Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Another OT Furnace Question

Posts

Another OT Furnace Question

#1

Another OT Furnace Question

Joe Pack

>My natural gas furnace will not stay lit. The pilot comes on and I can hear the ignitor trying to light the burner, but the gas valve does not always allow gas to flow. When the gas valve does allow gas to flow, the burner will stay on anywhere from 15 seconds to 2 minutes, then go off again.

This has been an intermittent problem for going on 5 winters. I have had a service person here at least twice each winter, and sometimes as many as 6 times, for 5 years (2 different companies, since one went out of business). Almost every time they come, they go through their checks and almost never find anything major. Many times, by the time they get here, the problem has corrected itself.

They always check the obvious...the ceramic sensor (i.e., thermocouple) that senses the presence of a pilot light. Sometimes it has been cleaned and the furnace works for some time. The last time, early in this heating season, the sensor was found to be faulty (an ohmeter test) and was replaced. The furnace immediately worked, with no trouble until 3 days ago.

To my eye, this ceramic sensor is fine...no corrosion or buildup on the tip. Still, the furnace cycles through trying to start (regular clicking of the ignitor), sometimes firing and going off in a couple of minutes, sometimes not starting at all. Resetting the furnace by turning the power off to the furnace, then back on after one minute (as suggested by the tech at 10:00 p.m.tonight) did allow the furnace to fire up immediately after turning the power back on, but it went off a couple of minutes later.

As I sit here writing this, I can occasionally hear the furnace clicking, trying to start, and sometimes "grinding" like someone is missing a shift in a miniature toy car transmission. This sound is not terribly loud, nor does it last for more than a second or so, but I don't think it is really supposed to be doing that.

In addition to the ceramic sensor, I had a small vacuum diaphragm (about 3 1/2" in diameter, 1 inch thick) replaced about 2 years ago. The tech didn't think it was really bad, but could think of nothing else since everything else tested out okay while he was here. Of course, when he replaced the diaphragm, the furnace fired up and worked okay for several days before acting up again. I don't fault him...the furnace worked after he replaced the part.

The tech is coming again on Monday (would have been overtime...a $120 service call plus parts on Sunday). Fortunately, my electric heat pump is keeping the house fairly warm, but, in sub-zero temperatures, running the heat pump is not my idea of economy. It will do until the tech gets here for a $60 service call on Monday.

The furnace has worked fine all winter, at least until now. Now it is acting up just like in past years. I need help, and two reputable, experienced techs have not been able to pinpoint any definitive problem.

The bottom line...does anybody here have any idea what might possibly be out of kilter?

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#2

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

Ray SW Ohio

>How old is the furnace? Maybe its time for a new one. Those service calls add up.

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#3

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

Barry Irby

>Joe, I'm finding your statement to be confusing. You say:

"My natural gas furnace will not stay lit. The pilot comes on and I can hear the ignitor trying to light the burner, but the gas valve does not always allow gas to flow. When the gas valve does allow gas to flow, the burner will stay on anywhere from 15 seconds to 2 minutes, then go off again."

Do you have a standing pilot that is supposed to stay lit all the time? The newer furnaces I am familiar with don't have a standing pilot, they have either a piezo igniter or a glow plate. You can hear the piezo ones that make a snapping sound as they create a spark. The ones with the glow plug or plate do not make any noise. What they do is heat up a plate until it glow orange or nearly read hot and then use that to ignite the gas.

Come to think of it, I have not watched one with the piezo lighter in a long time. Do they light a pilot light first and then light the main burner?

Actually, it sounds to me like one of several things. If your furnace is controlled by a logic board, perhaps the board has gone bad.

The other thing that comes to mind is maybe your gas is either wet or contaminated. I had a house on a system once that had gotten a lot of water into the lines during the construction of the system. The furnace would not stay lit. The gas company came and removed the regulator and blew out and enormous amount of what appears to be steam (water vapor). Later they did it again, but there was much less the second time. After that, no more trouble.

My cousin had a problem with her propane system and she found water in the regulator (a few drops). Blew it out and the problem went away.

Natural Gas systems operate under such low pressure (about 5 psi)that water will leak in about as readily as the gas leaks out. In older systems with pipes buried fairly deep, its not uncommon. I would suggest you ask your gas company to check your gas supply.

