Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Question about tool batteries

Posts

Question about tool batteries

#1

Question about tool batteries

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I have a number of cordless drills, Makita, Ryobi and Dewalt. The bateries are all pretty much less than stellar compared to new, however, they still take a charge. Some are as old as ten years.

Here's my question. Do batteries start a decline from the day they're manufactured? Or do they actually have to be used in order to deteriorate? I don't use mine continuously, which may explain why some of the batteries are old but still function. I do have an old Makita though that has to be at least 25 years old and I'm on my third replacement battery for it.

If you buy a new factory OEM blister-pack battery on ebay for instance, if it's already a few years old but still unused, will it perform as well as a newly manufactured battery?

Or am I just being way too frugal (cheap)?

Re: Question about tool batteries

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Question about tool batteries

Dale Lenz

>It has been my understanding, that most batteries have a shelf live, ballpark 5 years. I've purchased some "new" batteries off of EBay and they did not last very long, 2 year or so, then again I�ve had good luck for �eBay� batteries. So I buy �new� batteries now, I do shop, first. Thinking about going back to corded tools, 50 buck every few years does not make a lot of sense to me for shop work, but cordless tool sure are convenience. The price we pay for handiness.

Re: Question about tool batteries

#3

JL

Re: Question about tool batteries

JL

>Basically a battery (or set of batteries) is a slow chemical reaction. You are going from a charged state to a discharged state when you use the battery. You are going from a discharged state to a charged state when you charge it.

Having said that - the chemical reaction is never 100%. Each time you discharge or use a charge, all of the reaction may not take place. Likewise for charging - you may not pump in enough energy to "flip" all of the chemicals into a charged state (hence the possibility of zapping some types of batteries to "rejuvenate" them).

As an example take the rule of 99%. The first type you recharge the battery, you get it to 99% of capacity. The next time you get it to 99% of that 99% (or ~98%). So by the time you've charged it several times you might be at 93% (or less). That's assuming you are getting a 99% efficiency when recharging. Some chemical reactions are less efficient than 99%.

My $0.02.

Re: Question about tool batteries

#4

batteries

Philip Duffy

>Tim, You can take batter powered tools to a place called " Batteries Plus " - -no relation to me - -and others, and get the tool battery pack to be better than new! I have taken a few to my local place and they will refuse to work on junk but will do a superb job on quality tools. Saves money, for sure, over the cost of a new tool. Phil

Re: Question about tool batteries

#5

Rebuild'em

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>There are several battery rebuilders [Google "Primecell" or "voltman batteries" for two - there are more] on the net that do a good job of renovating old packs. They will also upgrade your packs for more capacity [for a bit more $] if you choose.

So long as your packs come apart with screws [Dewalt's 12v used to be solvent welded] it's also pretty easy to rebuild your own with a soldering gun and some flux-core electronics solder. Any number of clic/brick e-stores like Radio Shack sell NiCad cells in various grades. The basic building block is the 1.5 volt NiCad cell. Just remember to dispose of the old cells properly. Depending on your charger, some packs can also be upgraded to NiMh cells. Since Lithium packs need a special charger [with a cooling fan and thermostat feedback circuitry], that upgrade would not be available to you.

I've had several packs done at Primecell. Even with freight I saved about $15 per pack over buying new ones, and got stronger/longer lasting packs than new ones in the big box rack. Several contractor friends use rebuilders all the time and swear by them. They may also send 50 packs in at a time for even better prices.

Re: Question about tool batteries

#6

Re: Question about tool batteries

A Wright

>I needed to replace some 18v Dewalt batteries a couple of weeks ago in a drill that was about 8 years old, and after looking around I found that the going price for a pair of 18v "XRP" batteries was $120.

I was at Lowes the next day and found an 18V drill kit on close out for $130 (display with a few scuffs), so I bought it instead. I decided that getting an extra drill and charger was worth $10.

Re: Question about tool batteries

#7

Rebuild Costs

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Primecell charges $48.00 per pack to rebuild 18 volt to 2400mah NiCad, Voltman is a bit less and builds to 2100.

If you want the serious upgrade to NiMH chemistry, they'll change $72 and $80 respectively for 9 to 18 volt packs.

Other point is you get stronger packs than those that come with a new tool.

No connection. Just very satisfied customer.