Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT: Re-Roofing

Posts

OT: Re-Roofing

#1

OT: Re-Roofing

Ken Krawford

>My 20 year old roof needs to be replaced. The contractor specified 15# felt in the estimate. The shingles are 30 year architectural. I don't know if this has any bearing but the roof has a very steep pitch.

My question - is 15# felt adequate or should he be using 30# paper?

Thanks.

Re: OT: Re-Roofing

#2

Re: OT: Re-Roofing

Barry Irby

>Where are you? If you are in the colder parts of the country you should have an Ice and Water Shield type product along the eaves and valleys and maybe the rakes. This will help protect you in the event of ice damming. (Only Important if ice damming occurs where you live, even occasionally.) Since they are installing felt, I am assuming they are removing the old roofing. If you are doing a nail over, you don't need either the felt or the ice and water shield.

Other than that, 15 lb felt is fine but, serves little purpose once the roofing is in place, especially on a steep roof. Its like a tent. Goes on fast and gets the house "in the dry" while the roofing is being put on.

Re: OT: Re-Roofing

#3

Re: OT: Re-Roofing

steve mackay

>Mr Irby is right on. I'm the type that thinks bigger is always better so spend the money but once the shingles are on the weight of the paper has little to do with it. The shingles are another story though. Spend 'till it hurts for those ! And if you can, keep an eye on the guys when they do the valleys. Thats the first thing to go.

Re: OT: Re-Roofing

#4

No way an expert

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but I've seen some advice that the 15-lb. felt is better, because it provides some "breathing" below the shingles.

Re: OT: Re-Roofing

#5

Re: OT: Re-Roofing

Jerry Nicholson

>Check on what the roofing manufacturer requires. Use the wrong thing and you might void that 30 year warranty. The manufacturer of my new 50 year shingles required an adhesive membrane at the lower edge for protection from ice buildup. I opted to spend an extra 1k or so to get the self sealing adhesive membrane on my entire roof (about 33 squares). When my house was built it had cedar shingles (later covered by cedar shakes) so it had "skip" sheathing. I had to pay for OSB on top of the "skip" sheathing so I would have a solid roof deck under my composition shingles.

Jerry

Re: OT: Re-Roofing

#6

Re: OT: Re-Roofing

Fred Davis

>Ken,

Roofing is a area inhabited by amateurs , crooks and some reliable roofing contractors.

Without any guidance ,all of them will opt for the least expense and hassle to themselves.

Since I was a General contractor for many years in the state of California , I specified the roof covering , not the roofer and got a good job every time.

Roofers are not entirely to blame for a cheap skate approach to roofing , since they deal with insurance adjusters every day , who are not competent to survey damage and home owners who want the job done cheaply , so they can share the insurance claim money.

All of that aside , your steep roof pitch is in your favor shingle life wise and the 15 LB is adequate.

I personally from experience at looking and removing old roofs and seeing how the 15 LB. felt had dried out and deteriorated from age will opt for 30 LB. felt every time.

Beyond that , in some areas of your roof if you have them ,valleys for instance should have metal valley runs, preferably baked enamel, unless you can afford copper which is even longer lived.

Allowing the roofer to weave the shingles in the valley helps him labor and material wise and does you a disservice which you need to avoid.

Also insist that all roof jacks and chimney flashing be replaced with new.

If your in a area of country which needs it , have the first five feet covered with waterproof membrane to avoid water damage from ice damming.

Inspect the gutters for rustout and the fascia board behind them and the shingle mould for dryrot and replace before reroofing.

Lastly pick a roofing contractor that is licensed and insured and has a waiting list of customers and lives locally.

Good luck,

FredD

Re: OT: Re-Roofing

#7

Hope that works well for you.......

Barry Irby

>One of the important aspects of 15 lb felt is that it is permeable. That is, it "breaths" or allows for the transmission of moisture vapor while remaining waterproof. Think of a windbreaker jacket verses a disposable plastic raincoat. The jacket could be waterproof and shed rain, while allow your perspiration to evaporate and escape from the inside. In the plastic raincoat, after a while you are as wet on the inside as you are on the outside. So, It may not have been a good idea to install the stick down ice and water shield over the entire roof unless you are sure it is permeable. Be sure you have good attic ventilation and watch for evidence of condensation on the nails and underside of the sheeting.

Re: OT: Re-Roofing

#8

Fred makes several good points......

Barry Irby

>It might pay you to look into what it takes to get an actual written warranty on your roofing. You may find the manufacturer requires a "certified" roofer and perhaps an inspection. Then, you might get that warranty in writing. Otherwise, the "30 years" is only a projection of what they think they might last. Not in writing, no warranty.