Also, there should be "drip legs" on your gas piping. They look like short pieces of pipe hanging straight down with a cap on the bottom. (AS if the installer did not have an elbow with him, so he used a Tee and put a short nipple and cap in the bottom of the tee. They are there to collect crud and water out of the gas system. Some people claim they are "Old school" and useless. Some newer systems do not require them. If you have them, might not be bad to have the gas company remove them and check them for water and debris. If there is anything in them, I would be suspicious. If you don't have them, might install one just ahead of the furnace.

I think the system can tolerate a very small amount of water. It may blow right through the burners and be converted to steam, but if there is more than a drop or two it can shut the system down.

Good luck. Let us know what happens.

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#4

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

Ed Wozniak, Buffalo, NY

>Your boiler may have a flame sensor. This is a gizmo that can tell if your main burner has ignited. If your boiler has a failure such that gas is being supplied to the main burner but it is not burning it is important to shut the gas off. A failure in this system would produce the symptoms of pilot coming on, main burners igniting but then shutting down after a several seconds.

Your boiler may also have a power vent. Before the pilot is lit the draft fan is turned on. There is a pressure switch in the exhaust vent that will not allow the pilot to be lit until it determines that the draft fan is producing the proper pressure in the vent. This system failing could produce some of the symptoms you are describing.

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#5

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

Joe Pack

>Some good points, Barry. Thanks for the help.

The pilot is not an "always on." When the thermostat calls for heat, the pilot comes on, the flame touching the metal contact on the ceramic sensor. When everything is working properly, the pilot is on for 3 - 5 seconds, the system tells the gas valve that a pilot is present, I hear several clicks from the ignitor and then the burner fires. When the intermittent problem is present, the pilot comes on, there is the clicking when the ignitor is working, but no gas is delivered and the burner does not come on. The system will recycle after 30 seconds or so, trying to ignite the burner.

I babysat the system until 2:00 a.m. last night, just to see what was actually happening over a long period of time. A good number of times the burner fired, burned for a few minutes, then went off. Almost immediately the system recycled and tried to fire the burner. It took several attempts for the burner to fire. I finally went to bed, noting that the thermostat was calling for 70 degrees, but the actual temp was 67 degrees. This morning the thermostat was still set calling for 70 degrees and the actual temp was 70 degrees. Evidently the burner was working more often.

Just before I sat down to write this, I checked the furnace. The burner was on when I walked over to it, but went off while I was standing there. The system recycled in a few seconds and the burner reignited. It was still burning when I walked away a couple of minutes later. While I have been sitting here writing, it has reignited twice.

While I can't rule out bad gas, the line does have the suggested drip relief areas, and my gas water heater on the same main does not have this problem.

The furnace is about 15 years old, but, according to both companies I have used, there is no real need to replace it. I had considered doing so for energy purposes last summer, so I checked up on all the specs. It is a 92% efficiency furnace according to the info I got from the manufacturer (Armstrong) last summer (I was thinking efficiency when I bought it...ahead of my time, I guess). With everything else being in good condition according to the tech folks, I am trying to rule in or out possible sources of the ignition problem.

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#6

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

Joe Pack

>Thanks Ed.

I will ask the tech about the draft fan. I don't know that information.

My impression is that there is something in the system that is telling the burner to not come on or to shut down - I just don't know what that is, and the techs don't find anything wrong when they check it. Sort of like the car that grinds and clatters all the time except when the mechanic is standing there.

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#7

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>Replace the thermosat! This is not a cure all but they can cause really strange behavior and they are not expensive.

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#8

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Joe, here�s my shot at a diagnosis.

Addy protocol: I am not an electrician, or plumber or heating tech, (nor do I play one on TV)

If the furnace has electronic controls, my guess is an intermittent connection caused by a cold solder joint on one of the physically larger components on the control PC board. It is probably on the terminals associated with the circuitry that opens the gas valve for the burner, sometimes the contact makes enough to arc the cold joint closed and pull in the valve solenoid, other times it remains open. (make sure all the screw terminal connections to all of the associated controls and relays are tight too).

If the main control board that supplies current to the gas valve has not been replaced, that is where you should look.

I design embedded systems for a living, so I am comfortable pulling this type of control apart and have found that many times, reworking the cold solder joint will cure the problem, but I don�t recommend this to anyone not familiar with this sort of work.

