Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Squeaky Floor

Posts

Squeaky Floor

#1

Squeaky Floor

John T

>OK, I'm getting ready to lay hardwood floor in my sons bedroom. There are several squeaky spots that have been driving us nuts since we bought the house, and now that the carpet is gone, here's my chance to fix it.

I drove dozens of 2" deck screws into the subflooring, in the spots where the squeaks are, and most have gone away, but there's still a large, noisy area, right where you're most likely to walk in the room...

I can access the beams under the room from the basement, but the builders used adhesive as well as nails to lay the original subfloor, so I don't see any way of driving a wedge or shim under the offending areas.

Any other ideas (short of lifting the subfloor and starting over)??

Hoping to start laying floor tomorrow, but I sure would like to do it on a quiet subfloor...

Thanks in advance.

-John-

Re: Squeaky Floor

#2

Re: Squeaky Floor

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>BTDT

Use Bigger screws [#10 sq. drives] and move along the joists every 6". The squeeks are caused by the sub moving up and down on the old nails, so shimming from underneath is largely a waste of time.

For finished hardwood or carpeted floors there's a great system called "Squeek-no-mor" that I have used a number of times. Check out McFeely's [dot-com] for options.

Re: Squeaky Floor

#3

Re: Squeaky Floor

GalenV

>I would have used longer screws as well more like 2 3/4" or 3" as better chance of pulling subfloor down to joist.

What is your subfloor and is there any water "accidents" that may be delamination plywood or swollen chipboard and noise is from that.

I have seen one joist not setting solid on the sil so the whole joist moved.

If this is more midspan maybe the joist are weak and twisting (flex)

You might try cross bracing between joist or just a solid deep block that you can also add more screws from top if underlayment is sagging or bulged.

Just throwing out ideas.

Galen

Re: Squeaky Floor

#4

Re: Squeaky Floor

Justin Szeliga

>Also look for improperly nailed joist hangers in the floor system, they can cause some loud, hard to pin down & fix squeeks.

Sometimes the plywood edges can make noise if they can move against each other, also nails that are against the joist rather than in it.

As far as the use of adhesive previously, you're looking for spots where they missed the glue & nailing so you should be able to slip a shim & some glue in there.

Peace

Justin

Re: Squeaky Floor

#5

Try this....

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>TO cure a squeak in a floor you need to use screws with threaded ends, but smooth shanks on the upper portion so they will pull the flooring down. Screws with threads the full length will not do this unless you drill a clearance hole through the subfloor and not into the joist.

If there is a seam in the plywood right where the squeak occurs, put a thin blade in your skill saw and set the blade to cut about 3/4" or slightly less deep than the thickness of the floor. Saw along that joint line creating a small gap. Make a short cut say 5-6" long to start an make it longer if you don't cure the squeak with the first cut. If you don't cut all the way through the flooring you can fill the gap with caulk or adhesive once the squeak is eliminated

If there is no seam, look for a nail in the offending area that was slightly off line with the joist below so that it sticks out the side of the joist.

Lee

Re: Squeaky Floor

#6

Thanks, All

John T

>Thanks for the responses -

I will try longer and larger screws tomorrow - soon as the local hardware store opens.

The squeaks are mostly along an inside wall of the room, and there are no missed nails, or gaps in the adhesive that I can see from underneath the joists. This is all 3/4 tongue and groove plywood underlayment, with no water damage or other injury (except for the part I had to replace due to cat pee - as it happens, this was the one spot on the floor that DIDN'T squeak..... And I made sure the repair is screwed and glued well enough that it's not gonna squeak either!)

Hopefully, the longer and larger screwss will fix the problem. If not, then I'll at least have an early warning system for when my son becomes a teenager, and is trying to sneak in after curfew....

Thanks again for the help!

-John-

Re: Squeaky Floor

#7

Re: Try this....

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>You are getting some good advice. I suspect that if it was glued to the joist, that the squeaks may be between joist. If the sub-floor got wet during construction, it could have bowed down, then as stated above, the underlayment may be bridging across that span, but flexing when it is walked on.

If you can get under that spot while someone above makes the squeak, you should be able to troubleshoot exactly. Maybe you can add a 2 X 4 bridge block, to push up tight, and get a good bite with the new screws down from above, pulling it all tight together.

Re: Squeaky Floor

#8

Two more possibilities......

Barry Irby

>Good advice so far. For something to squeak, something is moving and rubbing on something else. Keep that in mind.

Two things not mentioned.

Do you have bridging or "X" braces in the middle of the span? When I was building, we used to put the metal strap version of it in the middle of the span. One floor had a horrible loud piecing squeak. We tried screws and everything we could from the top side. Turned out the bridging pieces were rubbing on each other. Tapped them apart with a hammer and no more trouble.

The other thing that came to mind is you mentioned and interior wall. Is the floor flexing under the wall? Walls are quite rigid after the drywall is installed. Perhaps the floor is moving and the wall is not. You Amy be able to drive some screws up from the bottom into the bottom plate of the wall.

Re: Squeaky Floor

#9

Re: Two more possibilities......

George Koch

>John, I agree with Barry on both the bridging and the interior wall bottom plate. Sometimes that plate doesn't get secured enough. Check the subfloor underneath the wall for the nails coming through. Another spot that sometimes develope squeeks is where the joists set on the bearing beam, especially if they they join at that point. Hope you find it! George

Re: Squeaky Floor

#10

Thanks!..

John T

>I've driven a few dozen more screws (3 inch, #10) and its really not cutting down on the squeaks.

I was wondering about the plate where the wall meets the subflooring as the next likely place. I'll try driving some screws up into there.

There are metal X braces under the floor, but I whacked at them with a hammer yesterday - didn't knwo what they were for, but thouoght they might be part of the problem - didn't seem to do much for the sqeak, but I felt better....

Thanks to all for your help.

-John-

Re: Squeaky Floor

#11

Re: Thanks!..

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>John, I had forgotten that you made a connection with the wall. Often, a homeowner will make changes after the floors are framed, which might move them off of the joist which were prepared to carry their weight, and move it out over a span in the deck. Bending down on one side would lift on the other side. Make sure the wall is on top of the joist if it runs parallel.

Do you have someone who can be above making the squeak while you are down under. Sometime it takes feeling the vibrations with the hands. While the other person is making it squeak, you should be feeling for vibrations, and pushing against suspected things to make it stop.

Re: Squeaky Floor

#12

Squeaks are GONE

John T

>Many thanks to all who replied -

Finally killed the sqeaks - 2 screws up from below into the floor plate of the interior wall - complete silence!!!

Now, on to laying the floor....

Thanks again.

-John-

Re: Squeaky Floor

#13

GREAT!!!!!, But.....

Barry Irby

>I would not trust just two screws. I would put in about ten just to be sure over the long term.

Gotta love it when a plan comes together.