Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Air Filtration System -Long

Posts

Air Filtration System -Long

#1

Air Filtration System -Long

GalenV

>My dust collector/air filtration system to this point is a 20" box fan and the fine alergen type furnace filter over the intake. This works if I keep it close to the lathe while sanding cause it plugs up in no time and then the air flow is reduced till it does no good. Not a good long term system.

I would like to get a unit I can hang in about a 350 square foot part of the basement shop. It seems hard to compare Jet, Powermatic, Craftsman, Delta, Grizzly, JDS and whatever else there is. Some are fixed speed and others three speed and rated somtimes without filter restriction so seem like that means little help.

Some it look like you can wash not only the electrostatic prefilter but the 3 bag filter as well. Some electrostatic or just paper prefilter are listed as disposal as well as the three bag filter. They all have a filter price tag like buying half a new overall unit. Not sure if washable is true if it is caked with fine dust, seems like you would just get a wet dust mat.

Not sure if the real low cfm are any better than home made and when larger if they run you out with noise.

From what I find on Wood Central search it is mostly the big dust collectors and cyclones.

Anyone have a simple way of picking a good air filtration unit for a small area and economical to keep filters up?

What ones to definitely stay away from?

Any commments would be helpful cause I am tired of trying to shop vac walls, floors, shelves, supplies and sure the shop vac is just resuspending it again.

Sorry for being windy, unless I put a filter over my mouth and call it good.

Galen

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#2

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

Barry Irby

>Good questions. Wish I had an answer. I made my Ambient Air Cleaner out of a furnace blower. Just a four sided box with filters on all four sides. Three are inlet filters and the other refilters the air on the way out. Just Medium quality pleated filters. When they cake up and the air flow reduces I either clean them or replace them. To clean them I blow them off with the air compressor.

As you know there are many variables. If you don't have lots of air flow, you don't have enough "energy" to keep the particles flying long enough to hit the filter. Part of the Irony is that as the filters becomes clogged it becomes more "efficient" at grabbing smaller particles, but the air flow slows down so that not as much air passes through it, larger particles may settle out before they reach the filter, but it is better at catching the smaller ones. The smaller ones that don't settle out readily are the ones you REALLY want to catch. They are the ones that go deeply into your lungs.

You mentioned Shop Vacing the walls. I know this is temping because the dust is unsightly, but once it settles onto a surface, it is no longer a threat to you because it can not make it into your lungs.

I am considering making a second air cleaner to mount in the opposite corner of my shop to help drive the air in a circle and keep it moving longer and faster so more will hit the filters. To reduce the number of times I have to clean the filters and to keep the air flow up, I am thinking of a much larger filter area. Perhaps ten filters instead of three or four.

I am also thinking of a down draft table for sanding that could also serve as an ambient air cleaner. Just letting it run even when its not in use for sanding.

The other thought is to not use an Ambient Air Cleaner at all. Don't stir the air and keep the particles flying. They may do more harm that good by keeping the particles airborne. Catching the dust at the source is a better idea. The best idea may be that filter over your mouth and nose.

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#3

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

wilbur

>"The other thought is to not use an Ambient Air Cleaner at all. Don't stir the air and keep the particles flying."

This theory never made much sense to me. The fine dust particles, which are the ones that are dangerous to your lungs, take a very long time to settle, and it doesn't take much to get them flying. An air cleaner won't add much to fine dust airborne time, but it will be taking them out of circulation as it runs, which is better than just waiting for the fine dust to settle.

In fact, I've found that moving the air around my shop more helps the air cleaner do its thing. If I'm doing something that generates a lot of dust, I'll set up a fan on the opposite side of the shop aimed in the general direction of the air cleaner.

I think most of the air cleaners that are out there are pretty much the same, but I bought a JDS 750-ER because at the time JDS was the only company that reported CFM with the filters in place (they may still be the only one), and I want to encourage good behavior.

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#4

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

Tony - Memphis

>I have a JDS 750 (about ten years old) in my 16'x20' shop w/10' ceiling. I have been very happy with it. I recently added the elctrostatic filter thinking it would save me money in the long run. I have changed the bag filter once or twice I think. I take it out and clean it once in a while. To qualify, I spend a few hours out there during the week and a lot of hours on the weekend. I'm not a big fan of sanding either. I have a "normal" DC and I still wear a mask when creating dust - always. Can quote cfm's and all that junk, but the filter on the fron of the JDS does get might dirty, so I figure it is doing something. Mine stays on high. I never touch it. As for noise, well, it sounds like a fan running liek you would expect. I kind of like the white noise though.

Tony

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#5

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

Terry in Edmonton

>I built my own unit using a pair of surplus 400cfm squirrel cage fans. It hangs from the ceiling in my shop. When I designed it I went to a commercial filter supplier and talked to them about my needs. They recommended a washable mat filter followed up by a a 2" thick HEPA filter followed by a 2" charcoal filter. This has proved to be a very good combination. The HEPA filter and the charcoal filter last about 1 year and cost about $12 each. I think the big secret to its success is the 2" thick filters. They have a LOT of surface area and don't plug up quickly.

I would look at the thickness of the filters in any unit you purchace. Reqular furnace type filters will plug up quickly and seriously reduce the air flow through them.

Good luck with your choice. Mine has made a big difference to the air quality in my shop.

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#6

Re: Air Filtration System Comments

GalenV

>Thanks for your comments.

