Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

OT: Tile Questions

Posts

OT: Tile Questions

#1

OT: Tile Questions

JPLeech in 'rural' Festus, MO

>After years of pondering, we've finally decided to get around to tiling the kitchen floor and backsplash. Which of course means we need a new stove, island countertop etc, etc. ;-) I was hoping to put a few questions to those who have done this much more than I have.

Do I have to remove the old vinyl flooring or can I just lay the backerboard on top of it? My concern is that the tile, thinset and backerboard will raise to floor enough to possibly interfere with an exterior door. If I do decide to remove the vinyl, how much of a pain is it? Also, what is the best way to handle the transition between the tile and the exterior door? Is it acceptable to just but the tile against the threshold? Or is there a way that I'm not thinking of?

As for the back splash, is backerboard necessary or can I just tile over the existing drywall? My concern is that the weight of the tile may pull the paper away from the dry wall.

As you can see, I'm full of questions and short on answers. Any pointers that you can share will be greatky appreciated!!

Thanks,

John

Re: OT: Tile Questions

#2

Re: OT: Tile Questions

Nat Robison

>I don't believe you'll have a problem with laying your backerboard on the vinyl. Some say you should bed the backerboard in a layer of thinset on plywood but I didn't do that for my kitchen (I laid backerboard directly over the subfloor) and I've never had an issue. If you're concerned about the addl. height, you may want to rip out the vinyl and (presumably) the 1/4" of luaun underneath it. It might be worth a few hours of your time. As far as the threshold goes, you should be able to tile up to it and either grout or use a sanded caulk that matches the grout's color.

As to tile on drywall, my backsplash is tile on drywall and I have no issues. I think it's fairly common to tile on drywall in any place that's not wet (i.e. a shower stall).

I'm not a pro tile guy but I've tiled in the situations you're asking about without any problems.

Re: OT: Tile Questions

#3

John Bridge Forum ___*LINK*

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Not to denigrate any WoodCentralian's tiling experiences, but asking that question here would be like asking a woodworking question at the John Bridge Forum. Although you might very well get a decent woodworking answer, they are the WoodCentral of the tiling world. Ask your questions there and you will get expert, informative, and most importantly, friendly answers to all your questions.

Rod
happy alum of the John Bridge Forum

Re: OT: Tile Questions

#4

Re: OT: Tile Questions

Fred Davis

>John,

I collaborated for years as a Contractor in CA with tile setters and learned about every trick they knew and here is a couple that would apply to your project.

Thinset is called a "glue job"in the tile trade as opposed to the standard of "wet set" " which is in mortar.

Your concern about pulling the paper off of drywall is a non issue, whereas every dip and hump in the wall structure will be reflected in the tile surface.

For someone like your self, this can be avoided with concrete board a 1/2" thick applied over the drywall and that is a time consuming job at best especially if they are clearance constraints behind the range and sink.

You may be lucky and have a straight wall to glue directly to the drywall, check it out with a straight edge.

For the floor tile, installation over a wooden subfloor without a 3/4" thickness of mortar bed will generally result in cracked tile , unless you pick a small tile , like mosaic that is a combination of small rectangular and square tile.

A concrete board will not prevent this cracking unless you can keep the board from flexing , sometimes possible with construction adhesive, but again like with the dips and humps in the wall , you have the same issue with a uneven floor.

That is the primary reason wet set tile is always a superior installation.

Having said that mortar beds are a trowel trade like cement finishing .only done by the tile setter and requires a lot of previous practice .

FredD

Re: OT: Tile Questions

#5

Re: OT: Tile Questions

Howard Norman

>I am not a tile expert but I have done some over the years. I would just put the backer board over the vinyl using adhesive and screws if it was my job. I would not worry about doing the back splash directly over the drywall either. I have hired pros to do the work that didn't do the job as well as I do and I am certainly no expert. The idea of going to the John Bridge forum is a good idea. I have used that forum several times over the past few years.