Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

rough sawn lumber

Posts

rough sawn lumber

#1

rough sawn lumber

DP

>First of all, I want to thank all of you for the responses to my last question about rough sawn lumber. I've just about completed an Arts and Craft bed that was featured in Wood Magazine using rough lumber for the first time. There is extra work involved, but it is worth it in the long run.

I have a gentleman that wants to sell me white oak lumber that has been stripped and dried in a barn for 4 years. Is this a long enough time for the wood to be safe to use?

Thanks

Danny

Re: rough sawn lumber

#2

Re: rough sawn lumber

Steve in Denver

>For $50 you could pick up a moisture meter and test it.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#3

Re: rough sawn lumber

Barry Irby

>Moisture meter, my thought exactly. You can do it the old fashioned way by cutting out a section and weighing and drying and weighing and calculating. (look on Woodweb.com for how to do it.)

Just about as cheap to buy a decent meter as it would be to buy a decent scale to weigh the wood with.

The "rule of thumb" is one year of air drying for each year of thickness. So if you are in a dry climate and the lumber has been stickered well and has good ventilation, you might be all right. But, the "Rule" is very flawed and should not be relied on. Huge variables, species, thickness, stickers, ventilation, local humidity, time of year the lumber was cut, and maybe a half dozen more. Not a reliable rule at all. Get a meter and check it. If its good, bring the lumber home and acclimate it to your shop and house for a few weeks/months.

Good technique in building the furniture will help too. That's always a good idea.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#4

one year of air drying for each inch thick

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>

Re: rough sawn lumber

#5

Re: rough sawn lumber *LINK*

John K Jordan

>The pores in white oak are plugged with tyloses which inhibits transfer of moisture compared to other species. For example, white oak takes longer to dry than red oak.

If you live in a dry climate, the lumber will be dryer than if you live in a wet climate.

I find a moisture meter handy for this. Be sure to check deeper than the surface. I use a pinless meter which will measure down to about 3/4". The oven-drying method always works and requires only a household oven and way to weigh accurately.

Be careful of air-dried lumber, especially oak. It may be full of powder post beetles.

JKJ


measuring moisture

Re: rough sawn lumber

#6

Re: rough sawn lumber

Joe in a Cleveland Suburb

>"Be careful of air-dried lumber, especially oak. It may be full of powder post beetles."

+1.

I brought a bunch of air dried Cherry home once and found out it was full of beetles. Not sure if they were powder post beetles or not, but I learned what to look for.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#7

The perils of buying barn-stored lumber

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It is noteworthy that for the 30 years that we sold hardwood lumber that only once did I every buy any of the dozens of stacks of barn-stored lumber I investigated.

1. First, to dismiss the dryness issue. Years ago this lumber equilibrated to whatever moisture conditions were in the barn. If the barn is anywhere but Arizona the lumber will be10-15% MC this time of year, too wet to work without some additional drying. It is trivial to get such lumber from 15% MC down to something workable. So, this minor issue is not why I rejected dozens of these barn stacks.

2. There is something in the history of these barn-stored stacks that they typically contain low grade lumber, poorly sawed, and stacked. I found that the typical stack of lumber stored in a barn was log run and sawed from less than stellar logs, and often as not, not sawed and stacked well. There is a lot to know about air drying lumber, especially oak, and it is typical that novices screw it up. It couldl be that the stack you describe is the exception.

3. I don't know what it is about barns but lumber stored in them is typically covered with planer-knife-eating grit. If the stack is dusty, the dust is mineral grit and it will eat planer knives. Add this cost to the cost of the lumber.

4. An analogy I like to make to novices buying lumber is that lumber is like beef. What you are familiar with are the cuts (lumber) sold in the store(retail lumber yard) cut (sawed) from grain fed animals(high grade logs). Even the best logs yield a lot of hamburger along with the rib steak. Just like the "cutters and canners" grade of animal that only yield hamburger and stew meat, some logs yield analogous low grade lumber. So the log run barn-stacks typically will have anywhere from none, to some, of the quality lumber you are used to buying in the retail lumber store.

