what type of sharpening stone do I have
mark thompson
>I have acquired a few old oilstones, and was wondering if there were any identification techniques to decipher what type of stone it is?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
what type of sharpening stone do I have
mark thompson
>I have acquired a few old oilstones, and was wondering if there were any identification techniques to decipher what type of stone it is?
Re: what type of sharpening stone do I have
Ellis Walentine
>A photo would be helpful, but here are a couple possibilities for you...
If the stone is black or charcoal colored, it is probably a carborundum stone, which is generally fairly coarse. Finer grit versions are okay for pocketknives and gag chisels and lawnmower blades.
If the stone is light brown in color, it is probably an India stone, usually in the 1000-grit range, suitable for coarse sharpening of woodworking edge tools.
Other common oilstones include various grits of Arkansas stones. A fine-grit white or light gray stone is probably a medium to hard Arkansas. A coarser one with marbling of a darker color is called a Washita stone. This is the stone you would use for preliminary sharpening of chisels and plane irons, prior to moving on to the harder Arkansas stones. A super-fine, jet-black stone is called a surgical hard Arkansas and is used to put a mirror polish on your edges. You need to work your way up through the grits before using the finer grits.
Nowadays, most of the craftsmen I know are using Japanese waterstones instead of oil stones. Waterstones cut faster but they require more attention to make sure they don't wear ruts or hollows.
Hope this helps.
Ellis Walentine, Host
Re: what type of sharpening stone do I have
Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod
>If the old stones are full of crud (and in my experience that is often the case) it will be tough to see colors. You might be able to resurrect them with Gunk engine degreaser blotted with paper towels.
If you're a beginner looking to save money by using old stones I'd advise buying new stones of known quality instead. After you are proficient using the new ones you can can play with the old ones. It would be a shame if you got turned off to sharpening because you were trying to do it with an old clogged stone of unknown grit.
Ed