Good luck with getting this fixed, and let us know the final �fix�.

Bob

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#9

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

Ed Wozniak, Buffalo, NY

>Once you get it all figured out I hope you let us know what the problem turned out to be.

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#10

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

doug Haller

>I agree with Dan . I had the same problem. I wanted to go with programable thermostat any so I changed out the old(15 year old) thermostat and it is working fine now. I think the thermostat was shutting down furnace with bad conection on the points in thermostat.

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#11

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

Tony - Memphis

>Im an ME, but I work with a bunch of EE's. When my furnace at our old house took a lightning hit (took out the furnace, modem, and the garage door opener), I brought it to work for them to look at. We got several things fixed, but the one issue was the timer chip (555 I think?). The unit would turn on and run fine, but never shut off the fan after cool down - no timer! It was (is) a very common chip..but nobody had any in stock. To make a long story short, the local AC supply house won't sell to individuals (racket!), but the ac repair guy took my money and sent me to pick up the new card. Silly game, but we were warm that day. It was cold too! oddly enough, the new card had built in fuses.

Tony

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#12

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

Pete in Holland, MI

>Most furnaces these days have a LED on the circut board. When the furnace fails to fire up, this LED will blink in a sequence. Check the owner's manual to see what the blinking code indicates, and start there. Furnaces go thru a fire-up sequence. When one step is not satisfied, they are programmed not to continue for safety reasons.

Good luck !

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#13

Count me in as well

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I discovered a problem this way too.

You can always disconnect the thermostat and then turn on the furnace with the wires, they are 24V low voltage... but there are 4 or 5 wires and you must know which wires do what. It's easier to just get a plain/jane thermostat and use that for testing/troubleshooting.

My furnace has a standing pilot light (I light it in the fall and it stays lit all winter) but there still is a loudish clicking sound which is the relays, not a piezzo.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#14

Too old; no LEDs, BUT...

Joe Pack

>

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#15

So, the tech said...

Joe Pack

>Just like I figured...the tech arrived around noon, checked everything out and found.......NOTHING WRONG! All the electronics checked out fine. The furnace came on every time, perfect in every way. So, he put his equipment away and started to put the access door back on when it happened................................

The burner actually went off while he was watching it! And came back on a few seconds later. And went out a minute later. And reignited 30 seconds later..... He actually could see it and check it out while the gremlins were still visiting.

What he found was a poorly draining condensate line. The line has a "U" bend in it by design, and is supposed to drain out when the condensate level gets too high. Evidently 'creepy crud' had been building up for some time, enough so that when the furnace ran too frequently, as in cold weather, more condensate ran in than was running out. As the condensate level built up, so did the pressure in the line. When the pressure got too great, a pressure switch was cutting off the burner to prevent possible exhaust problems. He cleaned the line and got a full flow, eliminating the pressure backup. Since then, the furnace has worked fine.

But it worked fine after all the other trips out also. The jury is still out, but my fingers are crossed that this is 'the' fix. I'll let you know if it is not.

If you have a high efficiency furnace with a condensate drain line, check it! It only takes a couple of minutes to take off the hose and blow it out. And be sure to blow out the PVC drain line running from the furnace to the floor drain. A clog there is as serious as a clog in the clear tubing.

Thanks for all the ideas. Hope someone benefits from my problem.

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#16

Be Alert, possible danger....

Barry Irby

>Condensate drains develop clogs that are related to some sort of biological Crud. Some of them have been known to have the germs that cause Legionnaire's Disease. (One of the Early cases was associated with a group of Legionnaires that got sick (Died?)while staying at a hotel where the AC system's condensate drain spritzed them with infected water.) So, don't mess with that apparently harmless water. This is probably a very remote possibility, but why chance it? If the problem returns, you might ask your Tech to install a Chlorination Port which is just a Tee in the line with a stand pipe that allows you to pour in a little bleach or drop in a chlorine tablet one a month. My limited experience is that once you have it, it reoccurs.

Re: Another OT Furnace Question

#17

Re: Be Alert, possible danger....

Joe Pack

>Thanks Barry.

There is an open T at the top of the line where liquid could be added...sort of like an access point to the U bend in the clear tubing. Would I be wise to drop in a few drops of bleach from time to time?