5.I won't take the time to type all that one needs to look for to determine what the stack contains, but one guide is the width and length of the lumber. If the lengths are short and widths 10" or less (for oak) the lumber was sawed from small logs that don't yield a lot of high grade lumber.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#8

Re: rough sawn lumber

del schisler

>kiln dried wood is the only way to go on white or red oak check this site Why take a chance on bugs in the wood i guess the larva can stay in the wood for a long time and all of a sudden wood powder To late than I have had this happen

http://www.woodweb.com/KnowledgeBase/KBPPAirDryingLumber.html

Re: rough sawn lumber

#9

a valueless rule-of-thumb

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I wish we could eliminate this saying from the woodworking vocabulary. For all the reasons that Barry enumerated above, it is impossible to make a blanket statement that provides a useful estimate of how long it will take lumber to equilibrate to its surroundings. The true range is a few months to years, which we should all agree is a useless guide.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#10

KD is does not insure bug free

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The KD process will kill bugs in the wood but it will not prevent a reinfestation.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#11

Re: KD is does not insure bug free

del schisler

>i understand that but It sure is better than not And take off the bark too I guess you can include ash as far as bugs go Their may not be any ash tree's left in later yrs

Re: rough sawn lumber

#12

problem with your analogy (OT)

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>As always Bill, an informed and complete response.

But there is one minor flaw in your food/wood analogy: that grain fed beef is the superior type. This is probably debatable and I am no farmer or husbandry expert, but I have read some about this subject and I think there is a consensus building about pasture fed ruminants versus the CAFO units. Reverting to your analogy, grain fed beef may be more like dyed or pressure treated lumber: it may be what you want for the project, but it aint natural.

Re: rough sawn lumber

#13

OT more information on eating meat

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I live on a farm that raises beef and sheep, I eat plenty of both, and I worked with ruminate nutritionists some time ago..... so what follows is based on some science and experience.

1. What differentiates prime, choice, good , etc grades of meat is primarily fat content. The fact that the price of these grades decreases suggests that most folks find prime more palatable than choice, etc down the line. Ditto for the grades of sheep. I get substantially more for a prime grade lamb than one graded lower. A minority of persons add current health theories to the what-they-will-pay equation and their peak of desirability may peak at something lower grade than prime. But the purchase decisions of this population has not affected the price these grades bring at market, ie prime still commands a higher price because most people perceive it is better.

2. Animals get energy and protein from what they eat. It is no less healthy or "natural" for a ruminant to eat corn and soybean meal than it is for them to eat grass, grass seeds, honeysuckle leaves , acorns, etc. provided that the animal has the right mix of roughage and other stuff ruminants need to make things work. We showed conclusively on the project I was on that any source of protein was largely equivalent. What actually gets fed depends upon the cheapest source, which could be fish meal, soybean or other seed meal, alfalfa, clover, etc.

I worked at feed lots in TX and CO and it is true that the diets on these lots is designed to put weight on the animal as fast as possible, ie they are high in easily digestible carbohydrate. The diet is probably unsustainable for an animal long term, but they are only on this diet a few months before they are killed, so whether they might have heart trouble after 4 years is not an issue. In addition to food the animals are vaccinated, may be given hormones and mineral and other supplements. I have no opinion on whether these supplements are harmful to people or not.

I know for a fact that I can not produce a prime or even a choice lamb on my pasture without supplementing its diet with additional carbohydrate(corn in my case) and protein(soy bean meal) and some minerals (my farm is deficient in selenium). These supplements don't exceed my definition of a natural ruminant diet. I keep some lambs for breeding stock and they live to ripe old ages so I can not say that their diet is unhealthy, nor is it any more unnatural than me eating Mexican food while living in E. TN.

Bottom line-you analogy of FAS lumber to dyed lumber is not valid for a nutritionally supplemented animal vs one barely staying alive on my winter pasture. Gotta go, as it is time to give the pregnant ewes their pound of corn, soybean pellets and a bit of mineral salt. Given the enthusiasm with which they eat it, they think it is sufficiently natural.