term used to describe a actual paint texture look.

Using Lacquer as a example , I tell the client the look ranges from flat , rubbed effect , satin, semi gloss and gloss and even higher gloss with rubbing compound.

The prince of finish effects is French polish using shellac which is more work , then most would do.

I also point out that a look like semi-gloss in lacquer will calm down in a few months to a more restrained look , keeping that in mind , a client might start out with gloss to arrive at semi - gloss a few months later.

Using the same terminology that the finish manufacturer does ,cuts down on confusion and endless arguments about the "look" of a finish.

FredD

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#9

Dale Lenz

Re: One good answer right there...

Dale Lenz

>in front of me thanks, Galen. Phone call are normally folks than have came from my web-site, hence they have seen my picture of the ultra high sheen. Until I have a satin finish picture up on my website, I'll try the wall paint description. Any other thoughts? Thanks a million folks!

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#10

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>In reading this thread I'm wondering about a way to describe the finish that does not involve finish terms like satin, gloss, etc. But some thing the average person would be familiar with. What comes to mind for me is this. Flat = a photo reproduced on a color printer on plain paper, Satin = about half way between the plain paper photo and a true photograph on glossy photo paper (or a comercial matte finish photo) Gloss = an catual glossy finish photograph. am I anywhere close?

Like any profession (or involved hobbyist) we tend to use terms to describe things that leave the layman wondering. I deal with this at work all the time. Terms or words that I find so descriptive and fit the situation so well (at least in my mind), often earn me extreme case of the "Hereford stare".

glc

glc

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#11

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

After thousands of gallons of paint...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...that I've applied as a painter over the years, I would agree with most of your list, except in non-automotive finishes, eggshell is pretty much always shinier than satin. Oftentimes, I've even found eggshell to be too close to semi-gloss for my liking.

If you ask to see the technical specs on a coating at a paint store, somewhere in those specs will be a number describing the sheen based on the amount of reflectivity at a given angle, usually 60�.

Jason, pro painter

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I've seen it go the other way

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>My folks have a round kitchen table that opens to allow for extra leaves. The leaves only get used when there is company (like my family or my siblings' families), which isn't all that often. After ~17+ years of daily use (getting wiped off before and after each meal), the main part of the table has pretty much a semi-gloss shine to it, whereas the lesser-used leaves are closer to the original satin sheen. Being a commercially-purchased table as far as I know, I have no idea what the finish material is.

Jason

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#13

Dale Lenz

Re: Gary is closest so far...

Dale Lenz

>in what I have been after. A lot of the responses, respectfully, have been "shop gargan". As in most disciplines we tend to talk in words We understand. But Gary has nailed it one the head, something that the wood product customer will understand.

We have also only discussed the sheen: what about what the sheen does to see the wood grain, the texture(?). I have told folks it's easier to see the wood grain with a satin finish, whereas, the grain is sometimes difficult to see on the whole wooden piece with a high gloss without changing the viewing angle due to the glare.

Texture: Ultra High Sheen is as smooth as a new car's finish, think I'm good with that one or saying a Grand Piano type finish. Satin (eggshell, low sheen, don't think it matters unless your talking to M.D. or a finish Rep.) is ???? closer to the wood (I'm reaching here folks). Maybe what I'm after is the texture, if that's the proper term for a "satin" finish. Texture for both the finish and the wood grain, I have used the term "a warm-mellow-glow" for my satin finishes. Thanks for the assistance so far. Please continue.

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#14

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

Sgian Dubh

>Gary, I just use the descriptions given by the manufacturer of the polish I use-- perhaps it's a British thing, but it certainly makes life easy.

So, going on Morrell's sheen descriptions for their pre-cat lacquer as an example, and bearing in mind that no polish has a perfect 'gloss', their descriptions go:

90% sheen- gloss

70% sheen- semi-gloss

50% sheen- satin

30% sheen- semi or low satin

10% sheen- matte.

I added my own text after each gloss percentage rating as suggestions for descriptions of sheen to customers. Slainte.