Thought about making better home made but have done that most of my life and thought a this point buy it and relax.

I hate it when there is no industry standard rating method even if you could trust manf. self test.

I had thoughts way locate overhead and draw dust up past yourself rather than down to floor.

The fan I use is at spindle height and to the back so pulls dust away from me.

The JDS 750-ER did appear to be a users choice at other sites I looked at.

If I had a choice would rather be in warm climate and turn outside in the fresh air. Someone would probably come up with a pollution standard that would prevent that.

Thanks again.

Galen

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#7

Re: Air Filtration System Comments

wilbur

>Hi Galen,

I completely missed that you were trying to control dust while sanding at the lathe. What also helps me a lot in addition to having a hood at the lathe connected to my dust collector is to put a floor standing fan behind me blowing towards the lathe and workpiece. The dust can't swim upstream and get in my face.

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#8

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I have the Jet. It does a good job on my 500 sq ft. shop. But really, it's only purpose is to keep dust from settling on everything in the shop when I make a dust cloud. There are some devices that you just can't collect dust from well. The most used feature is the timer. I turn on the timer when I leave my shop so I don't come back with dust settled all over the place. The thing runs for a couple hrs. and turns itself off. I have had it for quite a while and keep cleaning the original filters with a shop vac.

That said, I don't really use it very often anymore. Since upgrading my DC system and converting most of my handhelds to Festools, it just isn't necessary most of the time.

I see the health benefits of the air cleaner as minimal. The dust is still in the air and I still blow brown boogers if I create a dust cloud. A good DC and/or mask are really the things for health. The air filter may help a little ... not much though. But when the cloud of dust does rise, it's nice to be able to hit the filter and not have dust settled on everything the next day. That's the main reason I still have it and like it.

Jay

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#9

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I think you are on a fools errand trying to collect your lathe dust with an air filter. You need a dust collector of some sort. A 1 hp dust collector dedicated to your lathe would be sufficient. Get the upgrade bags so virtually nothing escapes once it's in the dust collector. Rig up a big intake that you can maneuver so it is directly in line with the dust stream coming off your lathe piece. That will get the bulk of it. Add an air filter (I have and endorse the JDS 750) to get the rest of it.

Ed

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#10

Re: Air Filtration System Comments

mdclor

>I agree with the dust collector suggestion and might add that getting a good one with a HEPA filter might possibly be the best solution. That way you get the fine dust before it becomes a cloud in the shop. It wouldn't be that much more expensive than an air cleaner and wouldn't require the space of a dust collector.

Merle

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#11

So what some are saying:

GalenV in Iowa

>I would be better off with a low end dust collector and duct it to the lathe than the air filtration system over head?

Delta seems to have a low end 50-720 with a 1 micron bag and Steel City but do not see Jet on smaller with 1 micron. These just have a plastic chip bag but most chips are swept or vac, so dust is big problem.

I am in a rental townhome and had already put in one 20 amp circuit with five outlets to alternatly plug in machines.

Use my shop vac on port of band saw,table saw,and belt/disc sander to try and reduce dust but blasts my ears.

Any suggested specific brand or model on low end DC over air filtration? Retired cannot buy both right now.

Galen

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#12

Re: So what some are saying:

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Yes, get a dust collector.

I have a 2 hp Oneida cyclone now but my previous dust collector was like the Delta you mention. Mine was a 1 hp pac-rim off-brand which I upgraded with 1 micron bags from Oneida. I sold it to a friend and it is still going strong 15+ years later. You do need the better bags. The cheap bags let the fine dust out. The dust collector is much quieter than some shop vacs. If you keep the air hose short it will move plenty of air. I clocked mine at 800 fpm at the machine and 400 fpm at the end of a 10' spiral plastic hose.

To keep the sub micron particles out of your lungs you need a respirator.

You can get quick-connect fittings (Oneida sells them) and use the dust collector on all your machines in place of the shop vac. Just move it from machine to machine as needed. It's not ideal but its way better than what you have now and way better than an air filter plus your current setup.

Good luck and let us know how it goes.

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#13

Re: So what some are saying:

Barry Irby

>Ed Is correct. The lesson here is that collecting the dust at the source. Grab the the dust right where it is created and don't let it float out into the air. And the second part is to wear personal protective gear. Nothing you can do to the air can beat filtering it right before it enters your nose or mouth.

Go to Bill Pents site for more information than you ever thought existed.

I have my Dust Collector (and air compressor) outside my shop in a closet. Several advantages. Noise is reduce to almost nothing and whatever dust escapes or passes through the filters is out doors and no threat to me.

I never set up a permanent dust collection system for my lathe. The turning throws chips every where and would be hard to collect. It also generates very little fine dust. (The bigger chips that fly and fall to the floor may be litter but they are almost no health threat. What I do at the lathe is bring the DC hose up to the thing I am sanding and hook it into the tool rest as a holder. I get it as close as I can and then play the "dust stream game". I watch to see if the stream of dust off the sandpaper flies into the hose.

Re: Air Filtration System -Long

#14

Re: Bill Pentz web site

GalenV in Iowa

>Barry

When I went to Bill Pentz web site the outline part E for Dust Collector Info just gives me an error for file not found. Other files open. Maybe he has changed web site data and there is an error.

I hope Iowa is not going to be like California on state tax return and issue IOU cause I want to spend my return on woodworking equipment to support the economy! Don't think any equipment suppliers will in turn take my IOU for dust collector today.

Galen