Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

Posts

Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#1

Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

I know a guy who is getting ready to spend $9000 on 2200 sq.ft. of bamboo flooring. I seem to remember reading here about someone's bad experiences with bamboo. My friend is convinced that the 50 year warranty has him protected. Of course, the experience may be dependent on the manufacturer of the product.

Any comments pro or con?

Personally I wouldn't pay $4.00 a sq.ft. for any kind of flooring, but that's just me.

Gary

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#2

JL

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

JL

>My friend Mike installed some bamboo flooring in his 2nd floor bedroom. But he got his from the surplus place for a lot cheaper.

Anyway - it looks great. It is as hard as the dickens. He dulled the blade already on his miter saw and the replacement blade during the installation. He's had it in there for about 3 months now. What's nice (IMO) is that it is all "wood" as opposed to a thin layer of veneer on fibrous wood product. If the surplus places still have some come summer, I'll have to think about it - though the Brazilian Cherry also looks tempting. How many sq. ft. do you need? I can check over at the surplus place if you want.

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#3

100% bad

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I've seen it installed in 4 places in the last few years. In 4 of those 4 places, it isn't good. It's supposed to be really hard, but it dents and scratches way too easily and looks terrible. It's got a high gloss finish and get's dented... the finish doesn't come off like it was scratched, it just gets depressed into the flooring.

I've always read good thigns about it, but that's not what I hear nad see firsthand.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#4

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

Andy Halterman: No play time

>I just quoted a job where my cost on the reclaimed oak flooring was $11.00 per square foot. I suppose you don't want any of that? :-)

Bamboo can be hit or miss. Early stuff was good but there have been problems with the finish on some of the more recent stuff. I've seen it literally separate from the bamboo. I'd imagine the warranty would cover this but I'd get specifics. I know for a fact that certain manufactures of prefinished flooring make one jump through many hoops (some of them the flaming kind for added excitement) to get a warranty claim approved. I've been a party in enough of these situations that I think a warranty on a floor finish is worth about as much as the paper it's printed on.

Caveat emptor is my advice on bamboo. Do your homework.

Andy Halterman

This bad economy has me working seven days a week in Hendersonville, NC�

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#5

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

Justin Szeliga

>I did some work in a condo 2 1/2 years back & the client had Brazilian Cherry floors installed, & the guys bringing the fridge in dented the floor with the rollers of the fridge dolly. The stuff is as soft as white pine it seems.

Peace

Justin

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#6

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

Craig Daymon

>I've been researching it since I plan to put it in my house...once I get the house. From what I've learned, it can vary widely based on manufacturer. Many of the lower cost products buy from various sources and bundle it together. This leads to variations in thickness and durability.

I know Smith and Fong is a top manufacturer, as well as Teragren, but both are relatively expensive. I'm looking at Cali Bamboo (short for California).

I'm also planning on getting a stranded bamboo floor, which is substantially harder than regular bamboo flooring. I saw some Teragren stranded "Java" flooring at a store locally and it was the best looking "hardwood" floor I have ever seen. Cali has a "Java" product as well.

-Craig

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#7

Steven Antonucci

Ditto, firsthand experience is the same

Steve Antonucci

>

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#8

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

Doug Reynolds

>Easily dented by two labs. Removed and replaced in less than two years.

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#9

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

Barry Irby

>As a Home Inspector I did expert witness testimony on a house full of bamboo flooring. Well over 2000sf. Traffic in the house before the owners moved in ruined the finish and the builder tried applying more. It was a disaster. Looked like crap. Not subtle. When you stepped through the front door your instantaneous reaction was "What happened to this floor?" May have been the fault of the builder for not protecting the floor and doing a lousy job of "refinishing", but most builders get through this phase without having the floor go to H*ll.

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#10

Louie Lovas

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

Louie Lovas

>I have bamboo in 2 rooms of my own home for over 4 years now. Frankly I'm surprised to hear such negative comments. We've had really good results with it. Could be the manufacturer I guess. I've even been contemplating replacing some of the oak flooring.

I have the type that is vertically laminated. That might be the key to it's hardness. It's been tough wearing too even with a dog in the house. Sure it's got scratches on it, but no more that the oak flooring. No dents at all.

If you're interested I can look up the manufacturer. I still have an extra box in the back of my shop.

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#11

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

Mike Fitterling

>Too early to comment too much on durability, but we just installed about 800 square foot of it in the addition. No problems at all putting it in (stapling) except it took some finesse to hit the gun just right to minimize splitting of the tongue. I think it looks good, about the color of clear-coated maple.

My impression is it is pretty hard. Although we have not put furniture in yet, we have continued working on all sorts of stuff with it in, on ladders, stools, dragging vacuums across it, etc. with not a scratch yet. The addition is going to be the adult area of the house with no dogs, so I don't see any unusual wear problems in the future for it.

Mine is the inexpensive horizontal that Lumber Liquidators sells for $1.99 a square foot @ 1000 sq foot purchase (I sold my extra so buying at 1000 sq foot was cheaper than buying what I really needed at $2.49 a sq foot). By the way, someone mentioned bamboo flooring being mixed from different places; at LL they made sure that each box had the same sticker showing it came from the same mill batch. I had zero problems wiht color or size differences.

Cheers,

Mike


img

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#12

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

tom g

>Bamboo grows fast, and can be harvested quickly; but the "capillaries" that make up the body will be thin.

If the stand is allowed to mature, the walls of the capillaries will thicken and strengthen. Think of asparagus you pick too late- it gets tougher.

If you can get samples, use a magnifying glass on a cross-section to compare the wall thicknesses. That will help you choose a good solid bamboo that won't dent.

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#13

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

Bill White

>Bamboo is a type of grass. I looked at the stuff a while back. That's as far as I went into "green" flooring.

Bill

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#14

What? Which product? Did you expect no dents?

Craig Daymon

>Are you saying you installed stranded bamboo? If so, what manufacturer? Did you really expect to see NO dents? What miracle product did you replace it with?

I haven't seen a hardwood floor that didn't dent. If there is one, I'd like to hear about it.

-Craig

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

#15

Re: Bamboo flooring, good or bad?

slozuke

>We have the vertically laminated bamboo flooring and I have to say I am disappointed with it. We got this type of flooring thinking it would be hard but found it dents easily. As far as finish and color it looks great. I think that it because of the light color. The light color of it tends to hide the dents. Refinishing it, I have only needed to work on small spot areas and have used a semi-gloss PU and it comes out looking good.

My wife is more particular about it than I am but after 5 years of use, overall I am still okay with the look of it. But, if I had to do it over again I would probably look at other options.