OT more information on eating meat
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I live on a farm that raises beef and sheep, I eat plenty of both, and I worked with ruminate nutritionists some time ago..... so what follows is based on some science and experience.
1. What differentiates prime, choice, good , etc grades of meat is primarily fat content. The fact that the price of these grades decreases suggests that most folks find prime more palatable than choice, etc down the line. Ditto for the grades of sheep. I get substantially more for a prime grade lamb than one graded lower. A minority of persons add current health theories to the what-they-will-pay equation and their peak of desirability may peak at something lower grade than prime. But the purchase decisions of this population has not affected the price these grades bring at market, ie prime still commands a higher price because most people perceive it is better.
2. Animals get energy and protein from what they eat. It is no less healthy or "natural" for a ruminant to eat corn and soybean meal than it is for them to eat grass, grass seeds, honeysuckle leaves , acorns, etc. provided that the animal has the right mix of roughage and other stuff ruminants need to make things work. We showed conclusively on the project I was on that any source of protein was largely equivalent. What actually gets fed depends upon the cheapest source, which could be fish meal, soybean or other seed meal, alfalfa, clover, etc.
I worked at feed lots in TX and CO and it is true that the diets on these lots is designed to put weight on the animal as fast as possible, ie they are high in easily digestible carbohydrate. The diet is probably unsustainable for an animal long term, but they are only on this diet a few months before they are killed, so whether they might have heart trouble after 4 years is not an issue. In addition to food the animals are vaccinated, may be given hormones and mineral and other supplements. I have no opinion on whether these supplements are harmful to people or not.
I know for a fact that I can not produce a prime or even a choice lamb on my pasture without supplementing its diet with additional carbohydrate(corn in my case) and protein(soy bean meal) and some minerals (my farm is deficient in selenium). These supplements don't exceed my definition of a natural ruminant diet. I keep some lambs for breeding stock and they live to ripe old ages so I can not say that their diet is unhealthy, nor is it any more unnatural than me eating Mexican food while living in E. TN.
Bottom line-you analogy of FAS lumber to dyed lumber is not valid for a nutritionally supplemented animal vs one barely staying alive on my winter pasture. Gotta go, as it is time to give the pregnant ewes their pound of corn, soybean pellets and a bit of mineral salt. Given the enthusiasm with which they eat it, they think it is sufficiently natural.