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#15

Apples and banana's- gloss and satin gloss! :>)

GalenV in Iowa

>

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#16

grand piano finish

John K Jordan

>> I'm good with that one or saying a Grand Piano type finish.

I guess I'd be careful with the grand piano description - not all grand pianos are glossy. While I've seen and played plenty of glossy grands, my own piano is a Baldwin concert grand with a black lacquer finish just a hair glossier than a brushed satin. In fact, piano restorers sometimes use fine steel wool with a touch of very light oil on this type of finish to remove fingernail scratches common on the board just behind the keyboard.

JKJ

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#17

Dale Lenz

Re: Might be on to something...

Dale Lenz

>there, Galen. Need to roll that one a round in me head for a while. Thanks to everyone, once again

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#18

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

Fred Davis

>exactly gary,

that is why samples of finish on the wood the client picks are worth a thousand words of misunderstood technospeak.

FredD

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#19

Re: I've seen it go the other way

Fred Davis

>Quibbling aside Jason, in all of the cabinets I have had sprayed with lacquer and the thousands I have sprayed with lacquer , I have never seen a lacquer finish grow brighter with age, never happened,always gets somewhat duller.

FredD

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#20

There is more to making wood look great, than

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>putting a shinny glare in front of the natural wood.

I like using the best woods that I can lay my hands on, and from my own perspective, I like to see the wood. You can put a chocolate coating on poop, but that does not make it a candy bar.

Shiny finishes usually mean glare. Really great woods have a natural luster, often referred to as chatoyancy, which is the term for the reflective quality where the light is highly reflective off of the side of the grain, and absorbed more as it comes around to end-grain. This only refers to light from a single point source. I never show samples to a customer under diffused light like florescent, or bounced light. Nothing beats good old tungsten for warming up wood.

If I am selling my client on a great wood where I want the wood to be the feature, I usually just show them a freshly sanded sample with a fresh coat of oil, or wipe on something, then point out that they can then get however much glare that they want to hide it under.

You have to educate them that you are not selling stain pigments on a dull/ cheap substrate with a shiny surface, unless that is what you are selling, then you should forget everything I said above.

I do have a friend / associate who finishes those projects that need high-build finishes, when seeing the wood is not as appropriate.

When meeting clients in a new space, which has large windows, and maybe will be painted another color. If I am showing samples, I always look to see what quality of light is coming through the windows. Around here, it is not unusual to have a huge bank of windows with nothing but green foliage reflecting in. This is a major killer for most wood colors. I usually try to point out how they can improve the looks of my work with better lighting, or choose woods which are less effected by the green ambient light.

I like to make sample finishes, and study them under a polarized light source. Some look best with the grain vertical, some horizontal, and some best flat like a table top.

It is not often that I get the chance to use horizontal gain on a piece, but last year, I managed to work some in, and learned a new little tidbit. I was using a small fiddleback figure of Makore. Usually this type of figure is greatest in QS or rift, and most of this was rift. While I was working it, I was usually viewing it flat on a table, but when installed, the annual rings would have been sloping up at ~45� or down at the same angel. One way really reflected the light out, and the other absorbed it. Fortunately I was able to just flip the drawer fronts, and plug the holes for the european hinge cup holes for the one door that had to flip to correct this.

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#21

Dale Lenz

Re: Sorry, Keith....

Dale Lenz

>your response(s) was not what my question(s) pertained too.

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#22

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The table must not be lacquer, then!

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Or, it's just due to being wiped off several times a day for many years--something that typically doesn't happen on cabinets.

(I wasn't meaning to quibble...just sharing one of my experiences).

Jason

Re: Describing satin vs. high sheen finish...

#23

Re: The table must not be lacquer, then!

Fred Davis

>Jason,

I bet your mother is a conscientious housekeeper who polished that table top weekly , if not daily thereby giving the top a gloss that would not appear on the lesser used leaves . ;))) Just a thought.

FredD