Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

Posts

OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

#1

OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

Joe Pack

>I just installed Mac OSX Leopard and now have built in automatic backup capability. I am looking for a reliable external hard drive of at least 250 gb, up to 500 gb. From what I read, heat build up is a problem for these drives. Reviews are all over the place, so I'm looking for input from some of the computer gurus here...I trust you folks over the unknowns on the web.

I can use either USB or Firewire. Any recommendations or features to look for?

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

#2

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

John McGaw

>If the drive is used _only_ for backups and is turned off the rest of the time then heat buildup is unlikely to be a problem. I always build my own external drives so I can't suggest any specific brand but having a nice sturdy metal case and a small fan certainly can't hurt anything. If you are especially cautious, it is possible to purchase two-drive enclosures and use the drives in a mirrored configuration for extra security.

But not to rain on your parade, backups are great and are necessary but not all backups are created equal. Having your backup stored in the same place as your computer is often useless. The fire that fries or the burglar that steals your computer will likely get your backup too if they are right next to each other. The proper place for a backup is offsite -- a nice secure safe deposit box at your bank for example. And having one backup device makes things difficult since the backup will be unprotected for some length of time. Two backup drives are far better. (I'm semi-paranoid and have three drives in rotation with one of them in the bank at all times; not to mention the daily backups of critical files that live on a USB flash drive on my keychain and the weekly on another flash drive concealed in my car). And simply _making_ a backup can be dangerous: it needs to be verified after it is made to ensure that you can recover when needed.

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

#3

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

paul in AZ

>I have also read all sorts of opinions on which brand to get but wonder if there is a meaningful difference between any of them. All HDs are born to die eventually.

If you are referring to Time Machine as a backup I don't think it backs up the OS. It only does your files so your backup HD is not bootable. To create a complete bootable clone on another drive i use SuperDuper!, which is a $28 shareware. Easy to use.

My approach is to have a second bootable internal HD for when -if?- my primary HD dies and to have an external bootable drive with everything backed up to it that can be stored away from my computer. Paranoid? Not if you have had to rebuild a system after a HD crash.

The external only runs when I'm backing up to it so as pointed out heat is no problem.

Larger HDs are not overly expensive so get one at least 50% larger than the space used now. Like closet space, bigger is better.

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

#4

LaCie

John K Jordan

>Joe,

Since I've been spending my time on the tractor and on horseback instead of the computer these last few years, I asked my son the same question. He is "in the business" and keeps up. What they use at his company is LaCie drives, available in a number of sizes and interfaces, available from Amazon, Newegg, and more. I use three firewire drives for this at the moment but I'm going to get a couple more. They make several in the 1 terabyte size which look nice. Those with the ribbed case sides have no internal fan - those with smooth-sided cases have internal fans.

JKJ

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

#5

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup? *LINK*

iamrfixit

>Time Machine backs up your entire drive including the OS, in fact if you do a restore from it your system will look and work exactly as it did at the time of the backup. You can enter Time Machine and recover a single file, a few files or restore the entire computer to exactly as it was previously.

From Apple:

Back up everything.

Time Machine backs up your system files, applications, accounts, preferences, music, photos, movies, and documents. But what makes Time Machine different from other backup applications is that it not only keeps a spare copy of every file, it remembers how your system looked on a given day � so you can revisit your Mac as it appeared in the past.

I just bought a 1TB drive in a quad interface enclosure from other world computing, nicely made aluminum case with a Hitachi drive, firewire 400, 800 usb and esata. They are great to deal with and they know Macs


http://www.macsales.com

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

#6

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

iamrfixit

>Since you have firewire available you definitely want to go that route, firewire 400 is much faster than usb and firewire 800 blows it away if you have that available. All of the macs with built in firewire support booting from an external firewire drive, the intel macs will boot from usb or firewire but using firewire is much quicker. Very handy feature sometimes.

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

#7

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup? *LINK*

John McGaw

>I don't know if this is reliable or not but it sure is a great price for the size: $99 shipped for 1tB! I'm almost tempted to go and buy one simply for the price even though I don't need it...


Drive

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

#8

Maxtor/Seagate

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Both these external drives have 5-year warranties. Right now, I'm using an IBM PC that was purchased in 1998. It's Maxtor HD has performed flawlessly for over 10 years. I believe both brands are owned by Seagate.

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

#9

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

Jim Dillon

>Joe,

You're right about reviews of external drives being all over the map. I took a deep breath and got a WD "My Book" two years ago and it has been fine. This spring I got an Iomega portable for my new laptop and also have had no problems. Both are USB 2.0 and seem to run pretty cool. I got the Iomega because its color matched the laptop 8-) 8-) - and it came with a double-headed USB connection in case my laptop or older desktop USB ports were under-powered; neither proved to be the case. I've had good luck with Amazon or Newegg. Gosh, I've seen recent ads for 1TB drives for around $100; what a deal!

Jim

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

#10

Re: OT - Reliable external hard drive for backup?

Hamish

>I have USB2 and Firewire 400 external hard drives. Go the Firewire way if you can as it's that much faster. Firewire 800 is twice as fast. My discs are Lacie but I'm not sure who manufactures the workings inside.