Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Pinned M&T joints

Posts

Pinned M&T joints

#1

Pinned M&T joints

Dan Collins

>Friends: I use wooden dowels to pin all my M & T joints. I have noticed that on several pieces I have built over the last few years that the dowel is now protruding slightly from its hole. I buy hardwood dowels and generally use the same species of wood as the joint I am pinning. I am thinking maybe I am putting too much glue in the hole and it is later expanding which causes the dowel to be pushed out slightly, or maybe the dowels themselves are swelling a bit. Does anyone else have this problem and, if so, have you figured out the cause and a solution? Thanks. Dan

Re: Pinned M&T joints

#2

lumber is shrinking in thickness

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I'll wager the dowel has not moved nor grown in length. More likely the pined board has shrunk in thickness. Could be a result or winter lack of humidity, or the board swelled some upon gluing and the dowel was trimmed before this glue moisture thoroughly evaporated.

Re: Pinned M&T joints

#3

Re: Pinned M&T joints

Barry Irby

>Not sure, but it seems this is the natural response to the cross grain orientation. Wood shrinks more across the grain than lengthwise. Different with different species and more with larger changes in MC, but always some difference. My limited experience is that in short situations like a dowel through a 3/4" piece the difference is very slight, perhaps not enough to break the finish but enough to see and certainly to feel. Maybe this is why the mission style pieces use plugs that have the pillowed tops. As with many style items, it may have evolved from the necessity to hide the fact that the pins won't stay flush.

If you pins are popping back out after you drive them in, but before the glue sets, you may need a relief hole to let the excess glue and air out. Its the piston effect.

If the pins are deeper than 3/4, you may want to glue them only at the surface, so that the movement is concealed inside the hole but the pin is fixed at the entrance.

Re: Pinned M&T joints

#4

Re: Pinned M&T joints

paul in AZ

>I routinely pin M&T joints with a hardwood dowel. Most often with a pin of another wood as a decorative effect. [Not that anyone but I notice]. My favorite is a walnut pin in cherry. Given some time the pin usually protrudes very slightly. Not so that it is visible but I can feel it slightly above the surface. And not to a degree I've ever felt any need to try to fix.

I doubt that a glued pin could be pushed out by glue or that a pin will elongate. The problem is almost certainly your main wood drying slightly indoors, leaving the pin end a bit proud.

Starting with really dry wood is easy in our desert climate. Your problem could be further drying and shrinkage when the piece is brought into the house. Your shop is likely not as dry as a centrally heated house.

Re: Pinned M&T joints

#5

They work themselves out

Warren in Lancaster, Pa

>Pins gradually work themselves out over a number of years. Pins that have been cut flush on the inside become sunken on the inside as the outside protrudes. So you can tell that it isn't just shrinkage causing the protrusion. Old pieces of furniture can have a noticable protrusion and some people leave the pins that way to mimic old furniture.

Here is how it occurs. Even if you use straight pins, the pin and the hole tend to become tapered as the pin is driven home. This is because of compression; the begining of the pin and the entrance to the hole are the most compressed. In the summer as the stile swells the pin tends to stay flush at the front and pull away from the back. In the winter when the stile shrinks, the pin does not want to go back all the way and so it protrudes. Over the years the pin slowly exits.

Re: Pinned M&T joints

#6

like fields "growing" rocks...

John in NM

>frost heaves them up a little every year, eventually they make it to the surface.

So your explanation is pretty much the same as Bill's but over the longer term. I've had considerable initial shrinkage as Bill's describing, within say 6 months or a year, but haven't watched a piece for long enough or examined antiques to have a feeling for whether the pin actually moves. Definitely one to file away for the future.

Re: Pinned M&T joints

#7

Re: like fields "growing" rocks...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Many people say that shrinkage alone accounts for the pins coming out and cite the pins as evidence that an old piece was constructed of green material. I remember John Alexander was quite taken aback when I told him that it happens for kiln dried wood also. Like your rocks, it is the repeated cycles of swelling and shrinking that causes the action.

Re: Pinned M&T joints

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: My solution

Dale Lenz

>Believe most of the poster have "pinned" the answer, it's due to the pin's receiving wood shrinking slightly. A friend of mind that does a lot of Green & Green type work suggested to leave the pins slightly proud and to carve the proud top of the pin to your liken. I like to scruff the proud pins a few times with 600-800 grit S.paper to give the pin a friendly feel when you rub your fingers over them.

Know your material and... learn to work with it, not against it.

None of us could of built Rome in a day, when we started woodworking, : ' >.