Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#1

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Well folks, things have been pretty hectic around here the past couple weeks as I attempt to break in a new computer without breaking everything else. In the shuffle, my Ides of January question never materialized, so we don't have much time to log our answers. My deadline is in about 10 days. Once again, we'll be excerpting your answers for our bi-monthly column in Woodwork Magazine.

This time, the topic is all about change:

1. Are you using hand tools more these days than you were, say, five years ago? If so, can you say why?

2. Have you changed other aspects of your woodworking routines, habits, interests or preferences, and, if so, why? You might have noticed a change in the types of projects you do, or the source of your ideas or supplies or plans. You may have changed the amount of time you spend in the shop or the complexity of the techniques and projects that interest you. I want to know how your woodworking is evolving, or isn't.

There are no right answers here. Thanks to all for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#2

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Old Father Time is taking his toll on me and as a result I spend far less time in the shop than I did a few years back. I don't have the stamina nor the desire to get involved in any lenghty projects. Guess my wild youth is asking payback now.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#3

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>1. I think I do use hand tools a bit more than I did, say, 5 years ago. I enjoy the quite nature of hand tools as opposed to the noise of power tools. There is just something I can't articulate about using a plane that I find enjoyable, the sound and feel of a plane doing its job makes me feel good. It is also often more convenient to pick up a hand saw and carry it to the wood than to carry wood to the shop, or get out the cords and worm drive and maybe the generator to make a couple of cuts.

2. The way my life has changed in the past few years has changed the type of woodworking I do. I didn't really have a shop (or even all of my tools) for a couple of years. Moving on to acreage, along with moving the house and shop, has shifted my woodworking time towards the stirictly utilitrian side of things, for now. Fence building, home and barn improvements and most importantly getting the shop restablished are my focus now. I am very lucky to have a partner who is also interested in woodworking, in fact just a couple of days ago she told me we need to concentrate on getting heat back in the shop so we can start doing some fun projects. A few years ago in Montana, Dave Smith turned Lisa on to the lathe and I see that as a direction I would also like to move. I think the appeal there is similar to that of a plane, plus the shorter time start to finish on work pieces. All I have to do now is get something better than a really old Shopsmith.

glc

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#4

yes, yes

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>1. Are you using hand tools more these days than you were, say, five years ago? If so, can you say why? Yes. I used to cut and assemble furniture. Learning to use hand tools enabled me to remove tiny controlled increments of wood which enables precise fitting of furniture components, a door for example.

2. Have you changed other aspects of your woodworking routines, habits, interests or preferences, and, if so, why? As my skills improve I build more challenging pieces. Continual improvement.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#5

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Tony - Memphis

>1. Yes, I am using hand tools more. The more I learn about them, the more I appreciate them. Many times, I find the use of a hand tool quicker, certainly quiter, and very satisfying to use. I think getting an education on them has made a big difference. learning to sharpen has made a huge difference. I appreciate the safety and control of them as well. I think Chris's focus on hand tools in PWW and their other magazine has made a difference too. Availability has made a difference too. I live in the Mid South. There aren't many good sources of used tools here. Between Ebay, Lee Valley, and Lie Nielsen, I can get any tool I want.

2. My preferences haven't changed. I've always favored 18th century style and still do. What has changed is my abilities. Ther more I do and learn, the more challenges I take on. I've always tried to introduce a new technique each for each new project. I'm a weekend/evening warrior, so I'll probably never get real good a particular technique, but half of what I enjoy about the hobby is learning new things. As for time in the shop, I'm always trying to get out there as much as I can!

Tony

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#6

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Chuck in ND

>I'd have to say the same as Ken Oakley, plus I don't think theres much of a future in it anymore. I'm really tired of busting my hump for little or nothing for so many years. But I'm haveing a hard time of shakeing off the tool addiction though, mostly power tools or their accessories.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#7

Some changes, no doubt

doug f, san clemente, ca

>I've downsized my projects simple because I don't want to be hefting around 2x8x10 boards of cherry and walnut. Dining room tables have morphed into nightstands, blanket chests into shaker boxes, etc.

Because of the downsizing and the commensurate lack of joinery, I've found myself relying more and more on handtools for dovetails, surfacing and other joinery. It's more relaxing and, I must say, more satisfying.

'Course, getting older may be the cause of all this.

Doug

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#8

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>1. Are you using hand tools more these days than you were, say, five years ago? If so, can you say why?

Yes. I can think of a few reasons why. First, I finished purchasing the majority of my large machines and have been able to pick up the handtools I use instead of saving for machines ... or paying them off ;). Second, the forums and popular media have been more active in promoting the use of handtools. I now understand why a tool is useful before I buy it. I have to admit, my first handplanes were bought with little knowledge of why I "had to" have them. Third, companies are making nice versions of the tools that don't require intimate knowledge of the tool so you can adjust and use it. My first handplane never worked well, so I didn't use it or understand why I needed it. I finally attended a seminar where I saw how it should perform and realized the advantages of it. That particular tool is gone, but I do have a combination of nice new handtools and used that I've refurbed. But, IMO the ability to refurb a tool is directly related to being able to use it.

2. Have you changed other aspects of your woodworking routines, habits, interests or preferences, and, if so, why? You might have noticed a change in the types of projects you do, or the source of your ideas or supplies or plans. You may have changed the amount of time you spend in the shop or the complexity of the techniques and projects that interest you. I want to know how your woodworking is evolving, or isn't.

Yes. I have been trying to do different things since I started woodworking. It's one of the reasons I'm still interested in the hobby. Even after 10 years, I'm not out of things to learn and try. In fact, the things I want to do still outnumber the things I've done.

