Another OT Furnace Question
Joe Pack
>My natural gas furnace will not stay lit. The pilot comes on and I can hear the ignitor trying to light the burner, but the gas valve does not always allow gas to flow. When the gas valve does allow gas to flow, the burner will stay on anywhere from 15 seconds to 2 minutes, then go off again.
This has been an intermittent problem for going on 5 winters. I have had a service person here at least twice each winter, and sometimes as many as 6 times, for 5 years (2 different companies, since one went out of business). Almost every time they come, they go through their checks and almost never find anything major. Many times, by the time they get here, the problem has corrected itself.
They always check the obvious...the ceramic sensor (i.e., thermocouple) that senses the presence of a pilot light. Sometimes it has been cleaned and the furnace works for some time. The last time, early in this heating season, the sensor was found to be faulty (an ohmeter test) and was replaced. The furnace immediately worked, with no trouble until 3 days ago.
To my eye, this ceramic sensor is fine...no corrosion or buildup on the tip. Still, the furnace cycles through trying to start (regular clicking of the ignitor), sometimes firing and going off in a couple of minutes, sometimes not starting at all. Resetting the furnace by turning the power off to the furnace, then back on after one minute (as suggested by the tech at 10:00 p.m.tonight) did allow the furnace to fire up immediately after turning the power back on, but it went off a couple of minutes later.
As I sit here writing this, I can occasionally hear the furnace clicking, trying to start, and sometimes "grinding" like someone is missing a shift in a miniature toy car transmission. This sound is not terribly loud, nor does it last for more than a second or so, but I don't think it is really supposed to be doing that.
In addition to the ceramic sensor, I had a small vacuum diaphragm (about 3 1/2" in diameter, 1 inch thick) replaced about 2 years ago. The tech didn't think it was really bad, but could think of nothing else since everything else tested out okay while he was here. Of course, when he replaced the diaphragm, the furnace fired up and worked okay for several days before acting up again. I don't fault him...the furnace worked after he replaced the part.
The tech is coming again on Monday (would have been overtime...a $120 service call plus parts on Sunday). Fortunately, my electric heat pump is keeping the house fairly warm, but, in sub-zero temperatures, running the heat pump is not my idea of economy. It will do until the tech gets here for a $60 service call on Monday.
The furnace has worked fine all winter, at least until now. Now it is acting up just like in past years. I need help, and two reputable, experienced techs have not been able to pinpoint any definitive problem.
The bottom line...does anybody here have any idea what might possibly be out of kilter?



