Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Breaking Router Bits *LINK*

Posts

Breaking Router Bits *LINK*

#1

Breaking Router Bits *LINK*

Nick Barnes

>I have recently broken two perfectly fine router bits at the shank below the collet. They are from a reputable manufacturer, not cheapos.

I'm using them to plunge cut into 3/4" plywood and cutting out handle holes with a template (simple rectangle). I don't think that I'm pushing too hard, but I'm upping my next bit to a 1/2" shank. Does anyone have any pointers on what to do?

Thanks,

Nick


Router Bit Specs

Re: Breaking Router Bits *LINK*

#2

Re: Breaking Router Bits

David Yoho

>Nick, I think you're on the right track switching to the 1/2" shank. I only buy 1/4" shanks when the profile is small, otherwise, I select 1/2" for the majority.

The one question that comes to my mind is why you don't drill a starter hole and eliminate the plunge operation altogether? Seems that would put more stress on a 1/4" shank bit than the rest of the operation.

David

Re: Breaking Router Bits *LINK*

#3

Re: Breaking Router Bits

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I'd remove the bulk of the waste with a jigsaw, leaving 1/16" to 1/8" to clean up to the line with the router. If nothing else, your router bit will stay sharp a lot longer. Half inch shank and pre-drilled starter hole are good tactics also.

Re: Breaking Router Bits *LINK*

#4

Re: Breaking Router Bits

Barry Irby

>I agree with David and Ed.

Also, I would drill a starter hole and I would make the cut in probably three passes. Step down about a 1/4" each time unless I used the idea that Ed offered and cut most of it out with a jig saw. OTOH, I wonder if cutting a quarter inch at a time dulls the first quarter of the bit more than the rest of it? I also wonder if this does not put the lateral stress right out on the tip of the bit which might cause the shaft to fatigue and break. But, then I have done it this way many times and have never broken a bit.

I can't remember seeing a bit with a half inch shank that has a bearing at the top. Would have to have a bearing 2with an ID of 1/2 inch and and OD of maybe and inch. so the cutter would have to be and inch to be a flush trim bit. That would change the radius of the corners as well.

Re: Breaking Router Bits *LINK*

#5

Re: Breaking Router Bits

Dick Coers

>Those pattern bits are not center cutting. When you plunge it in, there is a section of wood that is left inside the carbides that remains uncut. That is probably causing your trouble. If you want to continue with the plunge cutting, I suggest you use a spiral bit, and a guide bushing. You will have to make a new pattern, but you can also easily plunge and make multiple cuts.