Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

Posts

Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

#1

JL

Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

JL

>I'm starting a new settee.

I'm going to have a cherry seat with cherry turnings. I was figuring on using white oak for the spindles and for the hoop. I was planning on leaving it natural (without stain) and using some sort of suitable finish.

I realize that there will be a contrast between the seat (and undercarriage) and the hoop and spindles. I think it would look pretty good.

The following questions:

If I do make it a continuous arm, should I have white oak arm stumps (turnings) or cherry?

Should I consider staining the white oak or leave in natural?

The reason why I don't want to use cherry for the hoop is that it somewhat difficult to get green cherry and cherry has a tendency to delaminate when you bend it (pitch pockets). Cherry spindles are somewhat weaker than white oak - and my spindles are 3/8" at the top.

TIA

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

#2

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, pleas

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>A cherry seat with everything else painted black or dark green is a nice look, IMO. Build it with oak and cherry as you've outlined and then if you don't like the way it turns out, try the paint.

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

#3

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, pleas

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon JL,

I'm thinking over what Ed recommended, and I would probably go the painted route myself rather then leave the white oak stained or natural. Actually, my druthers would involve swapping/steaming/bending maple for the oak. I'm not crazy for the look of white oak contrasting with cherry from a textural as well as color/shade aspect. So I'd paint the oak if I used that specie in the project. Whatever you do will look great. It alweays does.

George

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

#4

hickory?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you can get it I think hickory would go better. It is tighter grained and the heartwood can be reddish. Personally I think either is going to look strange but then I am not fond of mixed wood furniture. Not in your case, but most times it seems to be done for novelty not beauty.

On the other hand, I have 4 all-cherry Windsors so someone figured out how to bend it.

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

#5

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, pleas

Ron Bauman

>Tried to send you some pics last night of Cherry, White Oak, Yellow Birch table, but got a Daemon Failure notice. Do I need to delete NO SPAM? I am officially computer illiterate. Please advise if you are interested.

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

#6

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, pleas

Ken Platt (granby, CT)

>I happen to like the contrast of white oak and cherry. I think it depends if one likes a high contrast look. Some do, some don't. I think it helps if the overall design of the piece is simple with clean lines. If it's a complex piece, then there are two kinds of contrast, and to my eye those pieces look overly contrasty (I know, it's not a word, but seems like it should be). Some still like that look, but to my eye it's jarring.

The other thing I'd consider is where in the piece the contrast lies. If the top half of the settee (spindles, hoop) is one thing, and the seat and legs another, then the piece takes on a split look rather than a unified look. I prefer contrast when there is a predominant look from one wood and an accent contrast, which is clearly subordinate. So, in this case, I'd make the seat of cherry, and the legs, spindles and hoop of white oak, and I think that'd work ok.

I'm pretty sure somewhere I've seen a shaker-style bench with that exact combination of woods, looked nice.

Ken

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

#7

JL

Yes, you need to delete NOSPAM.

JL

>

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

#8

JL

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, pleas

JL

>That's a possibility I hadn't thought of (making just the seat cherry). I have some thick white oak. I could make an undercarriage of white oak.

I was thinking about making the seat be the dividing line. I figured the contrast of the white oak superstructure over the cherry base would look nice.

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

#9

JL

Legs and stretchers also? Or just the spindles..

JL

>and hoop?

Re: Opinions on using white oak with cherry, please..

#10

Re: Legs and stretchers also? Or just the spindles

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I was thinking of a natural seat with everything else painted. Here's a suggestion. Go to Google images and search on windsor chair. In the first few pages of images there are examples of chairs with all the combinations discussed in this thread and more. Hope it helps with your decision, and hope to see a photo when you finish it.

Ed