Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Reported wood working accidents (long)

Posts

Reported wood working accidents (long)

#1

Reported wood working accidents (long)

mdclor

>Wood Centralians,

This may have already been suggested, so I apologize if it is a duplicate. Or, it may already be on the web and I am not aware of it.

Since I have been reading Badger Pond and Wood Central, many accidents have been self reported with follow up suggestions from the injured party and cognoscenti for avoiding future recurrences. It occurred to me that there is a wealth of information here that might be categorized by guilty tool type; table saw, band saw, router, etc that could be made available to novices and experienced wood workers alike as a resource or refresher before using a particular tool. I think this would be a great service to the entire wood working community.

There would need to be the initial research to glean all the reported accidents and suggested safety measures (from Wood Central and other sites, if any exist ;)), then the categorizing, editing, maintenance and updating, etc.

Not to mention the collection and statement of the required/prudent legal disclaimers. Maybe it would need to be a separate site or a blog so Ellis would not have any liability. I am not a lawyer, so I don't profess to know anything about these issues other than that they may exist.

All in all, this would be a large project should anyone be willing to dedicate their time and efforts. The potential candidates should be experienced wood workers, have the available time (not working one or more jobs), be able to present the information in a clear and concise manner, have a sense of literary style and keep the reports "light" so potential wood workers aren't scared away from a great hobby before they get started. In short, someone like Rod Peterson or John Jordan, although I know that both of these gentleman have many other responsibilities and are already contributing more than their fair share. There must be potential candidates that others might suggest.

Anyhow, I think this would be a great project for the right person and will look forward to the responses from the Community.

Thanks for your consideration,

Merle

P.S. I am not a qualified candidate for a many of reasons. I am not in the running nor do I intend to run...oh, never mind, that season is behind us now for at least 2 years, hopefully!

Re: Reported wood working accidents (long)

#2

Interesting idea

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I'd support a collection of safety-related postings, but we are not at liberty to lift posts from other sites for publication here. That said, with all the years of messages in our archives, I have no doubt that we can find a pretty exhaustive collection of anecdote and wisdom on this topic. As you say, we'd need a researcher to do the searching. Volunteers are welcome.

Ellis

Re: Reported wood working accidents (long)

#3

The Law of Unintended Consequences

Curly Smith

>suggests that this is not a good idea. If you organize the woodworking accidents, and near misses, contained in the archives then you provide easy fodder for an over-reaching regulatory agency. The accidents as presently contained in the archives still greatly understate the incidence rate since people seldom post �I didn�t cut off my thumb today�. Even so, the accident rate in comparison to the total posts is low. However, once you remove all other posts, and merely highlight the casualties, then woodworking will be seen as extremely dangerous and in dire need of both regulation and safety upgrades. I�ve often read that dado blades are outlawed in Europe because they�re �too dangerous� but I�ve never read a satisfactory explanation on how that determination was made. Unless you want such decisions made here, and the most logical would be to require Saw Stop devises on every saw, then you should reflect on how information can be used, and especially misused, for other purposes.

On the other hand, a section on �Safe Methods of Work� might accomplish the desired results but it carries its own risks of legal liability.

Re: Reported wood working accidents (long)

#4

JL

It's dumb of me, but I volunteer.

JL

>I'll comb through the archives on the Messages and Turning Boards (we all know that hand tool users don't have accidents or problems :)).

If anyone would care to email me any TRUE stories and their fixes, I will compile them also.

Re: Reported wood working accidents (long)

#5

Re: The Law of Unintended Consequences

Well just hurry up....

>I suppose that one could live one's life being overly cautious. Then one could neither draw from, or contribute to, the world around. What a crock!!!

Selling Band-Aids could lead us to believe that life in general is too dangerous.

NOW I FEEL BETTER!!!!

Bill

Re: Reported wood working accidents (long)

#6

Re: The Law of Unintended Consequences

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>My mind is not as sharp as it once was, but did'nt the Saw Stop inventor try to get his invention legislated into law as required equipment on table saws. When this failed, he went on to develop his own saw line.

Re: Reported wood working accidents (long)

#7

Re: The Law of Unintended Consequences

Fred Davis

>Curley ,

I agree with you , that is a well thought out possible consequence, insurance companies antennae would rise like the tide .

I would like any discussion of mishaps in the shop to be called what they are " carelessness " not "acts of God" and especially not "accidents"

Cutting yourself or losing a digit is carelessness most often caused by inattention on your part.

Accidents are beyond your control, in most cases caused by others and therefore not anticipated by your own good methods of work.

So it seems to me.

FredD

Re: Reported wood working accidents (long)

#8

Re: The Law of Unintended Consequences

mdclor

>If I understand you correctly, you are saying that no good deed goes unpunished. I suppose there is truth to the statement and I like your suggestion of offering safe procedures as a positive way to accomplish the ultimate goal.

Merle

Re: Reported wood working accidents (long)

#9

Re: The Law of Unintended Consequences

mdclor

>Fred,

I think many adverse events are due to carelessness, but I also know that many are due to a lack of knowledge. For example, not knowing that kick back can result from having the trailing edge rotate into the blade on a table saw or knowing that a climb cut with a router requires more caution than a regular cut.

Basically, I am suggesting a clear, concise list of the various "gotcha's" associated with the major tools that a neophyte might experience would be of great value.

Merle

Re: Reported wood working accidents (long)

#10

Re: It's dumb of me, but I volunteer.

mdclor

>JL,

Thank you for agreeing to take on this project. I am excited that someone other than me sees value in the undertaking and is willing to donate his time and efforts to benefit the wood working community. Please email me if you need any assistance.

I know that the manufacturers all include safety precautions in their various operating manuals, but how many of us actually read them and how relevant are they? I seem to recall reading about electrical connections for a tailless tool. That kind absurdity devalues the good suggestions that may follow.

The value of this project is that it would be relevant from people actually using the tools rather than from lawyers that may not have even seen the tool. I am not bashing lawyers and manufacturers need to be "prudent" to protect them selves from litigation, but somehow something gets lost in the translation.

Again, thank you,

Merle

Re: Reported wood working accidents (long)

#11

Re: The Law of Unintended Consequences

Fred Davis

>However you wish to address it, adverse event , act of God , sh-- happens or it just wasn't my day , this proposed "gotcha list" would really be impressive and educational accompanied by "clear consise" photos of the damage.

I have taken many Carpenters and some Laboreres to the Hospital , at least one with a section of subfloor still nailed to his foot, never forgot any of them.

The guy that showed me what his right hand looked like ,after he had a shaper turn on while changing knives years before, made me more safety concious then I would have probably been , had I not seen his hand.

FredD