I started out with lots of primarily plywood projects; cabinets, shelves, etc. Then added more solid wood components to those. Now, I'm using more variety of wood and different thicknesses of wood and most of my projects involve little to no plywood. I'm building more furniture type projects. My latest project is a coat rack. Simple, but I'm using it to try out bent lamination. Playing with designs and different techniques keeps my interest high.

Jay

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#9

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

JoeW in Detroit, MI

>1. I have never been a big user of hand tools. I guess because I view their use as art and I just feel I don't have the time to develop the talent. I find I become more comfortable with the techniques used with power tools.

2. I am probably doing a little less now than I did 5 years ago. It has more to do with life style than anything else. Work, 2 kids, and always seeming to be taking classes has alot to do with it. The weather and my setup also plays a big role. Right now temperatures are hovering around 10F and my combo machine is in the garage. I typically try to complete one "big" project a summer - something like the bunk beds for my son or the porch seing for my wife. I tend to fret alot before I try a new technique or something I view as complicated and this slows me down alot. The price of lumber also tends to delay me somewhat. Its funny, I can spend a bunch on my Minimax, but a few hundred on some oak causes me to pause. I recently pruchased a Hawk scroll saw with the intentions of learning scroll work during the winter, and that has allowed me to do some woodworking during the winter.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#10

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Robby Wright

>I find that I like working with quiet tools more. That usually means hand tools. I am getting tired of the scream of machines and find hand tools to be more soothing. Last night I had to cut some length off the legs of a stand. I found myself grabbing a handsaw to do the work instead of a power tool. On the flip side, I find the way my tablesaw makes accuracy effortless to be neat too. And I just got an 8 inch jointer, a tool I have been lusting after for years.

Lately, it seems like I spend a lot of time making cabinets from sheet goods. I built a sound console desk for my church which involved melamine coated particle board with an oak panel wrapper. I am working on some new cabinets for my shop - I finally am getting around to fixing it up and getting things organized. I'll have to post the results when I am done.

I have also found that I am enjoying just puttering around my shop, making things for the shop. When I realized this, it made me thing about an article in I think Fine Woodworking, where the author talked about a guy that had a magnificent shop and a ton of tools, but never made anything with them except more stuff for the shop. I guess I fall partly in that category, and partly in the "I like to make things" group.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, CA

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#11

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Pat Evans

>1) There are some enormously talented artisans that post on this board. I can see why hand tools would appeal to someone with natural artistic talents. I, on the other hand, have always been inclined to engineering solutions to problems. I rarely make only one of anything, so my inclination is to look for efficiency, repeatability, and accuracy. Obviously, power tools are a better fit for my needs.

2) When my wife retired last December, I imagined that I would have lots of shop time while she did some of the routine things that were taking my time. I'm not sure what happened, but adjusting to both of us being retired has actually meant less shop time. Only recently have I gotten to where I can spend meaningful time there. Of course, with the collapse of the stock market we no longer have money to do the traveling we planned, so maybe now I'll get lots of shop time.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#12

A.J. Hamler

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

A.J. Hamler

>I have a terrible habit: As I woodwork, I get stuff out -- a screwdriver here, a nail set there, etc. I get them, I use them, then I set them down. After a few hours in the shop I have tools piled on top of tools. When I need something, I can't find it. I have eight -- count 'em, eight! -- tape measures, and before I know it I'm down to having just one left because I can't find the previous seven. (I'm the cook in our house, and do the same thing in the kitchen.)

This was tolerable a few years ago, but now that I'm a full-time woodworking writer I spend a lot more time in the shop; probably more than a full-time professional woodworker does. The problem has gone from simply being annoying, to a situation that was making me unproductive.

I've made a huge, huge effort in the last two years to combat this, and I've noticed that I've finally turned the corner in a lifelong method of how I work. I'm actually putting stuff back on the hook/shelf/cabinet/drawer I got it from most of the time now. I haven't completely licked it yet, but I can honestly say that I haven't had the experience of having just one tape measure left (or just one kitchen spatula left) in a long time.

A.j

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#13

Man oh man

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>That sounds like me. I lost a hook scraper once for several months. I set it down be on a saw horse and then stacked another on on top. I didn't use the saw horse for quite a while. I turned the shop up side down, almost, found the scraper when I needed the saw horses.

My name is Gary, I'm a tool setter downer....

glc

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#14

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Hope this isn't too late for your deadline:

1) Yes, I�m using hand tools more now than 5 years ago. Why? Because the novelty of having a decent collection of ww machines, which I did not have growing up, has worn off. I�m not going to give up the machines, I love them for stock preparation and quick repeatable cuts, but the actual cutting and fitting of joints and so fourth is much more enjoyable with hand tools. Since my early introduction to woodworking and such (like chasing tools for my dad�s home improvement projects at age 3 or 4), was all hand tools and handheld power tools, I suspect that hand tools use is just more familiar to me or something.

2) I have realized that for me to enjoy woodworking I don�t have to produce gigantic projects. I find I am more focused on just enjoying the processes involved. I tend to pick smaller projects that can be completed in shorter times. Trying to be more realistic about how much time I can devote to woodworking and setting achievable goals. While larger, more complex projects are still on my list of things I hope to try, I find that taking smaller steps at this stage keeps my interest up. While a Townsend Highboy would be an incredible thing to get involved in, I think at this point I can get almost as much personal satisfaction making a picture frame in an evening. Hopefully someday I will have the time to try that Highboy, but for now I�m plugging along, improving my skills and enjoying as much time in the shop as I can.