Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT: knife hardening

Posts

OT: knife hardening

#1

OT: knife hardening

Pat Evans

>I have two JA Henckels knives that I keep touched up with a moonstick and they will slice easily thru anything. I also have a complete set of cheap Henckels knockoffs that were a freebie from the grocery store. You have to look very closely to see any difference between them and the Henckels. However, when using them the difference becomes obvious. After just a few uses, the knockoffs become so dull that the moonstick won't sharpen them and I have to take them to the Tormek.

Is there any way, just using household items, that the knockoff blades could be hardened so they would hold an edge?

Re: OT: knife hardening

#2

Its the steel not the heat treatment

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Two things lead to a good knife- the steel and the heat treatment. Since the heat treatment is extremely cheap to do and the steel is by far the expensive element a crappy knife is more likely a result of crappy steel than improper heat treatment.

Re: OT: knife hardening

#3

PS

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You appear to be frugal. If that is the case, and you want a quality knife for the least price, go to a restaurant supply place and buy the white handled "professional" knives they will sell there. You can get a good chefs knife for less than$20 and paring knives for a few dollars. They have good steel but they don't look as nice as the Henckles.

Re: OT: knife hardening

#4

Re: PS

Pat Evans

>Thanks Bill. The Henckels I bought individually, intending to eventually collect a whold set. The knockoffs the wife got for free for spending too much on groceries. They are labeled with the grocery store name, and are so much like the Henckels, I'm surprised the store hasn't been sued by Henckels. Since the set had seven knives, a steel, and the knife block, I had hoped to find a way to make them usable.

Re: OT: knife hardening

#5

Re: OT: knife hardening

john lucas

>Pat There are a lot of things that affect the knive, edge angle, hardeness of the steel, type of steel and how finely the edge was ground. At home we can really only do anything about the bevel angle and polishing to get rid of the courser grind marks. Since we don't know what kind of steel it is, we can't really reharden it affectively and of course we can't change the steel.

I've found the cheaper have steel that allows the burr to roll over instead of sharpening away. This makes them cut very poorly.